US Paid Insurers Billions for Civilian Contractor Injuries in War Zones; Government Says System Ripe for Fraud

American taxpayers have paid nearly $5 billion over the past decade to private insurance companies through an obscure federal program designed to cover civilian contractors injured or killed in war zones, a ProPublica investigation found.

The federal workers’ compensation program, intended as a safety net for workers supporting military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, has instead become a financial windfall for a handful of major insurers. According to an internal Labor Department memo obtained by ProPublica, the system has been described from within the government as “ripe for potential fraud or, at the very least, gamesmanship for profit.”

Nobody knows the exact amount of misspent money. Chris Godfrey, the official who oversaw the program under the Biden administration, estimated that between $100 million and $150 million is wasted annually.

Under the Defense Base Act and the War Hazards Compensation Act, contractors purchase private insurance funded by the U.S. government. If an employee suffers an ordinary workplace accident, the insurer covers the cost. But if the injury or death results from enemy hostilities, the federal government reimburses the insurance company in full and tacks on a handling fee.

Investigators found that the Labor Department lacks the technology, staffing, and standards to adequately police these reimbursement requests. The agency’s computer system cannot issue fines, and federal examiners until recently relied on decades-old CD-ROM technology. Former Labor officials admitted that the agency simply lacked the capacity to investigate claims thoroughly.

US Paid Insurers Billions for Civilian Contractor Injuries in War Zones; Government Says System Ripe for Fraud
Photo: navytimes.com

“You can’t look under the covers. You just had to pay,” said one former senior manager at the agency.

Top Beneficiaries of the War Hazards Program

Insurance Company Total Reimbursed
American International Group (AIG) More than $1 billion
CNA Financial Corp. More than $740 million
Starr Insurance More than $730 million
Allied World More than $350 million

The system experienced a massive surge in payouts following a 2018 policy change. Prompted by industry lobbying, Labor Department officials loosened the rules for documenting post-traumatic stress disorder cases. Bulletin 18-03 removed the requirement for evidence tying a worker’s PTSD to a specific incident, requiring only that the employee was present in an area attacked by insurgents.

Annual payments subsequently soared from $242 million in 2018 to nearly $1 billion through September 2026, according to records analyzed by Navy Times. By 2024, psychological injuries accounted for 88% of all reimbursements.

Insurers capitalized on the lower evidentiary bar by adopting a churn strategy. Rather than spending money on protracted litigation for disputed claims, companies quickly settled cases knowing the government would reimburse them, along with a handling fee of up to 15%.

The US paid insurers billions to cover civilians harmed in war. Even the government says the system is ripe for fraud
Photo: primereports.org

Conversely, some insurers fought workers in administrative courts for years before settling, only to turn around and apply for government reimbursement by asserting that the disputed injuries were indeed war-related. Attorneys and former officials said that carriers faced little financial downside.

“If we win, great, and if we lose, War Hazard coverage is assured,” wrote Lawrence Postol, an attorney for AIG, in an email to an opposing lawyer.

Insurers have defended their handling of the program, arguing that they face significant financial burdens due to government delays in processing reimbursements. Starr Insurance said that it has consistently processed claims in compliance with applicable laws and that payment delays amount to an interest-free loan to the government. AIG maintained that it adheres strictly to Department of Labor requirements.

Founded in 1919 by Cornelius Vander Starr in Shanghai, American International Group (AIG) moved its headquarters to New York City in 1939 and grew into a global insurer operating in more than 200 countries and jurisdictions. During the 2008 financial crisis, the company received a $180 billion bailout from the United States Federal Reserve, which took a controlling stake; AIG repaid the government $205 billion by 2012 after a major restructuring.

As claims continue to roll in from decades-old conflicts, experts warn that the long-tail nature of workers’ compensation will keep driving up costs. “There’s way more to come, to be honest,” said Mark Reinhalter, a former Labor Department attorney. “We’ll likely see continuous increases over the next 20 years or so.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Family, Community Mourn Lesedi Mohube, Demand Justice

Naver’s KREAM Expands Into Used Luxury, Trading Cards, Private Label