In a review for BroadwayWorld, critic Marina Collins argues that Village Theatre’s current production of the musical Come From Away falters due to a series of distracting creative choices by director Timothy Douglas.
- The review awards the production a “MEH” rating, citing a sterile grey steel set and unnatural choreography that distract from the emotional core of Irene Sankoff and David Hein’s musical.
- Performances draw mixed reactions, with standout vocals from actors such as Nik Hagen, Anden Leo, and Matthew Kacergis, contrasted against over-the-top characterizations elsewhere.
- The production runs at Village Theatre in Issaquah through December 27 before transferring to Everett for a run from January 2 through 31.
The musical recounts the true events of September 11, 2001, when 38 planes were ordered to land in the tiny Canadian town of Gander, Newfoundland. The influx nearly doubled the population overnight as locals welcomed the stranded passengers, known as the plane people.
The underlying material remains brilliant, but the staging struggles to capture that emotional resonance, BroadwayWorld reported. The critic noted having seen the show before, observing that subsequent productions face a higher bar.
| Location | Start Date | End Date |
|---|---|---|
| Village Theatre, Issaquah | Current | December 27 |
| Village Theatre, Everett | January 2 | January 31 |
Tony Cisek designed a cold, three-level set featuring grey steel beams and concrete stairs. This industrial airport aesthetic contrasts sharply with the warm, rural wood tones typical of other stagings.
Choreography by Nikki Long also drew criticism for performative movements. The cast stretched their arms to signify airplanes and formed circles with hands resting on neighboring performers, which the review described as posturing and silly.
Costuming choices by Christine Tschirgi compounded the visual dampening by dressing the cast in flat greens and browns. When paired with the grey set, the performers blended into the background without any distinct visual pop.
Performances yielded mixed results across the ensemble. Mark Emerson played the mayor and other roles with an over-the-top approach that felt unnatural.
Conversely, Nik Hagen and Anden Leo delivered natural portrayals with standout vocals during the “Prayer” piece. Matthew Kacergis contributed soaring vocals into the rafters.
Bobbi Kotula and Mark Rabe portrayed Diane and Nick with endearing and fun moments as the couple thrown together from opposite ends of the world. Hannah Schuerman played the doting ASPCA worker caring for stranded animals.
Cassie Q Kohl sang the heartbreaking song “Me and the Sky” beautifully as the pilot Beverly, though the review questioned whether she possessed the age and gravitas for an experienced pilot in her 50s. Dee-Dee Darby-Duffin played Hannah, but her vocals lacked the range and power required for her big solo number.
With performance rights now widely available, regional productions are increasing. Another local staging appeared in the area less than a year prior.
Village Theatre was founded in 1979 in Issaquah, Washington, and debuted with How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. Its Village Originals program has launched over 160 new musicals since 1995, including Million Dollar Quartet and Next to Normal, which went on to win the 2010 Pulitzer Prize for Drama.
The theatre was contracted by the City of Everett in 1998 to operate the Everett Performing Arts Center and now serves 20,000 subscribers across both locations.
“Come From Away” performs at Village theater in Issaquah through December 27th before moving to their Everett location running January 2nd through 31st.