A court in Viterbo acquitted a South American woman of stalking charges Wednesday, dismissing allegations that she threatened her ex-husband with a knife and scissors after she took their daughter to London in 2021, Tusciaweb.eu reported.
The ruling by Judge Jacopo Rocchi, delivered with the formula “because the fact does not exist,” closes a case that began with a bitter separation between the woman and a 65-year-old man from the Lake Bolsena area, according to Tusciaweb. The couple married in 2000. The prosecution itself had requested the acquittal.
The allegations and the London move
The husband accused his ex-wife of three main episodes of harassment. He testified that two days before he traveled to London to retrieve their then-seven-year-old daughter in October 2021, she sent him a WhatsApp photo of a knife and threatened, “If you show up, I’ll gut you.” He also cited a 2022 incident where she allegedly brandished scissors in front of the child, and a 2023 shove outside a school witnessed by others.
The daughter returned to Italy with her father in October 2021. The mother followed in May 2022. Shortly after a civil court assigned the marital home to the mother and daughter, the husband filed the criminal complaint that triggered a restraining order barring the woman from approaching within 500 meters of the child.
Defense highlights timing of complaint
Defense attorney Luca Paoletti argued the complaint’s timing was suspicious. “Guarda caso” — just by chance — the denunciation arrived right after the housing assignment, Paoletti told the court. He emphasized that the examining magistrate (gip) had already revoked the restraining order after the guarantee hearing, recognizing the situation’s complexity.
“The gip understood the situation and revoked the measure after the guarantee hearing.”
Legal context and presumption of innocence
The verdict reaffirms the principle enshrined in Article 27 of the Italian Constitution: a person is not considered guilty until a final conviction. The prosecution's decision to seek acquittal alongside the defense highlighted the evidentiary gaps in the stalking charge.
Viterbo, the provincial capital where the trial was heard, has been a papal refuge since the 12th century; Popes Eugene III, Alexander IV, Urban IV, Gregory X and John XXI all resided or were elected within its medieval walls.
The city lies about 80 kilometres north of Rome in the Lazio region, surrounded by the Monti Cimini and Monti Volsini, and its historic centre remains encircled by largely intact 11th- and 12th-century walls. During World War II it suffered over twenty Allied raids that destroyed roughly a third of the urban fabric and caused 1,017 civilian deaths.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2000 | Couple marries |
| 2021 | Mother takes daughter to London; father retrieves child in October |
| May 2022 | Mother returns to Italy |
| 2022 | Alleged scissors threat |
| 2023 | Alleged shove outside school |
| Nov 22, 2026 | Acquittal by Judge Jacopo Rocchi |
The case illustrates how cross-border family disputes can spiral into criminal proceedings, with protective measures imposed and lifted within months. The full acquittal ends the criminal chapter, though the civil separation terms remain in force.