West Virginia Supreme Court Admonishes Judge Sweeney

“Sometimes you just have to take a punch for the kids,” said Ritchie County Judge Tim Sweeney on Friday.

His remark followed a decision by the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia to issue a formal admonishment against him for his unconventional tactics in addressing the state’s child protective services crisis.

The disciplinary action centers on events from last February, when Sweeney ordered leaders from the West Virginia Department of Human Services (DoHS) to his courtroom. He demanded they address a severe shortage of child protective services workers that had left a severely traumatized child languishing in an inappropriate placement.

When the department failed to move the child to a mental health facility in a timely manner, Sweeney—whose district covers Pleasants, Doddridge, Ritchie, and Wirt counties—took the rare step of speaking directly to the media to highlight the systemic failures.

Judicial Ethics and the Boundaries of Advocacy

Chief Justice Haley Bunn wrote in the Supreme Court’s decision that a jurist must follow the Code of Judicial Conduct regardless of how popular a cause is.

“While Judge Sweeney’s conduct happened to concern a matter that elicits universal agreement—the well-being of children—judges who stray so far outside their role such as to violate the Code are not immunized from discipline based on the popularity or success of his misconduct,” the court wrote in its opinion.

The Judicial Investigation Commission had previously flagged Sweeney for speaking publicly about pending cases and for Facebook activity that suggested a bias in favor of law enforcement. While the judge appealed to the Judicial Hearing Board, the board upheld the findings of ethical violations.

The Supreme Court ultimately concluded that by ordering health officials to his courtroom to serve as makeshift caseworkers, Sweeney had improperly influenced the outcome of a case he was presiding over.

The court’s ruling said that the judge created a case by summoning officials and then effectively steered its resolution when he met with then-DoHS Cabinet Secretary Alex Mayer to force a staffing plan. Despite the admonishment, the justices acknowledged that Sweeney’s motivations were not self-promoting or dishonest. He was ordered to pay for the costs of the proceedings as a proportionate sanction.

A Systemic Breakdown in Child Welfare

The crisis in West Virginia’s foster care and protection system has frequently spilled into the courtroom. In the same month Sweeney took action, Kanawha County Judge Maryclaire Akers similarly summoned the DoHS leadership after reports surfaced that children were being housed in hotels and 4-H camps due to a lack of available foster placements.

That case was later dismissed by the Supreme Court due to insufficient evidence, highlighting the complex legal hurdles judges face when attempting to intervene in administrative failures.

The strain on the department is well-documented, with caseworkers often juggling caseloads that exceed 100 children. This high-pressure environment has led to a cyclical failure where children “fall through the cracks,” as Sweeney described during his testimony.

The Mountain State Spotlight, which originally reported on the proceedings, has documented the ongoing tensions between the judiciary and the Department of Human Services regarding the state’s child protective services responsibilities.

Moving Forward Under Scrutiny

Sweeney, who has served without prior disciplinary action, stated on Friday that he respectfully disagreed with the Supreme Court’s opinion but intends to comply with the ruling. He remains steadfast in his assessment of the situation, maintaining that his primary duty was to the children trapped in a broken system.

“Abused and neglected children were helped and shortcomings were addressed,” Sweeney said. “That was and continues to be my goal.”

Photo of author

James Carter Senior News Editor

Senior Editor, News James is an award-winning investigative reporter known for real-time coverage of global events. His leadership ensures Archyde.com’s news desk is fast, reliable, and always committed to the truth.

Deportivo Sarmiento Wins 2026 Southwest Hockey Silver Cup