A woman died in the parking lot of Port Hardy Hospital on Thursday evening after arriving shortly after the facility’s emergency department closed for the night.
Island Health confirmed the death on Friday, stating that care providers and B.C. Emergency Health Services paramedics arrived to provide emergency interventions, the Times Colonist reported.
- The Port Hardy Hospital emergency room has been restricted to 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. operations since January 2023.
- BC Emergency Health Services reported that a paramedic became aware of the patient in need at 5:11 p.m. on Thursday.
- The patient was treated in the parking lot by paramedics before being moved to the hospital’s trauma room, where she could not be resuscitated.
Dr. Alex Nataros, director of the North Island Community Health Centre, said that while he does not know the specific details of the patient, it is his understanding that she was in her 40s and had family in the community. Nataros, who was not at the hospital, said that doctors there took over the patient’s care after initial treatment outside. “Despite the treatment, the woman died very tragically,” Nataros told the Times Colonist. The incident has reignited criticism regarding the ongoing overnight closure of the hospital, which has been in place for nearly four years due to reported staffing shortages.
Nataros, who was suspended by Island Health in 2023 following patient and healthcare worker complaints, described the situation as “reprehensible” and “unacceptable” while speaking to CHEK News. He argued that the facility is poorly managed, alleging there are more managers at the hospital than emergency room nurses.
The B.C. Coroners Service is now investigating the death, and Island Health said it is reviewing the circumstances with B.C. Emergency Health Services. “It would be inappropriate to speculate on any factors that may have contributed” while the review is underway, Island Health stated to the Times Colonist.
Questions Regarding Emergency Care
Questions remain regarding why the patient was not transported to the nearest 24-hour acute-care emergency room in Port McNeill, which is 40 kilometres away. Nataros told CHEK News that a colleague was on-site doing rounds at the 18-bed facility when the event occurred and was left shaken by the outcome. “My colleague is obviously very shaken up that this person died,” said Nataros. He further said that paramedics were performing CPR outside “for a prolonged period of time.”
Regarding the broader impact of the closures, Nataros stated, “It’s a major contributor to mental suffering and physical suffering, and our community is nearly twice as big as Port McNeill, and we have three adjacent First Nations reserves with significant morbidity and significant complications.” He added, “It’s outrageous that we are not the primary emergency room open 24/7 north of Campbell River.”
Physicians Criticize Ongoing Hospital Management Issues
Dr. Alex Nataros contends that the staffing shortages driving these closures represent an organizational failure within Island Health. While the provincial government announced a $45-million modernization and expansion project for the Port Hardy Hospital in March, the facility remains unable to provide 24/7 emergency coverage for the population.
Health officials implemented the daytime-only schedule at Port Hardy Hospital in January 2023 as a management decision to concentrate overnight emergency services at the Port McNeill facility. This consolidation was intended as a temporary measure to address regional staffing shortages affecting multiple hospitals across the north Island.
Despite these efforts, the Port Hardy Hospital emergency department continues to face recruitment and retention challenges in a community that has been historically underserved.

Political Promises and Future Outlook
New provincial leadership, including Minister of State for Rural Issues Anna Kindy and Premier Lorne Doerkson, have previously expressed support for addressing rural health care issues and reversing emergency department closures. The cause of the woman’s death will not be confirmed until an autopsy is completed.