X and xAI Settle South Africa Antitrust Case; No Cash Payout for Publishers

Elon Musk’s X Corp and xAI have settled with South Africa’s Competition Commission, withdrawing appeals to the Competition Tribunal in exchange for binding publisher-support commitments — but, unlike Google and Meta, neither company has put any money on the table for local media.

The deals, announced by the Commission on Wednesday, close out the last outstanding dispute from the Media and Digital Platforms Market Inquiry. X was the only platform that did not reach agreement with the regulator before the inquiry’s final report landed in November 2025, TechCentral reported. Now it has.

But the terms tell a story of their own. Where Google agreed in November 2025 to a support package worth R688-million — including R71-million a year for five years through Google News Showcase — X and xAI have committed only training programmes, workshops and access.

The Commission’s own chief economist, James Hodge, who chaired the inquiry, framed it carefully: “These commitments are an important step in translating the MDPMI final report into practical benefits for South African news publishers.”

Translation from the regulator’s language into plain financial terms: no payout. TechCentral’s headline says it outright — “no payout for publishers.” The xAI undertaking, in particular, does not compensate publishers for content already scraped to train Grok. It shows them how to opt out.

X and xAI Drop Appeals in Settlement

  • X and xAI dropped their Competition Tribunal appeals; in return, the Commission amended X’s remedies and replaced xAI’s mandates with a voluntary undertaking.
  • X must launch a Monetisation Support Programme within six months, run biannual publisher workshops for two years, and provide its paid Premium tier free where publishers need it to qualify.
  • Neither company commits any money to South African media — a sharp contrast with Google’s R688-million package and the training-plus-support deals struck by Meta and TikTok.

What X Actually Promised, and What It Didn’t

Under the settlement, per BusinessTech and TechCentral, X Corp must launch a monetisation-support programme within six months of the effective date, offering South African news organisations biannual workshops on audience analytics, revenue tools and content strategy. Publishers must attend at least one workshop and meet X’s own “rules and integrity criteria” to access the monetisation programmes.

X and xAI Settle South Africa Antitrust Case; No Cash Payout for Publishers
Photo: TechCentral

Here is the catch buried in the detail: “Revenue calculations remain unchanged,” the Commission said, per TechCentral. Publishers earn on the same terms as any other X creator. The Premium tier comes free for two years where needed to qualify; after that, publishers pay for it themselves.

Workshops will be recorded and translated into up to five local languages — but only “subject to sufficient demand,” per MyBroadband’s reporting of the settlement terms. X has also committed to digital literacy programmes for South African adults and children, a requirement carried over from the final report.

The Grok Undertaking: Opt-Out, Not Compensation

The inquiry found that AI chatbots had scraped South African news without agreement or compensation. xAI — now operating as SpaceX Super Intelligence after SpaceX acquired it in February, TechCentral reported — was originally required to train publishers on controlling how their content trains its AI models and informs its answers.

The voluntary undertaking is narrower. xAI will run biannual training sessions over two years, starting within six months of the Commission withdrawing the original remedies, covering Grok user settings and robots.txt — the file websites use to tell crawlers which pages they may visit. The undertaking does not compensate publishers for content already used. It shows them how to say no going forward.

That distinction matters commercially. Section 2 of the settlement, in effect, converts a compensation question into a technical-education one. Publishers who want their content excluded from Grok training get the manual. What they don’t get is back pay.

Who Qualifies, and Who Gets Left Out

The commitments cover South African print, online, radio and video news organisations that primarily report on current affairs or public-interest events, per the Commission. Eligibility is membership-based: organisations must be current members of the Press Council of South Africa or the Broadcasting Complaints Commission of South Africa.

That excludes any South African outlet outside those self-regulatory bodies — a meaningful carve-out in a fragmented media market, though neither the Commission nor the reporting outlets quantify how many organisations fall outside it.

How the Musk Deal Compares With Google, Meta and TikTok

The settlement follows the same remedial template the inquiry applied to Alphabet’s Google and Meta Platforms’ Facebook, both of which reached agreements before the final report. The scale gap is stark.

Platform Financial commitment Programme duration
Google R688-million package, incl. R71-million/year via Google News Showcase Five years (News Showcase component)
Meta Publisher training and support programmes (no cash payout reported) Not specified in reporting
xAI / SpaceX Super Intelligence No money committed; Grok and robots.txt training only Two years

MyBroadband quoted the Commission’s framing of the deal: “Access to revenue-generating tools, onboarding assistance, and training will help qualifying publishers build their revenue opportunities on X and understand controls relevant to the use of their content by AI.”

Read alongside TechCentral’s reporting, the comparison writes itself. The Commission accepted training where it had earlier extracted cash — from Google at least. Whether that reflects X’s weaker negotiating position after losing its appeal route, or the regulator’s willingness to settle for less from the last holdout, is not addressed in the reporting.

The Open Question for Publishers

The settlement converts an adversarial regulatory fight into a two-year clock. X’s commitments and xAI’s training both run for two years; the monetisation programme must be live within six months. After the Premium-tier subsidy lapses, publishers pay their own way on X.

For South African media houses, the practical calculus is now straightforward: attend a workshop, meet X’s integrity criteria, and earn on the platform’s standard creator terms — or use the robots.txt training to block Grok entirely. No money changes hands. That was the deal the last holdout was able to get.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Yaxel Lendeborg Tops TalkBasket.net Rookie Ladder; Cameron Boozer Climbs to No. 2