“It’s obliterated my landscape,” said Emma Valdez Wall, a California nursing student.
About 1,300 graduates and students of an online Utah-based nursing school are stuck in a licensing dispute between Nightingale College and the California Board of Registered Nursing, with a judge ruling against the school and a key hearing set for February.
The dispute centers on whether Nightingale’s graduates completed enough hands-on patient care to qualify for a California registered nurse license, KCRA reported. The board has barred the graduates from sitting for the national licensing exam while the legal fight runs on in Sacramento County Superior Court.
Nightingale College sued the board on Aug. 24, arguing that regulators applied standards never formally adopted for out-of-state schools — after authorizing testing for almost 2,200 of its graduates and licensing nearly 2,000 under the same curriculum, according to the college’s own statement. The board counters that clinical training fell short of what state law requires.

In Plain English: The Clinical Takeaway
- California requires nursing students to complete at least 500 hours of direct, hands-on patient care, including at least 30 hours in specialty areas such as obstetrics and pediatrics, before they can be licensed.
- If you are a Nightingale graduate in California, you cannot currently take the NCLEX-RN exam; the college is offering 100 students free supplemental courses it hopes will satisfy the board, with plans to extend them if they work.
- The judge’s ruling is not final — the underlying lawsuit continues, and the next hearing could determine whether the case survives at all.
Why the board blocked the licensing exam
The California Board of Registered Nursing, the agency that issues registered nurse licenses in the state, began reviewing Nightingale's curriculum after inquiries and complaints challenged whether the school's clinical training met California standards, the board's attorney Reza Pejuhesh explained at an August meeting, according to KCRA.
The core of the dispute is a gap between two legal baselines. California law requires in-state nursing schools to provide at least 500 direct patient care clinical hours, with at least 30 hours in specialty areas. Nightingale points instead to the “required curriculum” in the board’s own regulations and says its program matches those rules.
Deputy Attorney General Brent Jex told the court that letting Nightingale graduates become nurses without clinical hours in obstetrics or pediatrics “presents substantial harm,” in remarks reported from a Sacramento courtroom hearing.
“This was a huge decision for me, and to be told, ‘Well, now we have to change things,’ there’s no way that I can continue that. So, yeah, I mean, for me, it is kind of a long-time dream that is down the drain.”
Valdez Wall told KCRA she had researched the school carefully before enrolling, spending an estimated $8,000 to $12,000 over three semesters of online coursework while working full time. She has since withdrawn from the college.
A judge rules, but the case goes on
Sacramento Superior Court Judge Stephen Acquisto denied Nightingale’s request for a preliminary injunction — a temporary order that would have let graduates test for licenses while the lawsuit proceeds, per 10News reporting. In a 12-page written decision issued late Friday, he found the college was unlikely to succeed on its legal claims and called the board’s reading of the law “seems to be the only reasonable one.”
Acquisto also weighed the stakes: the interim harm to the public from granting the injunction “would be substantially greater” than the harm to the college from denying it, his ruling stated, as reported by 10News.
Nightingale’s attorney had argued the board cannot regulate out-of-state schools; the college also told the court there was no evidence any of its graduates had provided anything but the “highest quality of medical care.” Those claims did not carry the day — but the case itself continues.
How the row over clinical hours began
Both sides now agree the dispute traces back to a Microsoft Teams meeting on May 7, 2025, in which BRN Executive Officer Loretta Melby said she told Nightingale officials — including the college’s director of regulatory affairs, Blake Halladay — that the curriculum did not meet the board’s licensing requirements due to insufficient direct patient care clinical hours, according to a declaration filed in court, KCRA reported.
Nightingale Education Group CEO Mikhail Shneyder disputes that account. He told KCRA that what Melby’s declaration omits is her stated reluctance to act at the time. Shneyder claimed that Melby expressed she did not intend to do anything about the program because of its high enrollment and because she did not want to start World War III.
Shneyder noted the board continued licensing hundreds of Nightingale graduates after that meeting, KCRA reported. The board’s formal information request to the college came only in the spring of 2026, according to Shneyder’s account to KCRA.
The students caught in the middle
The human toll is mounting. Graduates report losing job offers during the months-long wait, KCRA reported. More than 500 spring graduates could not sit for the NCLEX-RN exam, with hundreds of summer graduates facing the same fate, according to Nightingale’s August statement.
Some students have taken their own legal action: a separate class-action lawsuit against the college alleges false advertising and breach of contract, KCRA reported. Shneyder defended the school, telling KCRA that Nightingale “makes a disclaimer to anybody who enrolls in the programs throughout this country, that we can only disclaim, and we can only talk about precedent in licensure.”
The board declined to answer questions, citing the ongoing litigation, KCRA reported. Nightingale did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the class action’s specific allegations.
What happens next for the 1,300 graduates
Nightingale is offering about 100 students additional, free telehealth-based coursework it hopes will satisfy the board’s requirements; the first graduate to complete the courses submitted paperwork to the BRN on Monday, Nov. 9, and awaits the board’s decision, KCRA reported.
The main lawsuit’s next hearing is set for February, when the court will consider the board’s request to dismiss the case, according to 10News. Until then, the graduates remain in limbo — thousands of dollars deep into an education the state may not recognize.
“Well, I can tell this, that Nightingale makes a disclaimer to anybody who enrolls in the programs throughout this country, that we can only disclaim, and we can only talk about precedent in licensure,” Shneyder told KCRA, explaining why the college says it is not at fault for the changed regulatory rules.
References
- KCRA 3 Investigates — Nightingale College graduates are in nursing license limbo in California
- 10News (San Diego) — Judge rules against Nightingale College in California nursing license dispute
- Nightingale College — press releases, Aug. 28 and Sept. 22, 2026, on the lawsuit and preliminary injunction motion
- Sacramento County Superior Court — Judge Stephen Acquisto’s 12-page ruling on the preliminary injunction, as reported by 10News