$2,300-a-Week Busselton Rental Sparks Outrage as Locals Priced Out

A four-bedroom rental in Abbey, Busselton has been listed at $2,300 a week—roughly 160 per cent above the suburb’s $880 median for comparable homes—prompting an online backlash and a debate over whether Western Australia’s South West rental market is pricing out local workers.

The listing, posted online on Tuesday by agency Acton Belle South West, asks $2,300 a week for a 1976-built, four-bedroom, two-bathroom house on an 806sqm block in the coastal suburb of Abbey, 230km south of Perth, ABC News reported. The median rent for a house that size in Abbey is $880 a week, meaning the ask sits about 2.6 times the going rate.

Asking price far exceeds local median rent

  • The asking price is roughly 160 per cent above the Abbey median of $880 a week for a four-bedroom house, per local property data cited by ABC News.
  • Busselton house values recorded the steepest regional decline in the country—4.1 per cent—in the July quarter, according to analytics firm Cotality.
  • Frontline housing and hospitality operators say shrinking rental supply, not a single outlier listing, is what’s squeezing local workers.

Why does one listing cost $1,420 more than the median?

The agent behind the listing argues the gap reflects product, not market drift. “This particular property sits firmly within the premium end of the market. It offers an exceptional location, high-quality fixtures and fittings, and a level of finish and presentation that distinguishes it from a typical rental property,” Acton Belle South West director Lyn Perks said.

Perks added the house “should not be viewed as a representative of rental pricing across the broader region,” while acknowledging the affordability pressure many West Australians face.

But the balance sheet tells a different story for locals doing the math on their own rent. Busselton resident Renee Guthridge told ABC News the price felt out of reach for families. “I just don’t understand how people can sleep at night charging that amount,” she said.

What do comparable Busselton rentals actually cost?

Local investor David Newman, who owns two similar four-bedroom, two-bathroom rentals in the area, told ABC News that plenty of comparable homes were available for around $900 a week. He said rising house prices, mortgages and interest rates had pushed costs up across the region, but doubted a long-term tenant would pay double the market rate.

Figure Value Source
Asking rent, Abbey four-bed listing $2,300/week ABC News
Abbey median, four-bedroom house $880/week ABC News (local property data)
Comparable homes nearby ~$900/week ABC News (David Newman)
Busselton house values, July quarter -4.1% Cotality, via ABC News

That last number matters. Busselton recorded the nation’s steepest regional house price decline—4.1 per cent—in the July quarter, according to Cotality data reported by ABC News. Yet asking rents at the top of the market are still being tested well above median levels.

Is this an outlier or a signal of worse to come?

Not-for-profit housing organisation Accordwest described the listing as an outlier but said it reflected broader affordability pressures. “The availability of the rentals as well is shrinking, so you’ve got hundreds of people and families trying to compete for a much smaller pocket of what’s actually out there, and hence you kind of see the increase,” Accordwest’s Matt Wilson told ABC News.

The pressure is now showing up in payrolls. Siesta Park Holiday Resort owners Greg and Jane Tickle told ABC News their staff need more hours just to cover rent. “We find that our staff find it hard, and they’re just needing more work to be able to pay their rent and afford anything else,” Ms Tickle said.

Her husband drew a line between two markets that are increasingly colliding. Greg Tickle said holiday businesses adjust prices dynamically during peak summer demand, but pushing long-term residential rents to similar heights makes it harder for local businesses to find year-round staff.

Who’s right about this market?

The two camps frame the same number differently. NewsLocker’s summary of the story put the split plainly: the asking price “has been scorned by priced-out locals, while the agent insists it is a premium property worth the money.” Newman’s position is that owners are free to ask whatever they like, and that “that’s part of living in the luxury of the South West.”

Wilson’s framing suggests the number itself is less important than the trend it sits on top of—shrinking supply against rising demand. On that reading, a $2,300 listing that stays vacant changes nothing; one that leases does.

The test comes when the listing either leases at that rate or doesn’t. Newman told ABC News he doubts a long-term tenant would pay double the market rate.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Gen X Health Worse Than Boomers at 50: UCL Study Shows Higher Obesity, Diabetes