Three Morgantown adults face criminal charges following an investigation into medical child abuse and unsafe living conditions that led to an invasive gastrostomy tube surgery for a two-year-old child.
Caregiver Fabricated Symptoms Leading to Unnecessary G-Tube Surgery
- Medical Child Abuse: Formally recognized as factitious disorder imposed on another, this condition occurs when a caregiver exaggerates, fabricates, or intentionally induces medical symptoms in a dependent.
- Invasive Intervention: Misleading information provided to medical professionals directly contributed to an unnecessary gastrostomy tube (G-tube) surgical procedure.
- Multidisciplinary Detection: Pediatric specialists, child abuse pediatricians, and state child protective services collaborated to uncover the fabricated medical history.
Sheriff Investigation Began October 7, Uncovered 175 Doctor Visits
The Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office said that the investigation began on October 8, 2026, after concerns surfaced regarding discrepancies in a child’s reported medical history and the general welfare of two juveniles residing at a Morgantown home, FOX 5 New York reported. WDTV said that the inquiry actually commenced a day earlier on October 7, 2026, focusing on a two-year-old and a nine-year-old.
Detectives reviewed extensive medical records and interviewed healthcare professionals, discovering that the two-year-old had approximately 175 doctor visits in just over two years, according to WDTV.
Emilee Guzman, the mother of the child, repeatedly informed medical staff that the toddler suffered from an inability or refusal to eat, alongside a severe fear of food diagnosed as avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder (ARFID). Guzman also told acquaintances that the child possessed rare conditions such as microgastria.

These misrepresentations culminated on October 1, 2026, in the surgical placement of a G-tube, a feeding tube inserted directly through the abdominal wall into the stomach. During an interview on October 13, 2026, Guzman acknowledged that she knowingly withheld information regarding the child’s actual food intake because she feared medical providers would suspect improper care and contact child protective services, WDTV reported.
On October 27, 2026, the lead detective consulted the pediatric surgeon who performed the procedure. The surgeon said that had accurate dietary information been available, he would not have performed the surgery and would have pursued less invasive alternatives. The surgeon said the procedure causes severe pain during both placement and removal and exposes the patient to serious clinical risks.
CBS News outlined that according to the Cleveland Clinic, factitious disorder imposed on another involves a caregiver falsifying medical needs or actively harming a dependent to simulate illness. While reliable epidemiological statistics remain sparse due to many cases going undetected, the condition carries severe morbidity risks when invasive procedures are unnecessarily performed.
| Defendant | Charges Filed | Specific Allegations |
|---|---|---|
| Emilee Guzman | One felony count of child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury | Provided misleading medical information leading to unnecessary G-tube surgery |
| Caitlin Jean Meredith | Two counts of child neglect creating risk of bodily injury | Implicated in hazardous living conditions and troubling household treatment |
| Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros | Two counts of child neglect creating risk of bodily injury | Implicated in hazardous living conditions at the Morgantown residence |
Executing a search warrant at the Jones Avenue residence in Morgantown, deputies uncovered deplorable and unsanitary conditions. Investigators documented accumulated garbage, scattered food, dried feces originating from cats and possibly humans, cockroaches, and heavy infestations of flies and gnats, according to WDTV. Authorities expressed grave concern regarding the recovery environment for the two-year-old, who required strict post-surgical hygiene to prevent site infections.
Beyond the medical abuse findings, investigators examined digital communications between Emilee Guzman and Caitlin Meredith that revealed troubling treatment of the nine-year-old child living in the home. The documentation included ridicule regarding incontinence, explicit threats, physical punishment, and excessive housekeeping demands.
Following removal from the mother’s custody, the two-year-old was observed consuming a diverse range of foods without difficulty or reliance on the G-tube. Foster caregivers reported that the child exhibited acute discomfort and resistance whenever anyone attempted to clean or approach the surgical site.
Arrests and Ongoing Legal Proceedings
All three defendants—Emilee Guzman, Caitlin Jean Meredith, and Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros—were taken into custody and booked into the North Central Regional Jail. The Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office commended medical staff at WVU Medicine Children’s Hospital and the West Virginia Department of Human Services’ Child Protective Services for their critical assistance during the investigation.
Authorities have withheld further identifying details concerning the minor children to protect their privacy. Anyone with more information about the defendants or the case should call the sheriff’s office Detective Division at 304-291-7260.
References
- Cleveland Clinic. Factitious Disorder Imposed on Another (Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy). Clinical Overview.
- Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office. Official Investigative Statement and Arrest Records. Published November 2026.
- WVU Medicine Children’s Hospital. Clinical Pediatric Evaluation and Child Abuse Pediatrics Reporting.