Apple to Stand Trial in Paris for Planned Obsolescence Over iPhone Repair Blocks

Apple will stand trial in Paris in June 2027 on charges of organized planned obsolescence, after French prosecutors concluded a four-year investigation into whether the company deliberately blocked repairs on 24 iPhone models, from the XS to the 15 Pro Max, outside its authorized network, according to Rtbf.

The criminal trial, confirmed by a source close to the case and reported Tuesday by Le Parisien, will run for four days starting June 17 before the tribunal correctionnel. Two entities are named: Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc., the parent company, according to Leparisien.

The charge is “entrave à la réparation et au reconditionnement” — obstruction of repair and refurbishment — a specific offense under French law since 2021, tied to planned obsolescence and designed to protect the environment and consumers.

Why does this matter beyond France?

How serialization actually works in iOS

According to the source close to the dossier cited by Le Parisien, Apple’s engineers configured the iPhone operating system to verify the serial number of individual components. When a part is swapped outside Apple’s official or approved circuit, iOS can disable or degrade features tied to that part.

The mechanism is software, not hardware: the logic lives in the OS, which means a repair shop can install a perfectly functional screen, battery, or camera and still see the phone penalize the swap at boot.

Apple to Stand Trial in Paris for Planned Obsolescence Over iPhone Repair Blocks
Photo: estrepublicain.fr

The alleged consequences are concrete. On some models, Face ID is disabled after a selfie camera replacement. The battery “Battery Health” readout can also be affected. Le Parisien reports the practices made impossible both out-of-network repair and the use of generic, non-Apple-branded parts, over a window running from November 2021 to July 2024 — more than two and a half years.

This is not a battery-gate rerun. The 2020 affair, for which Apple paid a 25 million euro French penalty in a criminal settlement before the current law existed, involved throttling performance on degraded batteries. Here, the accusation is structural: the software verifies provenance, not condition.

Who says what

HOP — Halte à l’obsolescence programmée — filed the original complaint on December 7, 2022, and called the decision to go to trial a first. “La ‘sérialisation’ se développe à contre-courant de la lutte contre le gaspillage” — serialization is growing against the current of the fight against waste — the association stated.

“La décision du parquet de Paris d’aller jusqu’au procès représente un signal fort pour les consommateurs et un avertissement pour ceux qui mettent en péril le droit à la réparation.”

That is Laetitia Vasseur, HOP’s general delegate and co-founder, who added that a conviction for planned obsolescence through repair obstructions “would be a historic first in France and in the world.”

Apple to Stand Trial in Paris for Planned Obsolescence Over iPhone Repair Blocks
Photo: lesechos.fr

Apple’s response, delivered to AFP and reported by Est Républicain: “Nous contestons fermement ces allégations infondées” — we firmly contest these unfounded allegations. The company says it designs durable products with software updates that let users keep devices longer.

Fixed fine is noise for Apple

The penalty ceiling looks almost comical against Apple’s balance sheet. The company risks up to 300,000 euros, or a percentage of its annual revenue — which now exceeds 400 billion dollars, roughly half of it generated by iPhone sales, according to the source close to the dossier cited by both Le Parisien and Est Républicain.

For a company of that scale, the fixed fine is noise. A revenue-based penalty is the only version that bites, and a criminal conviction could also open the door for affected consumers to seek compensation.

The deeper cost is architectural. The investigation was handled by the national inquiry service of the DGCCRF, France’s competition and consumer fraud authority, which spent four years on what sources describe as highly technical work.

What is still disputed

Apple contests the characterization outright, arguing its pairing practices protect users — a position consistent with its long-standing security argument that genuine, verified parts reduce risk of counterfeit components and tampering.

HOP reads the same mechanism as a commercial lock-in designed to push repairs into Apple’s own circuit and inflate sales. The tribunal will effectively have to rule on intent: is component verification a security feature, a revenue feature, or both?

What is not yet known: the full list of 24 affected models beyond the range the sources give — XS through 15 Pro Max, including the SE 2020 and 2022 and the 12, 13, and 14 series — and whether prosecutors will seek the revenue-based penalty. HOP has also filed a separate complaint against printer maker Epson on the same charge, per Est Républicain.

Apple Inc., the parent company named in the case alongside Apple Distribution International, was founded in 1976 as Apple Computer Company by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak and Ronald Wayne, and adopted its current name in 2007 as it expanded from computers into consumer electronics.

Headquartered in Cupertino, California, it has since 2011 for the most part been the world’s largest company by market capitalization, and in 2018 became the first publicly traded US company valued at over $1 trillion — a valuation that stood at just over $5 trillion as of November 2025.

The trial opens in Paris on June 17, 2027. “Une condamnation pour obsolescence programmée par entraves à la réparation serait une première historique en France et dans le monde,” Vasseur said.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Haaland, Hamilton, Leclerc Head Meta x SportsPro Athlete Honours 2026

Tommy Lee Jones, Ice Cube Transform Clunes, Victoria into Texas for ‘Outside Man’ Filming