ASEAN, China Miss South China Sea Code Deadline; Talks Shift to Singapore 2027 Chairmanship

MANILA — Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said that ASEAN and China have agreed on about 70 percent of the South China Sea Code of Conduct, but will miss the deadline to conclude it.

That is how much of the South China Sea code of conduct ASEAN and China had agreed on by the time the deadline ran out on Sunday, when Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro confirmed the negotiations would miss the 2026 target set three years ago, The Southeast Asia Desk reported. The news landed on the opening day of the 49th ASEAN Summit, held in Manila on Nov. 15.

The remaining 30% — the legal status of the code and its geographical scope — is precisely the part with teeth. A non-binding code would change little; the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties, which has governed the contested waters for more than two decades, carries no mechanism to stop aggression at all.

China, for its part, is signaling patience. Chinese Premier Li Qiang committed during a meeting with Southeast Asian leaders on Monday to an “effective, substantive and early conclusion” of the code, the Philippines’ foreign minister said, according to Reuters reporting carried by The Jakarta Post.

Lazaro, who had earlier pegged the deal at 80% complete, told Reuters she trusted “that Singapore will be able to finish the discussions” next year. The two figures — 70% and 80% — come from the same minister at different moments; the discrepancy is itself a measure of how fluid these talks remain.

Singapore inherits an unfinished code

The chairman’s gavel now passes from Manila to Singapore, which takes over ASEAN’s rotating chairmanship in 2027 with the same unfinished document. For the Philippines, missing the deadline means ending its year at the helm without securing what it had set as a key regional priority.

For the region, it means another stretch of contested waters governed by a 2002 declaration that is, as The Southeast Asia Desk’s reporting makes plain, non-legally binding.

How much that matters is visible in the incident tally. According to ACLED, the conflict-monitoring organization, between January 2025 and May 2026 the South China Sea recorded 3 collisions, 16 confrontations, 56 harassments, 134 movements of forces and 176 military exercises involving maritime activity. A Vietnamese research institute cited by The Southeast Asia Desk counted at least 15 incidents between the Philippines and China by the end of 2025 — near-monthly, by its reckoning.

The July foreign ministers’ summit under the Philippine chairmanship opened less than a day after Chinese and Philippine sailors clashed at sea, The Jakarta Post noted. Beijing claims most of the South China Sea despite an international ruling that its assertion has no legal basis.

Divisions inside ASEAN, not just with Beijing

The harder truth, analysts say, is that the sticking points are not purely ASEAN-versus-China. Collin Koh, a senior fellow at Singapore’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, told The Jakarta Post that divisions among ASEAN members had also slowed the talks.

ASEAN and China were unable to conclude negotiations on a long-delayed South China Sea code of conduct under
Photo: The Jakarta Post

“Other than Beijing, intramural divergences within ASEAN also play a significant role.”

Koh said, adding that the remaining differences would require “major concessions” from the parties. The geographical scope question illustrates why: several contested areas are claimed simultaneously by different ASEAN member states and by China, so even agreeing on which waters the code covers means members negotiating against one another.

Myanmar’s empty chair, extended again

The summit’s other open wound is Myanmar. ASEAN will extend the ban on the country’s leader attending the bloc’s annual summits, The Southeast Asia Desk reported, because the junta has failed to comply with the Five-Point Consensus adopted in April 2021 — a peace plan calling for an immediate cessation of violence, constructive dialogue, an ASEAN special envoy, humanitarian assistance through the AHA Centre, and envoy visits to meet all parties.

The military triggered the crisis by ousting the elected government in February 2021 and meeting civilian resistance with force. According to the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners, at least 818 civilians and activists had been killed and 5,392 detained as of May 2021. Since October 2021, when ASEAN foreign ministers agreed to admit only a “non-political representative” citing insufficient progress, the restriction has held through nine summits — the 49th now included.

Lazaro, born in 1959, joined the Department of Foreign Affairs in 1984 as an assistant director in its law division and went on to serve as ambassador to Switzerland from 2008 to 2011 and to France and Monaco from 2014 to 2020.

As undersecretary for bilateral relations and ASEAN affairs from 2022 to 2025, she was the Philippines’ top negotiator with China on South China Sea disputes, brokering a provisional arrangement for resupply missions to Filipino forces at Ayungin Shoal. Before her 2025 appointment as foreign secretary — the 29th holder of the post — she led the Philippine delegation in the very Code of Conduct talks she now reports on.

Both stories end the same way: with the next chairman. The code talks move to Singapore’s stewardship in 2027, and Myanmar’s seat stays restricted until, in ASEAN’s own framing, meaningful progress on the Five-Point Plan arrives. Lazaro’s confidence in her Singaporean successors may be tested sooner than anyone in Manila would like.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Fiona Harvey to Appear at Crown Court on Harassment Charge

Malawi Court to Rule Friday in Akster Case After Years of Delays