AU$109.2 million — that is the maximum fine hanging over any platform that gets this wrong.
A coalition of Australian church leaders, from evangelical and Baptist to Anglican, Presbyterian and Hillsong representatives, has asked Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to withdraw the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026, warning it could silence lawful religious teaching online. Christian Today reported the joint letter this week.
The churches are not fighting child protection. They say they back the bill’s core aim — shielding Australians, especially children, from serious online harm. What they contest is scope: drafted broadly enough, “harmful content” could sweep in sermons on marriage, sexual ethics and family that platforms pre-emptively remove to dodge liability.
The stakes in three lines
- The bill passed the House of Representatives on October 28 and is now before the Senate — the window for rewrite is closing.
- Platforms face fines up to AU$109.2 million, an incentive churches fear will trigger over-removal of contested religious content.
- The signatories want withdrawal, a narrower definition of harmful content, notice-and-appeal rights, and exemptions for small church websites.
Why does an entertainment desk care about a Canberra compliance bill? Because the same machinery that decides whether a sermon stays up decides whether a filmmaker’s interview, a musician’s lyrics video or a creator’s commentary survives an algorithm’s risk assessment. Digital duty-of-care regimes shift moderation from human judgment to liability math, and liability math is conservative by design.
The churches' sharpest worry is not censorship by government but censorship by insurance policy. When a platform risks a nine-figure penalty, the rational move is to take down anything ambiguous first and ask questions never. The letter argues the bill already exceeds what is needed to target content causing genuine serious harm, and that news, research, education and art enjoy exemptions while religious teaching does not.
A compliance bill with cultural side-effects
The signatories span Australia’s denominational map — evangelical churches, Baptists, Anglicans, Presbyterians, Hillsong figures and the Seventh-day Adventist Church in Australia, which joined the call for a rewrite. That breadth matters. Denominations that rarely share a stage agree the drafting is the problem, not the goal.
The administrative burden lands hardest at the small end. A local church running a simple website with a volunteer webmaster could face content risk assessments and record-keeping duties designed for billion-dollar platforms. The leaders propose either exempting low-risk religious and community sites or drastically simplifying their obligations.
They also want process rights: if content is removed or restricted, the person who posted it should be told why, with a fast and effective appeal. Under the current draft, a deleted Bible study could vanish without explanation — and without recourse.
Where the bill stands
| Milestone | Date | Status |
|---|---|---|
| House of Representatives passage | October 28 | Passed |
| Senate scrutiny | Under way | In committee |
| Senate hearing, eSafety Commissioner testimony | November 10 | Held |
| Maximum corporate penalty | — | AU$109.2 million |
At that November 10 Senate hearing, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant pushed back against claims the bill would produce sweeping censorship — while conceding the definition of harmful content could be made more specific. That concession is the hinge. If the definition narrows, the churches’ central objection weakens; if it does not, the letter’s authors have a documented, on-the-record reason to keep pressing.
For the streaming and creator economy, the precedent travels. Platforms operating globally apply their strictest market’s rules everywhere — it is cheaper to run one moderation standard than fifty. A broad Australian duty of care would not stay neatly inside Australia; it would shape what sermons, documentaries and music videos audiences in Sydney and Seattle alike can find.
The government’s position is unchanged: platforms should proactively address harmful content and risks to protect the public, children above all. The Senate now weighs that duty against a coalition of churches asking for one thing — pull it back, define harm precisely, and start again.
The letter asks the government to withdraw the bill and draft a new one that clearly defines the scope of harmful content. Until the Senate reports, the AU$109.2 million question — what counts as harm, and who decides — remains open.
Keep reading
- Object blue & Natalia Podgórska Map Life-Death Cycles in Fact Magazine Intervention
- Hayden Panettiere’s Estranged Mom Skips Celebration of Life, Blames Ex-Boyfriend
- Utah Sues Stake to Shut Down Alleged Illegal Online Casino Targeting Children (news-usa.today)
- Quad Leaders Meet in Manila to Discuss Indo-Pacific Security Ahead of Trump-Xi Talks (archynewsy.com)