BBC reporters tested four popular AI tools a week before Black Friday 2026 and found mixed results: ChatGPT and Claude surfaced unavailable or outdated listings, while Amazon’s Alexa returned accurate prices but only from its own store.
With Black Friday a week away, BBC technology reporters Liv McMahon and Imran Rahman-Jones put the free versions of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Amazon’s Alexa to the test, asking each to find a 55-inch TV deal. The exercise was not a rigorous scientific trial. It exposed consistent gaps between what the chatbots promised and what shoppers could actually buy.
ChatGPT suggests unavailable models and a Chinese retailer
OpenAI’s ChatGPT returned four options. Its top pick was a Hisense TV listed on Joybuy, a Chinese retailer, for £499 down from £649. The second recommendation was a 55-inch TCL model, though the sidebar showed prices for the 50-inch version ranging from £379 to £814.
Option three was the same Hisense TV at full price (£649) from John Lewis and Richer Sounds, which ChatGPT labelled the “best safer purchase” because of longer guarantee periods. Both UK retailer links showed the TV was no longer listed online. The fourth option, another TCL set, was £150 over budget and also unavailable. At the bottom, ChatGPT served “one OLED option to compare” — a £1,100 LG TV marked as an advertisement.
Claude relies on old reviews and dead links
Anthropic’s Claude gave the shortest response and based its picks on a small number of published reviews. It recommended the same two TCL models as ChatGPT, but the links led to dead pages on the Richer Sounds website. Other links pointed to year-old round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals. Claude was lukewarm on its remaining suggestions, calling one “a decent option” but saying it “wouldn’t pick” the other.
Alexa returns accurate prices — only from Amazon
Amazon’s Alexa for Shopping, launched in the UK in November, listed four TVs from its own store, ranging from the Amazon Ember at £532 to a Samsung. Its top recommendation was a different Samsung model at £616, down from £749, based on picture quality and Amazon customer ratings.
The fourth option was a 50-inch Sony TV, not the 55-inch size requested. All prices were correct, but Alexa acknowledged the limitation, encouraging users to check rivals “as prices can vary” and longer guarantees might be available elsewhere.
Inaccurate AI pricing wastes time and hides deals
Consumer group Which? warned that inaccurate AI pricing adds work to deal-hunting.
Senior researcher Hannah Walsh said: “If you ask ChatGPT for a list of 10 laptops under £400 and seven of the results are priced higher, you’ve likely wasted a good chunk of time going through them to discover the bot gave you only three options.” She added the reverse is also true: “you could miss out on great models in your budget if ChatGPT tells you they are more expensive than they actually are.”
Advertising may shape future recommendations
Naureen Mohammed, who advises businesses on getting products into AI results, told the BBC that shoppers do not see the full picture.
If retailers fail to update prices, “last year’s prices are served up as today’s deals.” She added: “I suspect the whole model for advertising is going to start influencing AI recommendations.” Her analysis of UK chatbot responses for Black Friday tech deals found Amazon mentioned in half of all answers, with Currys close behind.
Agentic AI showed promise last year but remains inconsistent
Tech journalist Alex Hughes used ChatGPT’s agentic AI mode during last year’s Black Friday sales. The search took about 20 minutes “with very little work on my end needed,” he wrote for Tom’s Guide. He did not buy at the time but later purchased one of the seven models ChatGPT surfaced, finding it cheaper in a physical shop.
Asked if he would use AI again this year, he said: “Probably not.” He reckoned it saved time, but “when you’re trying to deal with something like live price data… it will be inconsistent and quite often incorrect.”
Liv McMahon, a technology journalist with BBC News based in Glasgow, joined the corporation after a spell as a Search & Trends Writer at The Scotsman, where her election coverage and data‑driven stories regularly topped Google results.
At the BBC she has produced TV packages for the flagship programme Click and written explainers on topics such as quantum computing, while her current focus includes social‑media platform shifts and the impact of generative AI.
Practical checks shoppers can run
Mohammed recommends asking an assistant “is that this year’s price?” and always clicking the links provided — “because you shouldn’t take any advice from the AI system at face value.” A YouGov survey of 19 countries found the UK ranked second-last in the proportion of people who had used AI to help them shop, and 36% of respondents planning to shop around Black Friday said they would not use an AI tool at all.