Bergamo’s Donizetti Opera Festival opened Friday with the first modern staging of the 1828 original version of L’esule di Roma, a score unseen since the composer’s lifetime and published only months ago in a new critical edition.
The curtain rose on November 13 at the Teatro Donizetti one minute after a silence held for Antonino Fogliani, the conductor slated to lead the production before his death in August at age 50. His replacement, Bergamo native Fabrizio Maria Carminati, stepped onto the podium with days’ notice, Scherzo reported.
The evening carried the weight of a musicological event: the critical edition by Roger Parker and Ian Schofield, issued by Ricordi with the Fondazione Teatro Donizetti, restores the two-act “melodramma eroico” exactly as it premiered at Naples’ Teatro San Carlo, before Donizetti rewrote it for Palermo in 1830.
“The recovery of L’esule di Roma, made from the newly published critical edition of the score, constitutes a musicological event, but also, and above all, an occasion to discover — or rediscover — a true bel canto treasure,” Scherzo wrote in its review of the opening night.

Festival Opens with Modern Premiere of 1828 Opera
- The 1828 Naples original of L’esule di Roma received its first modern performance at the Donizetti Opera Festival, using a critical edition published this year by Ricordi.
- Conductor Antonino Fogliani died in August; hometown maestro Fabrizio Maria Carminati led the opening night after a minute of silence in Fogliani’s memory.
- Tenor Serguéi Romanovski earned the night’s strongest notices for Settimio; director Katharina Thoma’s modern-dress staging was described as having very little substance.
A Score Lost to the Repertoire Returns
Donizetti was twenty-nine when L’esule di Roma premiered at the San Carlo on January 1, 1828. The libretto by Domenico Gilardoni drew on the 1804 mélodrame Androclès, ou le Lion reconnaissant by Caignez — a classical tale of political persecution and a recognitive lion that allowed the censors of Bourbon Naples to swallow a story about tyranny and exile.
Within six years the opera had reached more than thirty Italian houses plus London, Vienna and Madrid, Beckmesser noted. Then it vanished, eclipsed by the composer’s later masterpieces and the shifting tastes of mid-century opera.
The 1830 Palermo revision — tighter, re-scored, with a new aria for tenor Domenico Donzelli — became the version staged in the rare modern revivals at Savona in 1986, Seville in 1998 and Palermo in 1999.
The critical edition now restores the Naples autograph: two acts, a different dramatic arc, and the original orchestral colors Donizetti conceived for the San Carlo’s forces. “This is the version now recovered, and for the first time,” Ópera Actual confirmed.
Carminati Steps in, Fogliani Remembered
Fogliani had been a fixture of the festival; his sudden death left a hole in the artistic plan. Carminati, born in Bergamo in 1958, had conducted previous festival editions and knew the orchestra. He led the performance dedicated to his colleague.
Scherzo described Carminati’s direction as “leaden, monotonous and routine,” arguing that cabalettas lacked vigor and arias expression, coining the term “batutero” — a time-beater — for his approach. Ópera Actual, by contrast, called his reading “exemplary” for the youthful score, praising the second act in particular and crediting the Orchestra and the Accademia della Scala Chorus under Salvo Sgrò.
Romanovski Leads a Strong Cast
Russian tenor Serguéi Romanovski dominated the evening. His Settimio — the wrongly exiled lover of the heroine Argelia — rang through the theater with “profiled and radiant” tone, Scherzo wrote, excelling in the aria Donizetti wrote for the 1840 Bergamo revival and in the celebrated third-act trio with baritone Luca Pisaroni (Murena) and soprano Lidia Fridman (Argelia), according to Beckmesser. Fridman’s Argelia and Pisaroni’s Murena drew warm notices; tenor Marcelo Solís, a graduate of the festival’s Bottega Donizetti young-artist program, impressed in the secondary role of Publio, Ópera Actual reported.
Thoma’s Modern-Dress Concept Divides
German director Katharina Thoma moved the action to the present, using curtains and projections — sets by Devin McDonough, costumes by Irina Barteles, lights by Fiammetta Baldiserri — to argue that political conflicts repeat across eras. “Very little substance: curtains and projections, with a transfer of the action to the present day to signify that political conflicts are the same in all times,” Ópera Actual summarized.
Scherzo was blunter, calling the staging “brave” in its exhumation of the score but thin in visual imagination. The festival’s parallel production, Le convenienze ed inconvenienze teatrali (Viva la Mamma!), directed by Silvia Paoli, earned fervent applause for its meta-theatrical wit.
Musicology Meets the Stage
The Parker–Schofield edition is the scholarly backbone of the festival’s Donizetti revival project, a multi-year partnership between Ricordi and the Fondazione Teatro Donizetti aimed at publishing the composer’s complete works in critical form. Restoring the 1828 L’esule allows scholars and audiences to hear the young Donizetti before the Palermo compromises — longer ensembles, different harmonic turns, the original finale.
Festival Continues Through November with More Performances
The festival runs through late November with further performances of L’esule di Roma on the calendar, plus the comic Le convenienze and a third title yet to be reviewed in full. Carminati remains on the podium for the remaining L’esule dates; the critical edition will enter the rental catalogue for other houses next season.