Bishops’ Conferences President Criticizes 5 EU States’ Rwanda Migrant Plan

Five European Union member states have advanced plans to establish return hubs in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers, drawing sharp criticism from church leaders who condemn the externalisation policy as bearing the chilling hallmarks of deportation while migration tragedies continue to unfold in the Mediterranean Sea.

Gathered in Vienna on November 16, interior ministers and leaders from Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece, and the Netherlands initiated what Christian Stocker termed a historic paradigm shift, according to reporting by Internazionale. The framework intends to transfer migrants facing definitive repatriation orders to the East African nation starting in July 2027.

Monsignor Mariano Crociata, president of the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union, warned that outsourcing migration management strips away fundamental human responsibilities. Vatican News reported that Crociata criticized the European Commission for endorsing a strategy designed to bypass domestic obligations.

Bishops' Conferences President Criticizes 5 EU States' Rwanda Migrant Plan
Photo: Avvenire

“La decisione di esternalizzare la collocazione dei migranti impressiona poiché ha il sapore di una deportazione: destina queste persone a condizioni di vita probabilmente non migliori da quelle da cui sono fuggiti,” said Mariano Crociata, vescovo di Latina-Terracina-Sezze-Priverno e presidente della Commissione delle Conferenze episcopali dell’Unione europea (Comece), in an interview with Vatican News.

Vincent Biruta defended the partnership, stating that migration is a global challenge requiring collective solutions and that his country offers individuals a second opportunity with appropriate vocational support, as detailed by Internazionale.

Bishops' Conferences President Criticizes 5 EU States' Rwanda Migrant Plan
Photo: Internazionale

Skeptics note striking parallels to previous externalisation models, including the controversial arrangement pursued by the United Kingdom in 2023, which allocated 715 million pounds before British courts and subsequent political shifts dismantled the project. Avvenire observed that European repatriation statistics remain remarkably low, with Italy executing only 4,784 returns in 2025 despite extensive political declarations.

Born in Castelvetrano, Province of Trapani, Sicily, in 1953, Mariano Crociata was ordained as a priest in 1979 and later served as Bishop of Noto after his appointment by Pope Benedict XVI in 2007. He subsequently held the role of General Secretary of the Italian Episcopal Conference from 2008 to 2013, becoming the first to come from a southern Italian diocese, before taking up his current position as bishop of Latina-Terracina-Sezze-Priverno in November 2013.

Country / Entity Initiative / Measure Key Figure / Reference
Five EU States Rwanda return hub agreement Scheduled operational launch in July 2027
United Kingdom (2023) Prior deportation framework 715 million pounds allocated
Italy (2025) National repatriation figures 4,784 recorded returns
European Parliament New repatriation regulation 418 yes votes, 218 no, 30 abstentions

A wooden boat carrying roughly fifty migrants from Tunisia capsized off the coast of Lampedusa, leaving a six-year-old girl from Côte d’Ivoire missing while her mother received treatment in an island medical facility, according to Vatican News.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Constanze Lohse: These Three Nutrients Recommended for Over-60s