Brazil Rejects Plea Bargain for Argentine Lawyer Accused of Racism in Rio de Janeiro

Rio de Janeiro’s prosecutor’s office has rejected a plea-bargain request from the defense of Agostina Páez, the 29-year-old Argentine lawyer accused of racist gestures against three waiters in an Ipanema bar, closing off her main path to ending the case without a conviction, APFDigital reported on Tuesday according to Apfdigital.

The decision matters because the mechanism her team sought — an “acuerdo de no persecución penal,” or non-prosecution agreement — was the one route that could have closed the case without a criminal record.

The prosecution says the math alone rules it out: three counts of racial insult, each carrying a minimum sentence of two years, add up to six years, well past the four-year ceiling the law sets for such deals.

Her Argentine lawyer, Sebastián Robles, played down the setback. “It was only a non-acceptance of a plea deal. The process is in the same place where we left it in March. We are waiting for the definitive ruling,” Robles said, according to Noticias Argentinas.

Here is why the timing matters. The case is already in its final stretch: closing arguments are filed, and Judge Carlos Márcio da Costa of the 37th Criminal Court of Rio de Janeiro has yet to set a date for the verdict. The prosecution’s refusal effectively removes the last off-ramp before that ruling arrives.

Brazil Rejects Plea Bargain for Argentine Lawyer Accused of Racism in Rio de Janeiro
Photo: apfdigital.com.ar

Why Rio’s prosecutors refused the deal

The Ministerio Público of Rio de Janeiro gave two reasons, both spelled out in a statement to La Nación, according to Clarín. “En las condiciones en que la acusada practicó las ofensas raciales que se le imputan, no hay posibilidad de acuerdo,” the office wrote.

The first reason is arithmetical. Brazilian law allows a non-prosecution agreement only when the minimum penalty for the case sits below four years. Prosecutors count three separate counts of racial injury — one for each of the three waiters who filed the complaint — with a two-year minimum each, totaling six.

The second is the gravity of the conduct. According to the prosecution’s account, detailed by La Nación, Páez first imitated a monkey toward the cashier and then, already leaving the bar, shouted racial slurs at other staff — “even after having been warned that such conduct was criminal,” the office said.

Prosecutors added that she told the victims nothing would happen to her because she was a lawyer and an influencer, “placing herself in a position of superiority” over the workers and Brazilian criminal law itself.

15 years in prison? The trial of the Argentine lawyer in Brazil for racism — DNews

The defense sought a review of the rejection, but the Criminal Advisory of the state’s Prosecutor General’s Office upheld it in an opinion signed by procurator Alexandre Araripe Marinho, La Nación reported.

How the case reached this point

The episode dates to January 14, when Páez, then dining with friends at a bar on Vinícius de Moraes street in Ipanema, argued with staff over the bill. A video showing her making monkey gestures went viral, and the three waiters filed a criminal complaint.

The consequences moved fast. A judge ordered her pretrial detention, later converted to house arrest with an electronic ankle monitor and a ban on leaving Rio. After more than two months in Brazil, she was allowed home under a habeas corpus granted at the end of March, against bail of roughly US$20,000. She landed in Argentina on April 1.

The trial hearings took place in March, with witnesses and victims testifying, Infobae reported. On September 23, the judge sent the file to the prosecution to weigh an agreement — the very route now closed.

Brazil Rejects Plea Bargain for Argentine Lawyer Accused of Racism in Rio de Janeiro
Photo: infobae.com
  • January 14 — The incident at the Ipanema bar; a video of the gestures goes viral and three waiters press charges.
  • Late March — After more than two months restricted to Rio, Páez is authorized to return to Argentina on roughly US$20,000 bail.
  • April 1 — She arrives back in Argentina, awaiting the verdict from home.
  • September 23 — The judge sends the file to prosecutors to evaluate a non-prosecution deal.
  • November 17 — Prosecutors reject the deal and uphold the refusal on review.

The defense’s counter-argument

The lawyer Carla Junqueira, who also intercedes in the representation of Páez, is pressing for acquittal. “There was no crime,” she told La Nación.

Her argument: the gesture was aimed at an employee who was facing the other way, so no harm occurred, and the episode should be read as a single incident rather than three separate offenses — a framing that would also undercut the six-year tally blocking a deal.

The defense also disputes that the insults prosecutors describe, allegedly shouted as she left the bar, were ever established. Robles told Infobae the rejection “does not substantially modify” his client’s situation.

But there is a catch, and it sits in the sentencing math. Whether a sentence lands above or below four years determines whether any conviction could be served through alternative measures, such as community service.

Brazil Rejects Plea Bargain for Argentine Lawyer Accused of Racism in Rio de Janeiro
Photo: lanacion.com.ar

What the verdict could look like

Robles sketched the scenarios his client faces. He expects any sentence to fall below four years, which could allow Páez to serve community tasks in Argentina — though, as Infobae notes, that is a defense expectation, not a court ruling. He also raised the possibility that the US$20,000 bail could go to the victims, again pending the judge’s decision.

The legal framework behind the prosecution’s hard line is itself recent. Brazil’s Law 14.532/2023 incorporated racial injury into the country’s anti-racism statute, establishing a more severe regime for this type of crime.

No date has been set for the ruling. When it lands, it will be Judge da Costa’s alone — the accord that might have preempted him is no longer on the table. “We are waiting for the resolution,” as Robles put it.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

New Taipei Council Candidate Chen Chu-yin Released on NT$500,000 Bail Over Anti-Infiltration Act Suspicions

British Workers File Leave Requests for GTA VI Launch