Charlotte is seeking to have a wrongful-death lawsuit brought by Iryna Zarutska’s family dismissed, asking a judge to toss the case over alleged security lapses the family claims left her vulnerable on the city’s light-rail system, with the city contending that many of those choices fall under governmental immunity. Zarutska’s murder drew national attention after surveillance video showed Decarlos Brown Jr. seated behind her aboard a Lynx Blue Line train before he is accused of stabbing her in the neck about four minutes after she boarded. The 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee had just left work at a local pizzeria. Her family alleges Charlotte failed to adequately police and secure the light-rail system, suing both the city and its private transit security contractor, Professional Police Services, or PSS. According to the city, choices related to transit policing, crime prevention, security contractors and public safety constitute governmental functions that North Carolina law protects from liability.
On Monday, the city filed a motion asking a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge to throw out the lawsuit brought by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee stabbed to death aboard a Lynx Blue Line train in August 2025. The motion came after mediation in the case reached an impasse.
Zarutska was killed after boarding the train following her shift at a local pizzeria. Surveillance video showed Decarlos Brown Jr. seated behind her before he is accused of stabbing her in the neck about four minutes after she boarded.
“The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by Decarlos Brown Jr.,” city attorneys wrote in the motion. “The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack.”
The immunity argument
The city contends the lawsuit challenges “law-enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight, and public-safety administration” — activities it argues are governmental functions shielded from liability under North Carolina law. The city further contends that the lawsuit alleges Charlotte failed to take reasonable and available safety measures on the Charlotte Area Transit System to prevent the fatal stabbing. The city argues that claims arising from Zarutska’s injuries and death are subject to a cumulative $1 million limit set in state law. It also invokes the state’s public-duty doctrine, arguing the family cannot hold the city liable for failing to provide general police protection without showing a specific promise of protection to Zarutska or a special relationship with her.
The suit, filed in August by Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, who was hosting the family in Charlotte, argues it was a preventable death. The suit also named the private transit security company in the filing. Haskell’s attorney, Lauren Newton, says “Their failures caused the fatal stabbing.” She argues “Simple fare enforcement, turnstiles or proper security staffing — which the city had the money for — could have saved Zarutska’s life.”
The city’s filing does not dispute several of the family’s factual claims. It concedes that no private security guard was present in Zarutska’s train car at the time of her death, that Brown apparently boarded without presenting a ticket or pass, and that the system operates without turnstiles or fare gates. But it denies those circumstances caused her death, arguing Brown acted on his own and that a violent attack on a passenger was not reasonably foreseeable based on prior crime across the transit system.
“The City disputes the Complaint’s characterization of CATS as a for-profit business and disputes that systemwide crime statistics, contractor staffing figures, or later recommendations establish that any act or omission by the City proximately caused Mr. Brown’s attack,” the motion says.
What the city says it had done
Charlotte rejects the claim that it neglected passenger safety, asserting that CATS had contracted armed and unarmed security in place, worked alongside law enforcement and carried out additional public-safety measures prior to the killing. In the period before August 22, 2025, CATS ran a broad security program, held contracts for armed and unarmed security along with company-police services, and pursued efforts around public safety, security planning, training, and transit operations. The filing also preserves the city’s argument that any payouts would be subject to North Carolina’s cumulative $1 million limit on such claims if the case were to proceed.
Brown stabbed Zarutska four times, according to surveillance video. He is in federal custody in connection with the killing. A hearing in his state murder case was recently delayed until May 2027.
The judge has not yet ruled on the motion.