Ten years after Britain voted to leave the European Union, Prime Minister Andy Burnham will sit down with EU leaders at a landmark summit on Friday, pushing for a youth mobility scheme, linked emissions trading and fewer food trade barriers — and openly floating, for the first time, the question of rejoining the bloc.
The summit lands exactly a decade after the June 2016 referendum, and the contrast with that vote could hardly be sharper. Then, “Leave” carried the day; now, a Labour prime minister is telling audiences the divorce deal itself was a mistake.
“The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough,” Burnham said in his first major foreign policy speech on Monday, referring to the 2020 agreement under which Britain actually left the EU, CNN reported.
Here is why that matters far beyond the English Channel. Britain remains the EU’s biggest single neighbor and one of the world’s largest economies, and its regulatory choices still ripple through European supply chains, financial markets and NATO’s northern flank. A UK that drifts back toward Brussels changes the arithmetic for Washington, for investors pricing British assets, and for the EU’s own ambitions as a geopolitical bloc.
But there is a catch, and it is a big one. Burnham has pledged not to cross his party’s 2024 manifesto “red lines” — no return to the single market, no customs union, no freedom of movement — while telling audiences last month he would like to see Britain back in the EU in his lifetime, though not in this parliament.
He committed only to opening talks “about options for our long-term relationship” after Friday’s summit, without details or a timeline.

Burnham inherits a deal Starmer nearly sealed
Friday’s summit is, ironically, mostly his predecessor’s work. Keir Starmer’s government promised to “make Brexit work” after its 2024 election, negotiating limited deals and aligning some regulations to ease trade friction. But Starmer’s cautious, technocratic style — on Europe and beyond — contributed largely to his own party ousting him this summer. Burnham, the more confident and media-savvy figure, took over four months ago.
The summit itself was scheduled for earlier this year and delayed when Starmer’s premiership collapsed. Nick Thomas-Symonds, the member of parliament who served as Europe minister under Starmer, told CNN the deal was “90% there” when Burnham’s team inherited it.
What is left undone is telling. Three issues remain open, Thomas-Symonds said: aligning tuition fees for EU students at UK universities with those paid by British students; Britain’s final position on the EU’s “Made in Europe” initiative, which threatens to squeeze UK firms out of European supply chains; and how many young people a youth mobility scheme would allow to move in either direction.
It is unclear whether Friday’s talks will move the needle on any of them.
The economic bill behind the rethink
Money explains much of the urgency. Economists broadly agree that leaving the EU stunted Britain’s growth potential, with estimates of foregone output ranging from 2% to as much as 8% — a spread worth hundreds of billions of pounds over a decade. As the government hunts for levers to restart growth, the EU, as Britain’s largest trading partner, has become central to the conversation.
Burnham says the three deals on the table this week could add up to 0.4% of GDP and cut bureaucratic hurdles for food exporters. Against a foregone-output estimate of up to 8%, that is a modest down payment — which is precisely why he has started talking about the longer game.
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Foregone UK output since Brexit (estimates) | 2% to 8% | Economists, cited by CNN |
| Potential GDP gain from Friday’s deals | Up to 0.4% | Andy Burnham |
| Deal completeness on Burnham’s arrival | “90% there” | Nick Thomas-Symonds, via CNN |
Yet the old trade-off — sovereignty versus frictionless trade — has not gone away. Europe Minister Hamish Falconer conceded to the BBC that implementing the deals would force Britain to accept EU regulations on products without any say in writing them.
Michel Barnier, the EU’s former Brexit negotiator, warned earlier this month that the UK cannot “cherry pick” elements of the single market. And the bloc’s foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, said last week that the EU had suffered “a lot of trauma” from Britain’s departure, cautioning that future negotiations “will not be that easy.”
Is the rhetoric ahead of the policy?
Not everyone sees a revolution. Anand Menon, professor at King’s College London and director of the think tank UK in a Changing Europe, told CNN that Burnham’s actual approach has not changed “an iota” from Starmer’s.
“The only difference is how we talk about the future, and Burnham saying we might consider rejoining,” Menon said. “The more people talk about rejoining, the more obviously complicated an undertaking it becomes. I don’t know where Burnham goes on this.”
Menon added that further change is unlikely unless the government compromises on its red lines — the very promises Burnham has sworn to keep. Thomas-Symonds, for his part, pointed to cooperation on immigration, stronger military ties and sector-by-sector regulatory alignment as ways to deepen the relationship without breaking manifesto commitments, adding that the bigger questions are ones Labour is “looking at in the next manifesto.”
The politics, meanwhile, are shifting fast. Two campaign groups with ties to the original Vote Leave campaign launched or rebranded this week with the express aim of opposing any rejoining attempt. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch accused Burnham of having “not learnt the lessons of the past,” arguing that “the problems this country faces today have nothing to do with being in or out of the EU.”
Nigel Farage, the Brexit architect who leads Reform UK, said Burnham “has no mandate” to negotiate closer ties. Even David Cameron and Boris Johnson — the two former Conservative prime ministers whose premierships were defined by the divorce — have cautioned against reopening old wounds.
And yet, public opinion may be moving Burnham’s way. Morgan Jones, deputy director of Persuasion UK, which researches public opinion, told CNN that polling suggests an option to rejoin on 2016 terms tomorrow would be “resoundingly popular.” But the same research found voters are put off by budget contributions, any threat of joining the Euro, and simply the process itself — there is, she said, significant voter exhaustion on this topic.
So the realistic stakes for Friday are narrower than the headlines suggest: a youth mobility scheme, an emissions-trading link, easier food trade, and Britain’s costly return to the Erasmus student exchange program next year — at a far higher price than it paid before. Menon is blunt about what failure would mean: the government “really needs” these deals, because without them “it’s going to look ridiculous.”
The bloc Burnham wants to rejoin bears little resemblance to the trading community Britain signed up to in 1973. The European Union as it exists today was created when the Maastricht Treaty came into force in 1993, uniting 27 member states with a single legal personality confirmed by the Treaty of Lisbon in 2009.
It abolished passport controls across the Schengen Area, runs a single currency used by 21 members, and represents itself at the United Nations, the World Trade Organization and the G7. In 2012 it was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.
Britain’s departure in 2020 made it the only member state ever to leave the EU — while ten countries are now aspiring or negotiating to join it. That asymmetry shapes the summit’s arithmetic: Brussels negotiates from a position of size, with an economy of around €18.802 trillion in 2025, roughly one sixth of global output.
Ten years after 17.4 million people voted to leave, the question is no longer whether Britain talks about going back — it is whether Brussels will let it return without paying the full price of membership. As Kallas put it last week, the negotiations ahead “will not be that easy.”