Grunge Ranks 5 Best Bubblegum Pop Vocal Harmonies: Archies to Ohio Express

Grunge ranked the 5th Dimension's "Up, Up and Away" among the five best bubblegum pop vocal harmonies from 1967 to 1969.

The five greatest vocal harmonies in bubblegum pop history span 1967 to 1969 and run from the Archies’ “Jingle Jangle” to Ohio Express’ “Yummy Yummy” — and Grunge’s new ranking shows how layered studio vocals, often from a single singer, turned manufactured confections into enduring chart classics.

That is the argument Grunge reported this week in a deep-cut ranking of the subgenre’s finest stacked voices, and it lands at a curious moment.

Bubblegum pop — the late-’60s factory line of saccharine singles churned out by writers and session singers masquerading as bands — is having a quiet rediscovery, with playlist-era listeners treating one-hit wonders as canon. The harmonies, Grunge’s piece argues, are the reason these records survived at all.

The surprise: some of the genre's most treasured vocal arrangements were never sung by the bands whose names sit on the label.

The 5 Best Vocal Harmonies In Bubblegum Pop History: Jingle Jangle — The Archies

Grunge Names Top Five Bubblegum Harmony Acts

  • Grunge named the Archies, the Cowsills, the Cuff Links, the 5th Dimension and Ohio Express as the five best harmony acts in bubblegum pop history.
  • Two of the five iconic tracks — “Tracy” and “Yummy Yummy” — were performed almost entirely by session singer Joey Levine and Ron Dante, not the credited bands.
  • The records date from 1967 to 1969, with “Yummy Yummy” peaking at No. 4 on Billboard’s Hot 100 for three weeks.

Ron Dante Recorded Dozen Voices Quickly

The opening pick sets the tone. The Archies’ 1969 single “Jingle Jangle” doesn’t ease listeners in — the warm, multi-layered vocals arrive from the first bar, with Toni Wine handling the melody and Ron Dante layering a soft falsetto verse over rhythm guitar. Dante and Wine bounce notes off each other toward the end until the final chorus, per Grunge’s account of the recording.

Then comes the entry that doubles as an industry masterclass. “Tracy” by the Cuff Links — stacked so thick it sounds like a roomful of singers — is, in fact, one man: Ron Dante again, the same voice that took the Archies’ “Sugar, Sugar” to No. 1 in 1969. Dante described the process himself.

The 5 Best Vocal Harmonies In Bubblegum Pop History: We Can Fly — The Cowsills

“With overdubs, I recorded a dozen voices on it to make it sound like The Association and The Turtles. I did all the voices in about two hours, with different parts, drawing on the doo-wop music I grew up with.”

That quote, Dante told Goldmine, is the whole bubblegum economy in miniature: a dozen voices, two hours, one earworm. The ghosts behind the bands are everywhere in this ranking, and Grunge’s piece pulls the curtain back on two of them.

The Family Who Wanted to Be the Beatles

The Cowsills’ 1968 “We Can Fly” gets singled out for different reasons. The original lineup — brothers Bill, John, Barry and Bob Cowsill — started out wanting to be the next Beatles, and while they never produced a “Because”-style showcase, their harmonies came close.

Mother Barbara, sister Susan and brother Paul had joined by the time the track was recorded, sweetening an already sugary sound with layered vocals that stretch the word “one” into a soothing final chord.

The 5 Best Vocal Harmonies In Bubblegum Pop History: Tracy — The Cuff Links

The 5th Dimension’s 1967 “Up, Up and Away” earns its slot on pure execution. Grunge’s description of the blend — one part bubblegum, one part sunshine pop, a dash of choral music — lands on an arrangement that sounds like twenty singers where there are five.

At the midpoint, the instruments fall away, the women take center stage, and the voices slowly dissipate as if the group had drifted off in the very balloon the song sells.

Scratch Vocal Becomes Hit Record

The funniest story in the ranking belongs to Ohio Express. The sporadic harmonies of “Yummy Yummy” — quick bursts of layered vocals that vanish and return — were sung entirely by Joey Levine, who wasn’t even trying to make the final record. He laid down a scratch vocal for a demo so the band could learn the lyrics, Levine told Record Collector in 2013.

The 5 Best Vocal Harmonies In Bubblegum Pop History: Up, Up and Away — The 5th Dimension

“The background’s flat and everything,” Levine said, recalling the demo. “[Buddah Records executive] Neil Bogart heard it and said, ‘You can’t take that guy off of it. He makes the record.'”

Bogart’s instinct was commercially bulletproof. The single climbed to No. 4 on Billboard’s Hot 100 and held that spot for three weeks — a figure Grunge credits in no small part to those in-and-out harmony bursts.

Five Songs, One Sweet Snapshot of 1967–1969

Song Act Year Harmony note
“Up, Up and Away” The 5th Dimension 1967 Five voices sounding like twenty; voices fade as if floating away
“We Can Fly” The Cowsills 1968 Band expanded to seven siblings-plus-parents filling out the blend
“Yummy Yummy” Ohio Express 1968 Sporadic bursts by Joey Levine; peaked at No. 4 on the Hot 100 for three weeks
“Jingle Jangle” The Archies 1969 Toni Wine and Ron Dante trade waves of catchiness from the first bar
“Tracy” The Cuff Links 1969 A dozen Dante overdubs in roughly two hours

What makes the ranking matter now is the pattern underneath it. Bubblegum pop was a producers’ medium — Buddah Records executives picking scratch vocals over plurality, fictional comics bands outsinging real ones — and the harmony stack was the trick that made the illusion convincing.

That same economics echoes through today’s pop machine, where topliners, vocal producers and credited frontpeople occupy roles the Archies would recognize instantly. Dante made records sound like the Association; the modern equivalent is a vocal producer making one singer sound like a stadium. The tools changed. The sleight of hand didn’t.

And the honest verdict comes from the man who sang the biggest one. Levine, decades later, still wasn’t impressed with his own backgrounds. Bogart was right anyway — the record exists because a demo singer’s throwaway take made the record, and, as Levine’s own account to Record Collector shows, nobody could say it better than that.

Grunge itself has a backstory worth a beat. The music site was launched in 2015 by Static Media, the Indiana-based digital media company founded by Reggie Renner and Mike Langin, who had earlier built the content recommendation network ZergNet in 2011. Grunge sits alongside Looper, Static Media’s flagship publication, and covers music for a portfolio that now spans more than 30 websites.

So queue up “Jingle Jangle,” pick a melody line to follow in “Tracy,” and listen for whichever voice is doing the heavy lifting.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Burst Water Pipe Closes Kortrijk Schools, 940 Pupils at Home