James Silva, an 86-year-old former Rhode Island priest, pleaded no contest on Thursday, Nov. 19, to molesting a boy in the late 1980s — and will serve no prison time. A judge gave him a suspended sentence.
At a Superior Court hearing, Silva entered the plea — nolo contendere — to one count of first-degree child molestation and one count of second-degree child molestation.
According to the state’s attorney general’s office, Silva had been indicted in 2021 on 11 charges; Judge Richard Raspallo dismissed the other nine and sentenced him to 10 years, suspended, with probation. Silva must register as a sex offender and, per the judge’s order, have no contact with victims.
Prosecutors had recommended prison time at previous pre-trial conferences, per the attorney general’s office as reported in local coverage, but did not object on the record to the plea.
From the courtroom, the victim addressed his abuser directly. “I have forgiven you but I will never forget. You knew I was damaged because of my parents divorce. I must have looked like an easy target to you,” he said. The man also gave the attorney general’s office permission to make his statement public.

How prosecutors say the abuse began
According to the attorney general’s office, Silva met the boy when his mother was taking evening lay-ministry classes at the diocese’s Office of Ministerial Formation between 1986 and June 13, 1990. After she divorced in 1987, she needed someone to watch her son, who was under 14.
Prosecutor Jonathan Burke, in the account he told the judge he would have proven at trial, said Silva began picking the boy up and taking him on outings — fast food, then driving lessons — and that the abuse escalated from touching over clothing.
Prosecutors say it culminated in a sex act at Silva’s home on South Carpenter Street in East Providence. This report keeps those details at the level the case records establish.
The boy kept the abuse secret for decades. In 2019, he contacted the Roman Catholic Diocese of Providence, which referred the matter to the Rhode Island State Police; the state police conducted the investigation that led to the 2021 indictment.
The victim’s statement drew on relapse and recovery
“What you did to me has made my life very hard to live. I have been in legal troubles because of not caring about myself do to the abuse I suffered at your hand.”
Those words, read in open court Thursday, came from Ronald McKeon, now 49, whom local reporting identifies as the victim. He told Silva he had suffered complex PTSD, recurring nightmares and drug addiction, and had questioned his faith.
“Now let me tell you that today I am sober and have a relationship with my sons. I have a wonderful woman in my life that loved me when I couldn’t love myself. My relationship with God is as strong as it can be today. I still have my PTSD and will soon start treatment for it.”
“This day was a long time coming for you and I’m glad it’s here. I hope to have closer after this and continue to build the life you stole from me. May God forgive you and may I keep praying for you.”
Bishop Gelineau warned repeatedly about Silva
Silva’s history with the church long predates this case. He joined the ministry in 1967 and was removed in March 1993. He already appears on the diocese’s list of clergy credibly accused of sexual abuse.
Court records cited in the reporting say then-Bishop Louis Gelineau was allegedly warned repeatedly about Silva through the 1970s and 1980s, yet moved him from parish to parish — roughly 12 transfers in about 15 years. When a Catholic Navy chaplain raised one case with Gelineau in 1981, the bishop is said to have answered: “Oh, no, Not again!”
Silva was sent to a treatment center in New Mexico, but molested another boy in 1991 after returning to Rhode Island, according to court records. He pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual assault in 1995 and received a seven-year suspended sentence with probation — again no jail time. Gelineau himself has been accused in a lawsuit filed this fall of raping a boy in Barrington in the 1980s.
The lawsuits behind the criminal case
McKeon has also sued the diocese, one of roughly 200 civil suits filed since the Rhode Island legislature opened a two-year revival window on July 1 for decades-old child sex abuse claims previously barred by time limits. Two other men have separately sued Silva and the Providence diocese over alleged abuse.
The two accounts of Thursday’s sentencing agree in substance but part on one detail: local court reporting describes the punishment as a 10-year suspended sentence with probation, while broadcast reporting out of Rhode Island describes it as sentencing Silva, per court documents, to 10 years of probation with sex offender registration and no contact with victims.
What is not yet known: whether the diocese will respond to the plea, and how the roughly 200 revival-window suits — McKeon’s among them — will move forward. The civil claims now stand as the venue where the church’s handling of Silva over some 15 years of transfers could still be weighed.
For McKeon, the record of the day ends where he left it, facing the man across the courtroom: “I have forgiven you but I will never forget.”