The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) has notified 63 employees that they face mandatory demotions to lower-paid roles because medical or psychological conditions prevent them from carrying a sidearm, CBC reported.
The move changes how the federal agency manages its workforce of 8,500 armed front-line officers. In a formal notice to the impacted employees, the CBSA characterized the demotions as a “downward deployment without salary protection,” framing the measure as a necessary component of its “reasonable accommodation process.”
While the agency provides temporary relief for short-term medical issues, it maintains that permanent inability to carry a firearm renders an officer unfit for their current position.
Mark Weber, president of the Customs and Immigration Union, labeled the policy an arbitrary and discriminatory practice that discards decades of institutional knowledge. “Essentially, they are being told by their employer that they no longer have value simply because they can no longer carry a firearm,” Weber told CBC.
One affected officer, speaking on the condition of anonymity, described the experience as dehumanizing: “I felt like a file being closed, not a human being.”
At the heart of the conflict is a disagreement over what constitutes the “essential duties” of a border officer. The CBSA argues that the capacity to use force is intrinsically tied to the role, even if the actual discharge of a weapon is rare.
Agency data shows that CBSA officers across Canada draw their sidearms an average of only 28 times per year. Despite this, spokesperson Kelly Cameron said that the agency must spend public funds judiciously, ensuring that employees meet the core requirements of armed positions.
The union disputes this necessity, pointing to a wide range of daily tasks that do not require a weapon, including analyzing flight manifests, managing the Nexus program, and training new recruits. According to the union, many of these roles are already filled by officers who are not carrying firearms, making the demotions a punitive choice rather than an operational requirement.
The administrative strain is already evident. Beyond the 63 officers facing immediate demotion, 14 others on sick leave are currently under review. Since January, 36 officers have opted for retirement rather than accept the forced reassignment. In total, 190 employees were receiving some form of firearm-related accommodation; of those, 27 were successfully transferred to roles at their existing pay grade, while 50 returned to full duty following medical clearance.
The CBSA’s specific mandate involves high-stakes tasks like drug interdiction and deportations, which the agency insists requires a fully deployable force.
As the CBSA prepares to finalize these transfers in the coming weeks, the union remains in opposition. The agency has said that there are “no longer any suitable placement opportunities” for the 63 affected officers at their current classification levels. For those involved, the transition results in lost income and lower professional standing after years of service.
The officer who spoke to CBC emphasized that their value was never tied to the firearm itself, but to their experience in the field. “The firearm never helped me do that job. My experience did. That experience didn’t disappear when I stopped being able to carry my gun,” the officer said.