The Tim Hortons app has been sending sensitive user data to Forter, an Israeli cybertech firm founded by alumni of the military’s Unit 8200 intelligence division, the advocacy group Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East confirmed on Tuesday, November 17.
The Montreal-based group identified the company after contacting Joel Reardon, the University of Calgary computer scientist whose analysis underpinned a CBC News investigation published on November 13. That report found the coffee chain’s app begins transmitting information the moment it launches: unique device identifiers, camera specifications, lists of sensors and the names of nearby Wi-Fi networks, all sent to an unnamed overseas third party.
CBC did not name the recipient, saying “accountability rests with the app developer.”
The Wi-Fi details can be used to determine a person’s location, Reardon told the CBC. The combination is enough to build a digital fingerprint of each device that can be identified later. “This was beyond the pale,” he told the CBC.
Rights group demands a cut-off
CJPME’s vice president, Michael Bueckert, called on the chain to end the relationship at once.

“Canadians ordering coffee should not have their unique and sensitive user data shared with an Israeli cyber-tech company whose infrastructure was built by alumni of a foreign military intelligence agency engaged in human rights violations,” Bueckert said.
“The company’s ties to an Israeli military unit that oversees the mass surveillance of Palestinians pose significant ethical issues, raising alarm bells for anyone concerned about cyber-security. Tim Hortons must cut ties with this company immediately,” he added in the group’s statement.
Jason Toney, CJPME’s director of media advocacy, went further against the broadcaster itself, arguing its reporting understated the risk. “CBC’s reporting obscures the true scale of the privacy risk Tim Hortons has exposed its users to. CBC is letting Tim Hortons and Forter off the hook. Canadians deserve to understand the truth,” he said. The group has raised the omission with the CBC’s ombud.
Tim Hortons defends the data
The company told the CBC that it collects the information only for “fraud prevention, account protection, and payment abuse prevention” — not for marketing or advertising. Michael Oliveira, Tim Hortons’ director of communications, added that the third party is barred from selling the data and that the chain does not sell users’ personal information to data brokers.
Too much data, experts say
Privacy specialists questioned whether buying a coffee justifies any of this. “The collection occurs before consent, and in my view is excessive,” Reardon told Al Jazeera. Celeste Rollason, an independent analyst who reviewed the findings for the CBC, said the amount of data gathered “seems quite excessive” for a fraud-protection service.
Digital rights group OpenMedia weighed in through its executive director, Matt Hatfield. “People open the Tim Hortons app to order a coffee, not have their data, including location indicators, exported to foreign companies,” he told Al Jazeera — while noting Tim Hortons is hardly alone in the practice.
He said questions about a vendor’s foreign military ties deserve answers whichever country is involved, and that at minimum the company should name every third party receiving app data, disclose where it is stored and who can access it.

Johanna Gunawan, an assistant professor of computer science and law at Maastricht University, told Al Jazeera that companies should answer for their vendors’ practices. “That’s simple transparency and due diligence,” she said.
Not the first privacy offence
The scrutiny lands on a chain with a record. In 2022, Canada’s federal and provincial privacy commissioners found the app had tracked users’ locations without adequate consent — even when the app was closed. Hatfield noted Tim Hortons faced no fines because Canada’s privacy regulator cannot issue them.
The Unit 8200 connection carries its own weight. In September 2025, Microsoft cut the unit off from some of its cloud and AI services after an investigation found its technology had facilitated mass surveillance of Palestinians.

The division has also been linked to Lavender, the AI system Israel has used to target Palestinians in Gaza. Toney cautioned, though, against assuming Forter uses Tim Hortons data in a “nefarious” manner — there is no evidence of that, and he described the firm as well established.
Forter was founded in 2013 by software engineers who had previously worked at Fraud Sciences, a firm bought and integrated into PayPal in 2008. The company sells fraud prevention and payment optimization services, applying artificial intelligence to decide whether a digital transaction comes from a legitimate customer or a fraudster.
Since its founding it says it has processed more than $1 trillion in digital commerce transactions and built a dataset of more than 1.5 billion online identities. In May 2021 it raised $300 million from investors led by Tiger Global Management, valuing the company at $3 billion.
- 2018 — The Jerusalem Post reports Forter’s technology is enhanced by Israeli military intelligence.
- 2022 — Canadian privacy commissioners find the Tim Hortons app collected location data without adequate consent.
- September 2025 — Microsoft disables services used by Unit 8200 over mass surveillance of Palestinians.
- November 13, 2026 — CBC publishes its investigation without naming the third-party recipient.
- November 17, 2026 — CJPME confirms the recipient is Forter and urges Tim Hortons to cut ties.
Al Jazeera was unable to confirm whether Forter still uses Israeli military intelligence, or whether any data it holds is accessible to Israeli government or military agencies. As Hatfield put it: “And frankly, it shouldn’t be giving our data to anyone when its business is selling coffee and doughnuts!”