Israeli Military Uploaded 3.5m Palestinian Photos to Amazon for Facial Recognition

3.5 million photographs of Palestinians were uploaded by Israel’s military to Amazon’s cloud in early 2024 so the company’s Rekognition facial recognition system could analyze them, The Guardian revealed, citing leaked documents and interviews with military sources.

An Israeli military department known as Rolling Stone, which maintains an extensive catalogue of images documenting Palestinian populations in Gaza and the West Bank, is the destination of the upload, according to The Guardian’s investigation which relies on reporting from Harry Davies, producer of the Guardian-backed documentary NAZA, and director Yuval Abraham.

The photos were moved into Amazon’s cloud during the early months of Israel’s aerial bombardment and ground offensive in Gaza.

The Jerusalem Post covered the same findings, which were revealed in reporting by The Guardian.

How the uploads fit a longer migration

The Guardian’s documents show Rolling Stone transferred significant volumes of data into a segregated segment of Amazon Web Services throughout 2023 — an area the company and its client called a “walled garden.”

The legal foundation is Project Nimbus, the multibillion-dollar 2021 contract under which AWS and Google provide cloud services to Israeli government and military clients.

The Guardian revealed last year that the contract prohibits the US companies from restricting or suspending Israeli use of their cloud even if Israel breaches their terms of service — a clause that would block the kind of unilateral cutoff Microsoft imposed last year after a mass surveillance system was uncovered by the Guardian and +972 Magazine.

Israeli Military Uploaded 3.5m Palestinian Photos to Amazon for Facial Recognition
Photo: The Jerusalem Post

Checkpoints as pop-up surveillance posts

After the start of the ground operation in Gaza in October 2023, the military also collected images of Palestinians at temporary checkpoints. Sources privy to the work indicated that these images were routinely incorporated into facial recognition schemes, such as the Blue Wolf application utilized by Israeli soldiers operating in the West Bank. It is not clear whether the 3.5 million uploaded photos came from these checkpoints.

Israel has long scanned faces at West Bank checkpoints and used smartphone applications to collect images.

The Rolling Stone system itself — described by a soldier testifying to the NGO Breaking the Silence in 2016 as “a computerised system where all the information relevant to the control of the Palestinian civilian population is centralised” — holds personal and family information, property details, checkpoint crossings, work permits, and data on criminal activity, alongside ID-card photographs taken when every resident turns 16.

Israel uploaded to amazon fac
Photo: UA.NEWS

During the early stages of the war, the military also used Rekognition to identify hostages abducted in the October 7 attacks and individuals suspected of terrorist activity. Prior reporting by The New York Times detailed that the IDF had conducted trials involving commercial facial recognition technology within Gaza for the purpose of identifying people within crowds and drone footage.

Inside the Tel Aviv skyscraper

According to several military sources, during early 2024, a small team of Israeli soldiers was working out of AWS’s Tel Aviv offices—situated on the 28th floor of a prominent Israeli skyscraper—investigating methods to leverage the company’s cloud infrastructure for better management of a facial recognition program currently active in Gaza.

Whether that work was made operational — or if it related to the 3.5 million images uploaded to Rekognition — is not clear.

AWS pushed back. “We respect the privacy of our customers, and we do not discuss our relationship without their consent,” a spokesperson said, adding the company has no “visibility” into workloads customers run in its cloud.

On the office visits: customers “regularly visit our offices for briefings and meetings,” and any suggestion that the visits were anything other than routine customer engagement “is wrong and unsubstantiated,” the spokesperson told The Guardian.

In response to inquiries, the IDF stated to The Jerusalem Post that it refrains from providing comments regarding contracts or services pertaining to operational requirements.

The timeline in one place

Date Development
2021 Project Nimbus agreement signed: AWS and Google provide cloud services to Israeli state and military structures
Throughout 2023 Rolling Stone transfers significant volumes of data to a “walled garden” segment of AWS’s cloud
October 2023 Start of the ground operation in Gaza; checkpoint image collection begins; Rekognition used on hostages and suspects
Early 2024 3.5 million photos uploaded to Rekognition; small group of Israeli soldiers works from AWS’s offices in Tel Aviv

Why the world’s investors should read this closely

The 2021 Project Nimbus agreement, under which Amazon provides cloud services to Israel, forms the basis of the cooperation between the Israeli military and the cloud provider. The Guardian’s files suggest the ties between AWS and the Israeli military deepened.

It’s not clear whether the soldiers’ work was made operational or if it related to the 3.5 million images uploaded to Rekognition. The IDF told The Jerusalem Post that it does not comment on contracts or services related to operational needs.

From early December, NAZA will be available to view free on the Guardian’s website, in addition to currently showing in theaters worldwide.

Photo of author

Alexandra Hartman Editor-in-Chief

Editor-in-Chief Prize-winning journalist with over 20 years of international news experience. Alexandra leads the editorial team, ensuring every story meets the highest standards of accuracy and journalistic integrity.

The Haredim Are Back: Israel’s Election and the Politics of Coalition