The Haredim Are Back: Israel’s Election and the Politics of Coalition

In a discussion published on November 11 by the Shalom Hartman Institute, co-hosts Donniel Hartman and Yossi Klein Halevi analyzed the surprise return of ultra-Orthodox political parties to coalition viability following deadlocked election results.

The conversation aired on their podcast, “For Heaven’s Sake”, produced in collaboration with Ark Media, under the title “The Haredim Are Back”.

The new Knesset is scheduled to be installed on Tuesday, with a new Speaker of the House expected to take office the following week. According to the co-hosts, the non-Netanyahu bloc, which holds at least a Knesset majority, is expected to begin legislative processes, even though no path to a government has emerged.

Hartman described the results as an election in which nobody won, nobody lost, and nobody has anything, while Klein Halevi observed that everyone is back in play — Benjamin Netanyahu, Eisenkot and others alike. Despite previous assumptions that any viable governing coalition would exclude the ultra-Orthodox parties under a covenant of those who serve, changing seat counts have altered the political situation.

Avigdor Lieberman stated on X that he would not accept a minority government supported by Arab parties, concluding that such an arrangement would quickly collapse and hand Benjamin Netanyahu a victory in a subsequent election. Lieberman indicated willingness to compromise regarding the ultra-Orthodox factions to avoid that outcome.

Israel Votes: The Haredim Are Back

Klein Halevi described a feeling of deflation upon realizing that no alternative coalition exists. He said that the election offered an opportunity to alter the separatist status quo and integrate the Haredi community more closely into mainstream civic responsibilities.

“What I think so many of us were hoping for was that this would be the, the opportunity to finally do a fundamental reset in our relationship with the Haredi world,” Klein Halevi told the Shalom Hartman Institute.

Klein Halevi added that bringing the Haredi parties into the government signals their indispensability, which threatens to perpetuate an unbalanced relationship that drains state resources as the community grows.

Donniel Hartman described a conflicted initial reaction to the development, noting an immediate sense of excitement tied to the prospect of removing Netanyahu. However, he ultimately concluded that the returning influence of the Haredi parties under these conditions prevents the compromises necessary for his vision of the state.

The co-hosts also discussed the role of Mansour Abbas, who had appeared at the Shalom Hartman Institute and, according to Hartman, accepts Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people.

“I’m willing to declare that Hamas is a terrorist organization,” Abbas said, according to Hartman.

By Omar El Sayed

Photo of author

Omar El Sayed - World Editor

Omar El Sayed is Archyde’s World Editor, focused on international affairs, diplomacy, conflict, and cross-border political developments. He brings a global newsroom perspective to complex events and helps readers understand how regional stories connect to wider geopolitical shifts.

Study Links Hypnic Jerks to Distress and Poorer Sleep for Some