Controversy Over Polish Athlete of the Year Nominees as Semeniuk and Ratajski Are Omitted

Kamil Semeniuk, who according to one expert won European championship gold, Nations League gold, Champions League gold and a club world title in twelve months, is not among the nominees for Poland’s Sportowiec Roku (Athlete of the Year) award.

Neither is darts star Krzysztof Ratajski.

The nominees for the long-running plebiscite organized by Przegląd Sportowy span many disciplines. The list includes Iga Świątek, Maja Chwalińska, Hubert Hurkacz, Robert Lewandowski, Ewa Pajor, Bartosz Zmarzlik, Wilfredo Leon and Jeremy Sochan, as well as Pia Skrzyszowska, Adrian Meronk and reigning champion Klaudia Zwolińska, according to the published list of nominees.

Two names on the list draw particular attention. Tennis player Maja Chwalińska reached the final of Roland Garros and won a WTA 1000 tournament in Wuhan, according to WP SportoweFakty. Ski jumper Kacper Tomasiak took three medals at the Milan-Cortina 2026 Winter Olympics, and many observers see him as the favorite for the main prize.

The absence of Semeniuk, the volleyball star, and Ratajski, the darts player nicknamed “The Polish Eagle,” has dominated the reaction. “Brak nominacji dla ‘The Polish Eagle’ to nieporozumienie. Kamil Semeniuk też miał swój gwiezdny czas. I w Perugii i w kadrze. Drugi wielki nieobecny,” said Mateusz Borek, journalist and commentator for Kanał Sportowy and TVP Sport.

Semeniuk’s trophy haul, and a spot outside the top 25

Jakub Balcerzak of the channel “Prawda Siatki” laid out Semeniuk’s record in detail: European championship gold, Nations League gold, Champions League gold, Club World Championship gold, the Italian league title and two Italian Super Cups across twelve months.

“Naprawdę?! Poza TOP25?! Nieprawdopodobne…” Balcerzak wrote of the volleyball player’s exclusion.

Kacper Czuba of TVN24 framed the contrast directly. “Z całą moją sympatią i szacunkiem, ale danie do TOP25 Jeremy’ego Sochana (mistrzostwo NBA, ale wypadł z ligi, marginalna gra), a nie wzięcie Kamila Semeniuka po świetnym roku, zakrawa co najmniej na kontrowersję,” Czuba said.

Karol Tyniec, a journalist with iGol and Legia.Net, said Sochan’s inclusion was puzzling given his minimal participation, while calling the nominations for Pajor and Lewandowski fully deserved — though he added this is likely Lewandowski’s last appearance among the award’s nominees.

“Jest, uwaga, Jeremy Sochan. Nie ma Semeniuka i Ratajskiego. Cóż,” was the curt verdict of Jan Piekutowski of the portal Meczyki.

“A tak serio, to kompromitacja”

The sharpest words came from the darts community. “Krzysztof Ratajski nie znalazł się w gronie nominowanych do nagrody Sportowca Roku, gdyż to Sportowiec Roku powinien dostawać nagrodę Krzysztofa Ratajskiego. A tak serio, to kompromitacja, że Rataj po takim roku nie ma nominacji,” said Damian Smyk of the channel “Tetrycy.”

Others kept it shorter. “A gdzie jest Krzysztof Ratajski?” asked Jarosław Kuś of Polsat. Maciej Łanczkowski, editor of the weekly Piłka Nożna, went further, saying Ratajski deserved the nomination more than Lewandowski. Kuba Łokietek, darts expert and commentator for Canal+ Sport, joked that Ratajski skips the nominee stage altogether and goes straight to winning the Super Champion title.

Janusz Siennicki of WP SportoweFakty left a single-word-style comment — “Kamil Semeniuk???” — under Przegląd Sportowy Onet’s announcement post.

Tyniec, for his part, still named a favorite despite the controversy. “Faworytem mimo różnych spekulacji pozostaje dla mnie Kacper Tomasiak. Trzy medale muszą dać miano najlepszego sportowca,” he said.

A plebiscite dating back to 1926

The Sportowiec Roku poll is Poland’s oldest sports award of its kind. It has been held since 1926, when Wacław Kuchar became the first winner. The record of five victories belongs to Justyna Kowalczyk. The Gala of Champions, where the result will be announced, will be broadcast by Televizja Polska.

Semeniuk, born in 1996 in Kędzierzyn-Koźle, began his senior career at ZAKSA Kędzierzyn-Koźle in 2015, winning three Polish Championships, three Polish Cups and two CEV Champions League titles before moving to Sir Safety Perugia in 2022.

With the national team, whose debut came in 2021 against Belgium, he took silver at the 2022 World Championship and at the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris. In 2022 he was named CEV Male Volleyball Player of the Year and MVP of the Champions League.

Whether the backlash forces any reconsideration of the shortlist is not addressed in the published materials. What is clear is that the debate has centered on a single question — how a year like Semeniuk’s, or Ratajski’s, fails to earn a place among 25 nominees.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Québec City Reveals 2027 Canada Games Ceremony Line-Up 100 Days Out