The COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, concluded on Sunday without a final agreement after two weeks of negotiations reached a deadlock over the future of fossil fuels.
The collapse of the talks marks the first time a major UN climate summit has failed to produce an overarching political pact since 2009, according to the BBC.
- Negotiators in Antalya failed to agree on a final “cover decision” after the longest summit in UN history.
- The European Union, Panama, and several Pacific island nations rejected drafts that omitted a direct reference to fossil fuels.
- A proposed target to increase electricity’s share of final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 had backing from over 90 countries.
The impasse centered on the terminology used to describe the transition away from oil, coal, and gas. While more than 100 countries pushed to retain language calling for a transition away from fossil fuels—a commitment established at the 2023 Dubai talks—oil-producing nations, including Saudi Arabia, maintained that such phrasing was unacceptable, CNN reported.
“I would have been happy with transition away from fossil fuels being in the text, but that was not going to get support,” said Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister and a co-president of the negotiations, to The Guardian. “but the red lines he and his staff tried to negotiate were” unbridgeable, Chris Bowen, Australia's climate minister and a co-president of the negotiations, told journalists. “unbridgeable.”
🌍 Are climate promises translating into action? At #COP31, countries launched a new global progress check as divisions persist over finance, fossil fuels and a just transition. With time running out, cooperation is crucial.https://t.co/IZoE92ynEm
“they said was non-negotiable – that any agreement from the summit must refer to the need for the world to” transition away from fossil fuels, many negotiators told Bowen, the co-president of the negotiations.
Disagreement on Energy and Finance
The final drafts proposed by the co-presidencies of Australia and Turkey sought to address these divisions by “recalling” the Dubai consensus in its entirety without explicitly naming fossil fuels, as reported by AP News. This omission drew sharp criticism from the European Union, which labeled the text insufficient to address the climate emergency.
“We have done our utmost, but it is clear that there are parties in this hall who oppose this text. We recognize that there is no consensus on this document,” said Murat Kurum, the COP31 president, as reported by CNN. Ireland’s climate minister, Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU, stated the bloc could not endorse any agreement that failed to mention fossil fuels, according to The Independent.
Beyond the energy language, the summit also stalled over financial commitments. Many developing nations expressed frustration at the lack of clear, actionable pledges from wealthier countries to support adaptation efforts against climate-driven disasters, the BBC reported.
Now that #COP31 has concluded, I want to send a message to civil society, young people, Indigenous Peoples, scientists & frontline communities: Keep spreading the facts. Keep demanding #ClimateAction. Keep turning up the heat. Hold governments and companies to account.… pic.twitter.com/Nvsp2FOHeh
Diplomatic Deadlock Over Fossil Fuel Language
The impasse in Antalya was driven by a fundamental disagreement over terminology. Russia also warned against turning to slogans, claiming that moving away from coal, oil, and gas too quickly could trigger fuel poverty.
The conflict intensified as the summit progressed. Although the first draft of the “cover decision” explicitly called for an immediate transition away from fossil fuels, those references were stripped from every subsequent version. Longtime analyst Alden Meyer said that fossil fuels went unmentioned in final decisions for over 25 years, primarily due to persistent objections from Saudi Arabia.

Criticism of Compromise and Future Reform
This approach drew sharp rebukes from climate advocates and several national delegations. Denise Cauchi, chief executive of Climate Action Network Australia, argued the summit failed to broker an agreement and caved to lobbyists promoting controversial carbon capture technology.
Other critics expressed profound dissatisfaction with the process. Harjeet Singh, a veteran of climate negotiations, warned that the crisis cannot be solved by pretending a phase-out is unnecessary, while climate scientist Bill Hare cautioned that electrification fueled by coal and gas fails to limit warming.
COP31 President Murat Kurum ultimately acknowledged the impasse, stating there was no agreement on the text, and urged that future summits must build upon previous achievements rather than stepping back.
As a senior figure in the Labor Party, Chris Bowen has served as the member of Parliament for the division of McMahon since 2004 and held various ministerial roles in the Rudd and Gillard governments between 2007 and 2013. He currently serves as Australia’s minister for climate change and energy, a position he has held in the Albanese government since 2022.
In his capacity as a co-president of the COP31 UN Climate Change Summit, Chris Bowen led negotiations aimed at securing an overarching political pact. During the summit, he worked to navigate the diplomatic impasse over fossil fuel terminology, attempting to bridge deep-seated divisions between nations while managing the complex process of reaching a unanimous global consensus.
I'm deeply disappointed that #COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome. I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands. But this setback does not change the facts. There may be no… pic.twitter.com/SBMZPpfU5l
The breakdown has prompted calls to reform the UN climate negotiation process, which relies on unanimous consensus. Former US vice-president Al Gore described it as “an outrage” that a small group of petrostates could veto global climate action, according to The Guardian.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres issued a statement on November 22 expressing deep disappointment in the outcome.
“There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science,” Guterres said.
While the primary pact failed, participants did reach agreements on several secondary processes, including a framework for a “just transition” to support workers shifting into clean energy sectors, the BBC noted. It remains unclear how the failure to secure a broader agreement in Antalya will impact the mandates for COP32.
More on Saudi Arabia
🌍 Calls for a stronger climate deal intensified as #COP31 reached its final scheduled day. Countries across regions demanded explicit action on fossil fuels and stronger climate finance. Read the report from Antalya 👇https://t.co/hrgsH3Zfb9
Related reading