“There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science,” UN Secretary-General António Guterres said on Sunday as COP31 ended without a deal.
The United Nations climate talks collapsed after negotiators failed to secure an agreement on how to handle climate change. Al Jazeera reported that the summit extended into overtime following strong opposition from key oil- and gas-producing countries against any mention of fossil fuels in the final text.
The annual talks last failed to reach an agreement in Copenhagen in 2009. If approved, the draft text would have acknowledged for the first time that global warming is on course to exceed the 1.5 degrees Celsius, or 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit, threshold from the 2015 Paris Agreement, while also dropping a $120bn target for adaptation funds for poorer nations.
“I am deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome,” Guterres said, sharing what he described as profound frustration with those who expected governments to rise to the moment.
Delegates and negotiating blocs clashed sharply over the draft presented by COP31 presidents Türkiye and Australia. The European Union stated it would not endorse a deal that greenwashes fossil fuels, while Denmark’s climate minister, Samira Nawa, argued that the text’s mitigation language and science references were not strong enough.
Vulnerable nations expressed outrage over the outcome. The Marshall Islands delegation said that they had been let down on all sides, warning that they would not be forced to accept false solutions or compromise their future for fossil fuel interests.
Major oil and gas exporters defended their stance during the deadlock.
Delegations from various climate-vulnerable regions voiced intense dissatisfaction following the breakdown of the Antalya summit. The Vanuatu delegation said that the text fell short of international legal requirements, scientific demands, and community needs while remaining silent on fossil fuels.
The Least Developed Countries group pointed out that they struggled to find meaningful outcomes responding to their priorities. Meanwhile, Kenya complained that the draft failed to mention Africa or account for the continent’s special needs and circumstances.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres urged that the priority must now be accelerating and financing the shift away from fossil fuels agreed upon at COP28 in Dubai. He stressed that those least responsible for climate change should not bear the heaviest consequences alone.
Australian minister Chris Bowen said that the transition away from fossil fuels proved to be a central stumbling block during the negotiations. He explained that while some parties insisted the shift must be explicitly mentioned, others threatened a veto if it was included.
As COP31 co-president alongside Australia, Türkiye — represented by Murat Kurum, its minister of environment, urbanisation and climate change — presided over the Antalya summit where the draft text was presented to delegations. The EU stated it would not endorse a deal that greenwashes fossil fuels, while vulnerable nations including the Marshall Islands and Vanuatu denounced the outcome for remaining silent on fossil fuels and failing legal and scientific demands.
COP31 president Murat Kurum, Türkiye’s minister of environment, urbanisation and climate change, told a closing plenary that no new text would be carried out without consensus and that existing decisions would be implemented. Chris Bowen, Australia’s minister of climate change and energy and COP31’s president of negotiations, called the collapse very disappointing while highlighting commitments like an electrification pledge signed by more than 90 countries.