Coronial Inquest Hears Four NSW Babies Died After Free Births Without Medical Checks

A coronial inquest in Lismore has heard four babies died in the Northern Rivers region between 2022 and 2024 after free births or home births where routine medical checks were absent, the Guardian reported.

Neonatologist Associate Professor Nicholas Evans told the court on Friday that Baby DH, who lived eight hours after a free birth in Byron Bay, had complex heart abnormalities “readily detectable” on a standard pregnancy scan.

“The site of [Baby DH’s] birth meant that he didn’t have a chance,” Evans said. The same expert linked Baby R’s death at 43 weeks to a due-date recalculation by birth keeper Sita Tara Kali that pushed the delivery past the 42-week safety limit.

Four Deaths, One Region

The inquest is examining the deaths of Baby DH, Baby D, Baby R, and Baby B. Three followed free births — deliveries without medical professionals — and one followed a planned home birth. Evans said routine antenatal care would have identified the twin pregnancy that led to Baby D’s stillbirth, the post-maturity risk for Baby R, and the Group B streptococcus infection that likely killed Baby B.

Mother Unaware of Twins During Free Birth Inquest — Newsreel

Baby D’s mother did not know she was carrying twins until the second baby was born stillborn. Evans told the court the “root cause” was the missed twin diagnosis at 18 weeks. Baby R’s mother had a 12-week ultrasound dating the birth to 28 July 2020, but Kali advised calculating from conception, moving the due date to mid-August.

An ultrasound on 19 August showed a medical emergency; Kali reportedly told the mother to “go home and rest.” Baby B’s mother declined ultrasounds and a GBS test despite warnings from four attending midwives. GBS is present in 15 to 20 percent of women and infects about 2 percent of carriers’ babies, Evans said.

The Doula’s Role

Doula Amy Lou Smith, hired for $2,000 to watch for warning signs during Baby DH’s birth, denied giving clinical advice. Parents told the court Smith reassured them repeatedly as the baby turned purple, became floppy, and struggled to breathe. Smith left the home to set up a jumping castle before an ambulance was called.

“I believed if they had real concerns, that they would call an ambulance and not be texting a non medically trained doula,” Smith told the court, according to au.headtopics.com. The parents said they would have called Triple Zero immediately if not for her reassurances.

Doula Denies Clinical Advice as Inquest Hears Baby DH Died After Free Birth in Byron Bay
Photo: au.headtopics.com

Clinical Gaps and Missed Windows

Paediatric cardiologist Dr Paul Brooks said Baby DH’s abnormalities would “highly likely” have been identified prenatally, triggering a birth plan at a major hospital with cardiac surgery. For Baby R, Evans wrote that the due-date recalculation was the “root cause” of the post-maturity death.

Standard practice forbids pregnancies beyond 42 completed weeks. Expert midwives told the court they lack statistics for births beyond 43 weeks because they are so rare. Baby B’s twin survived after hospital treatment for the same GBS infection.

The Northern Rivers is the most northeasterly region of New South Wales, stretching from Tweed Heads at the Queensland border south to the Clarence River catchment between Grafton and Coffs Harbour. It encompasses the fertile valleys of the Clarence, Richmond and Tweed rivers and includes the main towns of Byron Bay, Ballina, Lismore, Casino and Grafton.

The area has a mild, sub-tropical climate and is known for tourism and agriculture, including macadamia cultivation on the volcanic soils inland from Byron Bay. The village of Nimbin, near Lismore, attracts visitors for its counterculture and alternative living initiatives.

Baby Birth Context Key Finding Expert Assessment
Baby DH Free birth, doula only Complex heart abnormalities Detectable on routine scan; birth site meant “no chance”
Baby D Free birth, birth keeper Undiagnosed twin pregnancy “Root cause” missed 18-week diagnosis
Baby R Free birth, birth keeper Born at 43+ weeks Due-date recalculation “root cause” of post-maturity
Baby B Home birth, four midwives GBS, pneumonia, sepsis Mother declined GBS test; antibiotics in hospital save most

Deputy State Coroner Joan Baptie continues to hear evidence. The inquest is ongoing.

Inquest Reveals Birth Keeper's Advice Before Baby's Death — Newsreel
Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

SC Health Officials Warn After Rabid Cat, Raccoon Expose Person, Pet Cat