Costa Rica Experts Warn Tokenizing Natural Resources via Bill 25.893 Requires Strict Regulation

Experts warned that tokenizing natural resources via Liberation Party lawmaker Diana Murillo's legislative initiative 25.893 requires strict regulation.

Costa Rica’s bid to fund environmental remediation through blockchain tokens hit a regulatory wall Friday as experts warned that digitizing natural resources requires enforceable legal frameworks, not just distributed-ledger infrastructure.

The warning came during a webinar hosted by LEAD University, where financial regulation specialist Rainer Brenes told elmundo.cr that token issuance must be anchored by “a valued asset, enforceable rights, and sufficient demand.” Without precise definitions of payment sources, participant risks, and administrator responsibilities, the technology merely wraps speculation in cryptographic packaging, according to Elmundo.

The debate centers on legislative initiative 25.893, championed by Liberation Party lawmaker Diana Murillo. The bill proposes sanitizing materials contaminated by illegal mining in the Crucitas zone and issuing digital assets backed by gold reserves that would remain unextracted underground.

Geologists have dismantled the premise. Former Environment and Energy Minister René Castro acknowledged the country's payments-for-ecosystem-services track record provides a foundation, but stressed the challenge is guaranteeing protection over decades, not quarters.

Bernardo Aguilar, president of the Civic Environmental Parliament, drew a distinction the market often ignores. “A preserved gold inventory can help delineate a geological vault, but does not by itself represent a cash flow,” he said. Success metrics must track ecosystem restoration and community wellbeing, not token price action.

This mirrors a structural flaw in asset-backed token projects globally: the oracle problem. Smart contracts cannot verify physical gold remains in situ without trusted off-chain attestation. In a region where state presence is contested, that attestation layer collapses.

Rafael Sánchez, the webinar moderator, framed the stakes bluntly: "Costa Rica does not need to turn its natural resources into commodities to recognize their value." The statement highlights a jurisdictional gap. No current framework defines whether such tokens constitute securities, commodities, or a novel asset class — leaving investors exposed and enforcement agencies blind.

Elmundo.cr reported the discussion concluded with a call for caution over speed. Collector.com.tr carried the same dispatch, confirming the consensus crosses outlets. The legislation remains in committee. No timeline for a vote has been published.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Docket Commenters Call for Flexibility in Rare Disease Trial Design and Evidence, but Question