Credit union members use rewards programs at a much lower rate than national bank customers, leaving a 31-percentage-point gap between executive perception and consumer behavior.
While 45% of credit union leaders believe their rewards outperform competitors, only 14% of members view these incentives as a primary advantage of their institution.
- Only 14% of credit union members engaged with loyalty programs in the past year, compared to 25% of national bank customers.
- 44% of credit union members with multiple cards prioritize rewards when selecting which payment method to reach for at checkout.
- 32% of consumers who bank primarily elsewhere indicated that competitive rewards could incentivize a switch to a credit union.
The gap between internal strategy and member behavior, highlighted in the November 2026 Credit Union Tracker from PYMNTS Intelligence and Velera, suggests a fundamental misalignment in retail banking. While nearly half of credit union executives perceive their rewards as superior to those of their largest competitors, the data indicates that members do not share this sentiment.
Among consumers holding multiple cards, 40% identify better incentives—specifically cashback—as the primary factor in card selection. For credit union members, that influence is even higher, at 44%. Consequently, a member may maintain their primary checking and savings accounts within the credit union system while routing the bulk of their high-frequency, high-value card spending to national competitors that offer more aggressive reward structures.
The movement of transaction volume away from credit unions threatens to diminish their standing as the primary financial institution for their own members. For those who maintain multiple cards, 60% explicitly stated they do so to maximize rewards.
Among consumers currently banking elsewhere, 32% identified better rewards as a leading factor that could trigger a migration to a credit union. This trend is particularly evident among younger demographics; 37% of Generation Z and 36% of Millennials cite rewards as a key influence in their choice of a primary financial institution.
| Metric | Credit Union Members | National Bank Customers |
|---|---|---|
| Rewards Program Usage | 14% | 25% |
| Current Offering (CU Assets <$500M) | 31% | N/A |
| Executives Prioritizing Engagement (May 2026) | 53% | N/A |
Currently, only 31% of institutions with less than $500 million in assets provide loyalty programs. However, the industry is shifting; 43% of these smaller entities intend to launch such programs within the next three years.
To bridge this capability gap, many credit unions are turning toward external vendors. According to the research, 52% of executives are open to working with third-party partners to manage loyalty and engagement platforms. This reliance on external support rises to 58% among smaller institutions.
As Cody Banks, senior vice president of product experience and enablement at Velera, noted to CUToday, “Loyalty today is more than points or a program; it’s an outcome that issuers are looking to drive.”
The industry’s focus on this issue has intensified, with the percentage of executives identifying member engagement as a top innovation priority rising from 36% in late 2024 to 53% by May 2026. However, the mere implementation of a program does not guarantee success.
“The opportunity is not simply to offer rewards, but to make them an intentional part of a broader strategy for deepening member engagement and fueling long-term growth,” Banks told CUToday.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.