Czech Supreme Court Annuls Senate Election, Orders New Vote After One-Vote Margin

One vote. That was the margin that decided who went through to the second round of the Senate election in Czech district No. 51 on the Žďársko — and on Wednesday, Nov. 18, it proved one vote too many to trust.

The Supreme Administrative Court has annulled the October election in the Žďár nad Sázavou district and ordered the vote to be held again, Hospodářské noviny (HN.cz) reported. Only the second such ruling in Czech history.

The annulment strips Josef Klement of KDU-ČSL — the man who won the seat in a runoff on Oct. 17 — of a mandate he never got to pick up in person. While 20 other newly elected senators collected their certificates that day, Klement could not. The court, after recounting ballots from 26 precincts, found errors serious enough that the result could no longer stand, Seznam Zprávy reported.

Here is the arithmetic that started it all. In the first round, Klement advanced with 11,373 votes. Radek Černý of ODS took 11,372 — one vote short of the runoff. After the recount, Seznam Zprávy reported, Černý should have received at least two votes more. The margin was simply too thin to survive sloppy counting.

“V říjnu jsem získal důvěru od 12 254 z vás. Nechci, aby žádný z těch hlasů propadl,”[“In October I earned the trust of 12,254 of you. I don’t want a single one of those votes to go to waste,”] said Michal Šmarda, mayor of Nové Město na Moravě and former leader of SOCDEM, announcing he will run again.

Why the count fell apart

The court asked for ballots from 26 precincts, chiefly those with suspiciously high numbers of invalid votes. Judge-rapporteur Milan Podhrázský said the panel found irregularities — more or less serious — in 15 of the precincts reviewed, HN.cz reported. None of it, he stressed, was deliberate.

Czech Supreme Court Annuls Senate Election, Orders New Vote After One-Vote Margin
Photo: Seznam Zprávy

“Volební komise příliš spěchaly a nevěnovaly tomu dostatek péče,”[“The electoral commissions rushed too much and didn’t devote enough care to it,”] Podhrázský said, per HN.cz. In one precinct, commissions threw out two ballots as invalid merely because they were torn.

Elsewhere, the number of envelopes issued didn’t match the number of votes counted, sometimes by more than ten. In several precincts, the documentation was so disordered that no recount was possible at all.

Vojtěch Šimíček, who chairs the court’s electoral senate, gave iROZHLAS a concrete example: 320 envelopes issued, 320 cast, but the paperwork listed 12 fewer. “Můžeme spekulovat, zda se těch 12 obálek ztratilo nebo je komise vyhodila,”[“We can speculate whether those 12 envelopes got lost or the commission threw them out,”] he said, adding it created the impression the commission simply wanted the numbers to come out right.

Theoretically, the court could have sent Černý into the runoff instead and left it at that. But given the mess in the records, it couldn’t establish with certainty that Černý really had more votes, HN.cz reported.

So the whole election gets replayed — from the first round, with the same five candidates and no new registrations. The president must call the new vote within 30 days of receiving the ruling through the Interior Ministry.

Senatni volby zdarsko senat radek cerny josef klement michal smarda
Photo: Novinky

Back to the starting line

All three leading candidates are running again. Šmarda, who dominated the first round with 27.6 percent of the vote and then lost the runoff to Klement, is back — he was also just re-elected mayor of Nové Město na Moravě. Klement, who took 25.62 percent in round one and won the runoff with over 54 percent, says he feels stronger for it.

“Respektuji výrok Nejvyššího správního soudu a půjde se do toho znovu od prvního kola. Budu posílen vítězstvím z předchozích voleb,”[“I respect the Supreme Administrative Court’s ruling and we’ll go into it again from the first round. I’ll be strengthened by the previous election’s victory,”] Klement told ČTK.

Černý, the man whose one-vote deficit triggered all of this, is naturally back too. “Pro mě je nejcennější výsledek, že bude konečně jasno. Budu respektovat rozhodnutí soudu,”[“For me the most valuable outcome is that there will finally be clarity. I will respect the court’s decision,”] he told Seznam Zprávy earlier.

Radek Koten of SPD, who finished fourth, is still consulting his party leadership about running again, ČTK reported; David Moos of SD-SN, who finished fifth, has already confirmed on Facebook that he’s in, according to Hospodářské noviny (HN.cz).

Turnout is the open question. Runoffs for the Senate often draw paltry numbers, but the Žďársko second round managed a solid 23 percent, as Novinky noted. A “third round” is uncharted territory — and mobilizing weary voters a second time will test every campaign.

Czech Supreme Court Annuls Senate Election, Orders New Vote After One-Vote Margin
Photo: Žďárský deník

Only the second time in a decade

The court has done this exactly once before: in 2016 in Most, where Alena Dernerová of the Severočeši.cz movement won, the movement tried to withdraw her candidacy just before the runoff, the town hall ignored the request, and the court ordered a rerun, according to Seznam Zprávy.

Dernerová won again — as an independent — and the affair later landed before a criminal court. In 2004, the Supreme Administrative Court voided a Prague 11 Senate race over a allegedly dirty campaign, but the Constitutional Court immediately overturned that ruling and the result stood.

This year, courts have been unusually busy rewriting results. In municipal elections, with voters themselves using AI to flag “unusual” precinct tallies, regional courts changed which parties made it into councils in several tight races, HN.cz reported. In Želechovice na Olomoucku, someone broke into the polling room at night and broke the seal on the ballot box.

Černý’s complaint was the last of 16 election challenges the Supreme Administrative Court handled this season — the other 15 Senate complaints were all rejected, Seznam Zprávy reported. The next dated step is now fixed: the president has 30 days to call the rerun, and the voters of Žďársko will do the whole thing over again.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Avian Flu Detected in 3 Provinces After Poultry Exhibition, Radio-Canada Reports