Dillon Town Council approved the Swan Landing apartment project in a 4-3 vote Monday night, clearing the way for a 139-unit complex to replace the Skyline Cinema after five public hearings and a prior rejection in September.
The split decision, reported by Summit Daily News, followed two and a half hours of presentations and public comment. Developer Pagewest reduced the original 150-unit Skyline Apartments plan by 11 units, lowered building heights, added an amenity deck, and introduced rent caps averaging no more than 110% of area median income for 36 units.
Opponents argued the concessions were minimal. “You rejected the earlier proposal, yet Pagewest has reduced it by only 11 units,” Lexie Feikeme, a Piney Acres resident, told the council. “Is that a meaningful response to the concerns raised by (the) council and hundreds of residents?”
Council approves Swan Landing with rent-capped units
- Council voted 4-3 to approve the planned unit development for Swan Landing, overturning a September rejection of the denser Skyline Apartments proposal.
- Project includes 139 units with 36 rent-capped at 110% AMI; priority leasing goes to Dillon and Summit County workers for the first two weeks.
- Critics cite insufficient density reduction, building height, traffic, and loss of the town’s last commercial movie theater.
A theater goes dark, a town grows up
The Skyline Cinema has anchored the Dillon Ridge Marketplace for decades. Its closure marks the end of commercial exhibition in a town where the branded residences referendum killed a lakeside hotel project in 2024. Council member Kyle Hendricks noted the theater will close regardless of the vote.
“I’m afraid to miss this opportunity,” Hendricks said, “not just for us, but for the county, for the workforce.” He referenced the Waterview Residences as proof large-scale development is already reshaping Dillon’s skyline.
Tuyn frames project as missing-middle solution
Council member Rachel Tuyn framed Swan Landing as a rare private investment targeting the “missing middle” — households earning too much for deed-restricted affordable housing but too little to buy in Summit County. About 65% of Dillon’s housing stock operates as short-term rentals, she said.
Mayor Josh Samuel echoed that logic, arguing the site’s location in a shopping center reduces car dependence. “The fallacy is that if we build something big, it’s going to ruin something,” Samuel said. “It’s the direct opposite. It’s going to help the community.”
Norris Design principal Elaina Scott testified the project would increase Dillon’s tax base roughly sixfold through property and sales tax gains. She detailed the rent-cap structure: 36 units capped at 110% AMI, currently $3,008 monthly for a one-bedroom. Scott said that two earners at $70,000 each hit 120% AMI, often disqualifying them from traditional affordable housing.
Swan Landing’s caps lack an income ceiling to avoid that trap. Summit Combined Housing Authority director Corrie Burr confirmed her organization denies applicants weekly for exceeding income limits. “The Swan Landing project is fitting right in with the rest of the options,” Burr said.
Density, height, and character
Mayor pro tem Barbara Richard opposed the project, calling the lot rare and deserving of a “great plan.” She cited excessive density, building height, parking shortfalls, open space deficits, and traffic impacts. Council member Shannon White opposed the project over concerns about the “scale and intensity” of buildings one and two.
Council member Shannon White supported the housing mission but voted no over the “scale and intensity” of those front buildings. She questioned affordability for workers earning $22 an hour at City Market, citing a Kroger support letter. “Maybe their managers could, but certainly the bulk of their employees could not afford to live here without having multiple roommates,” White said.
Ben Raitano countered that town code allows up to 65 units per acre — Swan Landing sits near 34 — and that existing “massive” condos across Highway 6 already define the corridor. “It’s part of Dillon,” Raitano said.
“This is no different.” He projected a 20% boost to the full-time population, a goal the town has chased for 40 years. “All we’ve done is built a bunch of condominiums that belong to second-home owners,” he said.
Developer credentials and what comes next
Pagewest principal Brad Waitzer defended partners Zak Holt and Adam Wallace, citing his own 38 years and 10,000-plus units of experience. “I’m here to add some perspective and demonstrate that there’s considerable experience, financial capability and gray hair in Pagewest,” Waitzer said.
The council unanimously approved the development agreement guaranteeing public improvements after the PUD vote. Construction timelines have not been released, but the theater’s owners plan to donate projection equipment to locals hoping to open a smaller venue elsewhere.
The development agreement locks in infrastructure upgrades. “It’s going to help the community, and I believe that very strongly,” Samuel said.