In a column for Cinemablend published on Tuesday, the entertainment site argues that some of the harshest reviews of “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” describe a movie its writer simply did not see — defending a “faithful” adaptation even as critics grade the sixth franchise film down.
The piece ran the same morning the film’s purple carpet photos dropped, and the writer admits the disconnect caught them off guard. After reading reactions, the writer realized not everyone felt the way I did about the 2026 release, Cinemablend reported.
Why does this matter beyond one reviewer’s bruised feelings? Because the split lands squarely on the industry’s favorite anxiety: franchise fatigue. And the sharpest pan so far has a name on it.
Sunrise on the Reaping is a grim, exhausting trudge — yet another “They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?” reworking stocked with a photogenic Gen Z ensemble — that confuses piling on extra darkness (and trauma!) for the kind of depth its makers trust will give a fresh coat of polish to a franchise running out of creative steam.
That is Ryan Lattanzio at Indiewire, which graded the film a C- while singling out Jesse Plemons’ turn as Plutarch as a bright spot, per the column.
The Short Version
- Cinemablend’s columnist argues brutal reviews — Indiewire’s C-, The Guardian’s “overwrought” — miss a faithful, fan-first adaptation.
- The writer still concedes flaws: a long runtime that blunts arena deaths and thin time for Maysilee, Wiress, Beetee and Ampert.
- Positive reviews from outlets including The Hollywood Reporter and Time Out had the film trending positively on aggregators as of Tuesday.
A Dreary Slog, or a Love Letter
Here’s the split in one sentence: the same movie is being called a death march and a valentine.
Gizmodo’s Germain Lussier framed the film as built strictly for the faithful. In his view, the movie amounts to a heartfelt tribute to The Hunger Games, packed with callbacks, clarifications, and beats crafted to deliver the greatest possible joy to devotees of the franchise, he wrote, adding that it “isn’t concerned with setting up the world or reexplaining the stakes.”

Or, as he put it: “This is the sixth movie. If you’re watching this without context, well, that’s on you.”
The Cinemablend column leans on that reading. The writer says they feel like I watched a completely different movie than the pan-writers did, and points out that plenty of outlets — The Hollywood Reporter and Time Out among them — reviewed the film positively.
Faithful Down to The Details
One point of agreement cuts across both camps: fidelity. The column says it saw the word “faithful” peppered through reviews, and endorses it — the adaptation sticks to Suzanne Collins’ bleak source novel, right down to a bittersweet ending it compares to the third Hunger Games book.
Discussing Film’s Yasmine Kandil made the case most directly.
That being said, Sunrise on the Reaping remains exceedingly faithful to the novel’s sequence of events, perhaps more so than any of its predecessors, and often down to the most minute details. Yasmine Kandil
The column’s takeaway from that consensus: if you liked the book, you should like the movie.
The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw saw the same fidelity and shrugged at it, mocking the film’s “convoluted faux-mythic subtitle” in a review the column quotes at length: “Here is yet another iteration of the utterly exhausted, unbearably extended and now surreally boring Hunger Games franchise.”
His kicker, per Cinemablend: What, ‘harvest dawn’ not old-timey enough? The column reads Bradshaw’s jab as proof of its own thesis — that this movie isn’t for every demographic.
The Scorecard So Far
But the math tells a more complicated story than either side admits. The pan-worthy reviews are trending; so are the positive ones. Here is where the early verdicts stand, as gathered in the column:
| Outlet | Critic | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Indiewire | Ryan Lattanzio | C-; “dreary slog,” with praise for Jesse Plemons |
| The Guardian | Peter Bradshaw | “Overwrought,” “boring,” subtitle mocked |
| Discussing Film | Yasmine Kandil | “Exceedingly faithful” to the novel |
| Gizmodo | Germain Lussier | “A love letter” to franchise fans |
| The Hollywood Reporter; Time Out | — | Positive reviews, per the column |
What Even The Fan Column Concedes
The column is not a blanket defense. Asked plainly whether the film is perfect, the writer answers no.
Mckenna Grace and Jesse Plemons are named standouts, with Elle Fanning and Joseph Zada doing fine jobs — though the writer adds they are not bringing up Oscars here. The runtime also takes a hit: because the movie runs long, some of the emotional deaths in the arena land blunted, and the writer wishes there were more time with Maysilee, Wiress, Beetee and Ampert.
That is a notably measured list of complaints to sit beside “surreally boring.” The gap between those two descriptions is, in miniature, the review divide itself.
The Haymitch Ending That Wrecked The Writer
What the column asks for, ultimately, is simple: see it in a theater. The writer reports crying multiple times, says the film stirred up a lot of feelings about humanity, and what humans are willing to endure, and argues Haymitch’s story ties hard into Katniss’.
The detail doing the heavy lifting is the ending. The writer describes a closing scene connecting to the original “Hunger Games” in which Katniss accomplishes what Haymitch could not — a moment they call both hopeful and sad at once, and which they say left them emotionally wrecked.
Whether that lands as profundity or as new layers of darkness is exactly what critics are fighting over. The column said that, as of Tuesday morning, the film was still trending positively on review aggregators.