Doctoral Thesis Maps Deceptive Patterns as Routine Digital Infrastructure

A University of Vaasa doctoral thesis defended this week maps how deceptive interface patterns have become routine infrastructure in digital services, shifting the burden of resistance onto users who now treat manipulation as baseline behavior.

Laura Havinen’s dissertation in information systems science examines deceptive patterns — design choices that compromise user autonomy by nudging behavior or blocking intended actions — from the perspectives of both designers and users. The research finds that anyone using digital services cannot avoid encountering these patterns, which appear across websites, applications, online stores and social media.

“A deceptive pattern can, for example, be a large and colorful subscription button that is difficult for a consumer to ignore. Meanwhile, the cancel button is discreet and hard to find. Recurring pop-up windows, on the other hand, cause fatigue and irritation. My personal favorite among deceptive patterns is the false ultimatum ‘this offer is valid today only,'” Havinen said.

The research was sparked while Havinen chaired the Finland ACM SIGCHI Chapter, the Finnish association for human-computer interaction professionals. During one of the chapter’s gatherings, a designer outlined why deceptive patterns are put in place, noting that the motivations are far more nuanced than merely designers chasing profit and users stumbling into traps.

“Particularly as services continue to migrate online, deceptive patterns cost users time, money and privacy. You cannot get rid of newsletters, you end up ordering five items when one would have sufficed, or you find yourself stuck binge-watching videos on streaming platforms for hours. Artificial intelligence is also continuously introducing new ways to deceive users,” Havinen said.

Users were markedly more forgiving toward established brands than unfamiliar ones. Havinen cited fast-fashion brands, for which website gamification has already become an integral part of their brand identity.

Havinen said that various initiatives aim to curb deceptive design, yet these efforts still depend largely on designers’ individual moral compasses. The dissertation provides insights to help guide organizations.

Havinen chairs the Finland ACM SIGCHI Chapter, the Finnish association for human-computer interaction professionals, a role that first exposed her to designers’ reasoning behind deceptive patterns. She earned her M.Sc. from the University of Vaasa and works there as a doctoral researcher in information systems science. The dissertation was examined in Finnish on 25 November 2026 with Professor Thomas Olsson of Tampere University as opponent and Professor Tero Vartiainen as custos.

“Organizations need their own clear guidelines, because we must simultaneously protect digital service users and empower designers to create ethical user interfaces,” Havinen said.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Polestar Formula 2030 Concept Previews Next Polestar 2 (2027) and Polestar 7 (2028)