DOJ Backs OpenAI, Microsoft in Copyright Suit, Contradicts White House AI Framework, Fox News Reports

The Trump administration’s Justice Department has filed a statement of interest backing OpenAI and Microsoft in the New York Times copyright suit, embracing a sweeping “fair use” defense that breaks with the White House’s own balanced AI framework, Fox News reported.

The brief argues that requiring licenses for AI training data would impose prohibitive costs, threatening U.S. competitiveness and national security. But the filing contradicts the Carolina Principles for Emerging Technologies, adopted by G20 ministers at the Commerce Department’s recent Innovation Ministerial, which recognize the “essential role” of copyright protections and call for respecting intellectual property as a pillar of AI policy, Fox News reported.

DOJ backs fair use for national security and small developers

  • The DOJ argues unfettered fair use is vital for national security and small AI developers.
  • The White House AI framework and G20 Carolina Principles endorse licensing and creator compensation.
  • The bipartisan CLEAR Act would force disclosure of training datasets without settling the fair use question.

News organizations sue over training data

The New York Times and other publishers allege OpenAI and Microsoft used millions of articles to train large language models without permission or payment. The tech companies contend the ingestion qualifies as fair use, a copyright exception allowing limited use without authorization. The case is one of the biggest tests yet of how decades-old doctrine applies to generative AI.

DOJ breaks with administration consensus

The DOJ’s statement of interest adopts an “extreme vision of fair use” that would grant AI firms virtually unfettered access to copyrighted works for commercial training, according to Fox News. The brief warns licensing costs could hamper small competitors and U.S. AI leadership.

Yet the White House’s official AI framework acknowledges valid arguments on both sides, and the Carolina Principles — agreed to by G20 ministers — explicitly note the “complex legal and policy questions” at the intersection of AI and copyright, Fox News reported.

DOJ Backs OpenAI, Microsoft in Copyright Suit, Contradicts White House AI Framework, Fox News Reports
Photo: dnyuz.com

Startups say licensing reduces risk

The DOJ argument that licensing hurts small companies runs counter to what several AI startups have told policymakers. Paying for training material provides more reliable access, reduces legal uncertainty, and improves model quality, those founders argue.

New firms have emerged to aggregate rights and streamline licensing, undercutting the claim that a functioning market cannot exist. “It’s particularly problematic for large AI companies to complain about paying for access to copyrighted materials. They are among the best positioned to pay,” the Fox News analysis said.

Constitutional property rights at stake

Even if national security justified compulsory access, the Fifth Amendment requires just compensation when private property is taken for public use, and intellectual property remains property.

Letting AI firms appropriate creative work without payment would be akin to letting data center builders seize land without fair value, the Fox News commentary argued. Weaker copyrights risk reducing the human-created books, research, films, and songs that ultimately feed AI systems — a scenario that serves no one.

CLEAR Act offers a disclosure path

Sens. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., and John Curtis, R-Utah, introduced the bipartisan CLEAR Act in February. The bill would require AI developers to publicly disclose the copyrighted works in each new generative model’s training dataset. It would not decide fair use but would give creators the information needed to pursue compensation or remedies when they believe their rights were violated, Fox News reported.

Position Key Argument Source
DOJ / OpenAI Fair use covers AI training; licensing costs threaten competition and national security Fox News
White House AI Framework Acknowledges valid arguments on both sides of the copyright debate Fox News
G20 Carolina Principles Copyright protections play an “essential role”; IP respect is a pillar of AI policy Fox News
CLEAR Act (Schiff/Curtis) Mandates public disclosure of training datasets; enables creator remedies Fox News

Creative economy tops $1 trillion

Copyright licensing underpins more than $1 trillion in U.S. economic activity, the Fox News analysis noted. The New York Times suit, joined by other news organizations, seeks to establish that the same property rights governing music sampling, film clips, and book excerpts apply to the ingestion pipelines of generative models.

OpenAI launched ChatGPT in November 2022, a release that accelerated the generative AI boom and made the tool the world’s fifth-most-visited website by September 2026. Founded in 2015 as a nonprofit with Elon Musk and Sam Altman as co-chairs, the organization created a for-profit subsidiary in 2019 and restructured in 2025 into a public benefit corporation 26% owned by the nonprofit OpenAI Foundation; Microsoft has invested more than $13 billion in the company.

The courts will now weigh whether fair use stretches to cover industrial-scale copying for commercial AI.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

The Next Hint Published a Curated List of Ten Television Series Positioned

Andrew Scott Portrays Ian Charleson Choosing Hamlet Over Doctor’s Advice