In June 2013, whistleblower Edward Snowden shattered the U.S. government’s long-standing denial of mass surveillance, transforming seven years of stalled legal battles into a definitive proof of systemic privacy violations.
The revelations, facilitated by Laura Poitras and Glenn Greenwald, forced a public reckoning with the reach of the National Security Agency.
Seven Years of Judicial Mud
The government’s strategy was consistent and dismissive: it would neither confirm nor deny the existence of these programs, instead demanding that cases like Jewel v. NSA be dismissed outright, according to EFF.
Clapper’s response—”No, sir. It does not. Not wittingly”—was captured on C-SPAN, providing the final catalyst for an internal leak.
The Hong Kong Connection
In early June 2013, documentary filmmaker Laura Poitras and journalist Glenn Greenwald were conspicuously absent from a Freedom of the Press Foundation board meeting at the EFF offices. The reason for their disappearance quickly became global news: they were in Hong Kong meeting with an NSA contractor who had been secretly communicating with Poitras for months.
That contractor was Edward Snowden. He provided thousands of documents that finally validated years of legal suspicions, proving that the government had indeed been monitoring millions of citizens. A now-iconic photograph of Snowden working behind a laptop, featuring a prominent red EFF sticker, became the visual shorthand for the era of digital transparency.
Shifting the Legal Landscape
For the lawyers at the EFF, the leaked documents provided the evidentiary “wings” required to break through the government’s stonewalling. “We were struggling along in the mud, and we felt like somebody gave us wings,” said Cindy Cohn, former EFF Executive Director, in the latest episode of the Privacy’s Defenders podcast.
The leak transformed the nature of the challenge in Jewel v. NSA, turning a case built on inference and whistleblower testimony into one backed by internal documentation. The transition from fighting against a “neither confirm nor deny” defense to arguing based on undeniable records changed the trajectory of the litigation.
The Impact on Digital Rights
- Evidentiary Shift: The Snowden documents converted years of circumstantial claims into verifiable proof of mass collection.
- Institutional Credibility: The lie told by James Clapper under oath served as a turning point, signaling to analysts like Snowden that internal channels for accountability had failed.
- Public Awareness: The global dissemination of the leaks moved privacy from a niche legal concern to a central pillar of modern digital policy.
The podcast, which serves as a companion to Cohn’s book, Privacy’s Defender: My Thirty-Year Fight Against Digital Surveillance, highlights the roles of journalists, hackers, and lawyers in these early digital liberty battles. As the Privacy’s Defenders series continues, it documents the voices of those who were active long before the general public understood the scale of the surveillance apparatus.
Cindy Cohn, who was born in 1964 or 1965, has been a central figure in digital rights for over 25 years. Her involvement with the EFF began in 1993, when she served as the lead attorney in the landmark First Amendment challenge Bernstein v. Dept. of Justice.
Before becoming the organization’s executive director in 2015, she spent 15 years as its legal director and general counsel. Throughout her career, she has been recognized as one of the most influential lawyers in America, with The National Law Journal noting in 2013 that if Big Brother is watching, he better look out for her.
On November 17, 2026, the EFF released a video highlighting stories from the fight for digital rights, including the role of Snowden’s leaked documents in proving government surveillance. The history of these legal battles shows how fragile privacy is in the digital age, a reality that became undeniable after the 2013 events.