EIA Report: West, Central Africa Ivory, Pangolin Trade Grows Despite Crackdowns

Nigeria recorded 58 wildlife crime incidents between January 2021 and February 2026, yet only six ended in convictions — and the trade in pangolin scales and elephant ivory is still growing, a new Environmental Investigation Agency report published Tuesday by Mongabay shows.

The numbers are stark. Across West and Central Africa, just 16% of those arrested for poaching or trafficking are convicted. More than 50,000 kg (over 110,000 lb) of ivory and pangolin scales were seized in Nigeria during that five-year window, Mongabay reported, and the trade shows no sign of shrinking. Gabon logged the most incidents from 2021 to 2026; the Democratic Republic of the Congo followed with more than 16,000 kg (about 35,000 lb) seized.

Mongabay’s reporting centers on a trader it calls Mr. X, who sold carved ivory from a storefront in Lagos’s Lekki Craft Market, between handwoven raffia baskets and Ankara fabrics. From that shop, he built links with buyers across Asia, shipping products sourced from the forests of Gabon, Cameroon, and the Central African Republic.

In early 2022, Mr. X was arrested with nearly 900 kg (nearly 2,000 lb) of pangolin scales and 145 kg (320 lb) of elephant ivory. In May 2023, he was convicted and sentenced to two years in prison. Within months, he was free. Some 18 months later, investigators found him selling pangolin scales again — business had rebounded, and he had reportedly paid several million naira, a few thousand dollars, in bribes through his lawyer during court proceedings.

Story on The Morning Science
Photo: themorning.science

Why the arrests aren’t stopping the trade

Here is why that matters: the people being caught are rarely the people running the business. Mongabay reports that fines and sentences mostly land on poachers, middlemen, and other low-level, easily replaceable actors, while kingpins, corrupt officials, financial beneficiaries, and logistics coordinators stay out of reach.

“On the one hand, there’s been progress. Nigeria has had its first prosecutions … Even five years ago, it had not had any on wildlife trafficking at that level,” said Justin Gosling, who leads EIA’s program on securing criminal justice.

“But there are competing crime interests and priorities in [African] countries. Even with the best intentions of tackling wildlife crime, we have all sorts of other issues,” he said, noting that there could have been more progress.

Gosling acknowledged real progress, Mongabay noted: Nigeria now has its first prosecutions at this level, something it lacked even five years ago. But, he said, competing crime priorities and economic pressures have slowed the pace.

From Dar es Salaam to Port Harcourt

The geography tells its own story. East and Southern Africa — Dar es Salaam in particular — were long the hotspots. After crackdowns in the 2010s, traffickers shifted west, and Nigeria became the primary exit point for illegal wildlife from Africa in 2015, Mongabay reported.

The shifting landscape of wildlife trafficking in West and Central Africa — Environmental Investigation Agency

“We started seeing the emergence of Nigeria as probably the key hub for wildlife trafficking. It became internationally notorious for that,” Gosling told Conservation news.

But there is a catch: the pressure moves, and so does the trade. With enforcement tightening in Lagos, operations have relocated to Enungu, about 230 km (140 miles) inland from the Gulf of Guinea, and to Port Harcourt, a primary Gulf port city. An EIA investigator, speaking to Mongabay anonymously, said traders feel safer where law enforcement watches less — or where they have connections inside the port itself.

Traffickers are also adapting in other ways, Mongabay found: hiding contraband inside legitimate goods like edible moringa seeds, and moving money through bank transfers and underground banking systems.

The demand that keeps the networks alive

Two products drive it all — pangolin scales and elephant ivory, both highly coveted by Chinese buyers, Mongabay reports. Pangolin scales, made of keratin, the same protein as human nails and hair, are boiled or burned off the animals, then ground into powders, pills, or liquid remedies used in traditional Chinese medicine. There is no proven medicinal value. The meat is also eaten as a purported remedy.

“EIA has been working on pangolin scales and ivory for decades, and, even so, it's still a problem. It's not decreasing. And obviously, the elephant and pangolin populations are decreasing.” an EIA investigator who spoke on condition of anonymity said.

Pangolins have been the world’s most trafficked mammal for decades. Asian demand already pushed all four Southeast Asian and Chinese species to critically endangered status, so poachers turned to Africa, where two of the continent’s four species are endangered and two are vulnerable on the IUCN Red List. In 2017, CITES — the treaty regulating trade in endangered species — banned all cross-border commercial sale of all eight pangolin species.

The elephants are vanishing too. Mongabay notes that an intense wave of poaching beginning around 2007, driven mostly by tusk sales to China, cut African elephant numbers from an estimated 1.3 million to between 450,000 and 550,000 today.

Seizures by country, 2021–2026

Country Role in trade Seized (ivory and pangolin scales)
Nigeria Primary export hub by volume More than 50,000 kg (110,000+ lb)
DR Congo Second-highest seizures More than 16,000 kg (about 35,000 lb)
Gabon Most incidents recorded Not quantified in the report

Nigeria enacts major wildlife protection overhaul

One glimmer of hope, per Mongabay: Nigeria is set to enact its Endangered Species Conservation and Protection Bill 2024, the biggest overhaul of the country's wildlife framework in nearly four decades. Experts told Conservation news that similar laws must be adopted and enforced across the whole region to stop what some call the “leaking bucket” — crackdowns in one place simply push the trade into another.

“This has to be a concerted effort. The pressure has got to be on all the time,” Gosling told Conservation news. “Otherwise, it will displace somewhere else, which means the other countries … have got to get their act together.”

Ruth Musgrave, CEO of the Elephant Protection Initiative Foundation, told Conservation news the fight needs a holistic approach — public opinion, better laws, anti-poaching and intelligence work, and international cooperation. Her foundation has worked in several West African countries to secure and, where possible, destroy government stockpiles of ivory and pangolin scales so they don’t leak back onto the illegal market.

For the global reader, the stakes run beyond conservation. This trade feeds transnational criminal financing, corrupts port and customs systems on a major Gulf of Guinea shipping corridor, and erodes the rule of law in economies that international investors already treat as high-risk.

Gosling’s point cuts to the core: with environmental crime, the harm happens at the outset — the killing of the animal — so interception must come before export, not after.

“What we have at the moment,” he told Conservation news, “is just stockrooms full of dead animals which doesn’t really help anything.”

Read the original reporting from Conservation news’s investigation into the trafficking networks and its coverage documenting the conviction-rate figures.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Batch CEO Expects Sovereignty to Decide Public Contracts by 2027