Lawmakers from the Netherlands and Spain are challenging the European Commission this week over €2.5 billion in loans to Egypt, after internal figures showed welfare rolls shrinking.
The loans, unlocked in two separate disbursements, were tied to a promise: that Cairo would expand its main cash transfer programs, Takaful and Karama. But confidential documents reveal that Egypt instead recorded a net drop of 85,734 welfare households between 2024 and 2026 — while Commission reports told EU lawmakers the conditions had been fulfilled.
The money is no side payment. It sits within a wider €7.4 billion strategic partnership meant to shore up Egypt's economy and deepen migration cooperation across the Mediterranean — a context that turns the discrepancy into a question about how Europe wields its leverage.
“The finding by this investigation that the commission is seemingly sugarcoating Egypt’s performance is worrying,” said Tineke Strik, a Dutch MEP. She accused the Commission of treating its reporting obligations to parliament as an “inconvenient formality” on the way to securing migration cooperation.
The shortfall in the rolls
Here is how the conditions were written. To release the two tranches worth €2.5 billion, the European Union mandated that Egypt expand its primary cash transfer initiatives, the Takaful and Karama social welfare programs, which support struggling families across the country.
European Commission reports informed EU lawmakers that Cairo had met those benchmarks. The internal figures tell a different story: thousands of families were removed from the assistance rolls during a multi-year recertification process.
The arithmetic of what was lost is stark. A review of World Bank figures suggests that had Egypt achieved its expansion targets while keeping every current family enrolled, another 245,000 households — approximately 909,000 vulnerable individuals — would be covered by the programs now.

| Measure | Figure | Context |
|---|---|---|
| EU strategic partnership with Egypt | €7.4 billion | Economic stabilization and migration cooperation |
| Loan disbursements unlocked | €2.5 billion | Two tranches, tied to welfare benchmarks |
| Net change in welfare households | −85,734 | 2024 to 2026, per confidential documents |
| Households foregone | 245,000 | World Bank data analysis |
| Individuals affected | ~909,000 | Same analysis |
Brussels defends its math
The Commission does not dispute the figures so much as the framing. A Commission spokesperson argued that the policy benchmarks were concerned solely with enrolling new beneficiary families rather than tracking net changes, and insisted there was “no contradiction” in the evaluation process.
In other words, Brussels counted the arrivals and not the departures. Critics in parliament see that as a distinction without a difference for the families involved.
The pressure is now coming from more than one capital. The Guardian reported that Spanish MEP Sandra Gómez López has called for full transparency on how the conditions were assessed.
“The commission must explain transparently why it considers these commitments to have been fulfilled and demonstrate that European funding is genuinely contributing to improving social protection for the Egyptian population,” Gómez López said.
A test for EU influence
The timing sharpens the stakes. The release of the funds coincides with mounting global concern about Egypt’s domestic policies and press freedoms, where independent reporters and media outlets have been subjected to repeated legal proceedings and imprisonment.
Rights groups argue the EU has set a standard and then declined to enforce it. “Without benchmarks, the EU has turned a human rights conditionality into a blank cheque for Egypt’s authoritarianism,” said Claudio Francavilla, associate EU director at Human Rights Watch.
Policy experts go further, warning that soft benchmarks weaken European influence over long-term regional stability — the very goal the partnership claims to serve.
“European officials have done a poor job of leveraging the funds of European taxpayers to support genuine stabilisation,” said Timothy Kaldas, deputy director of the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy. Europe’s strategic interest, he argued, depends on a resilient and economically secure Egyptian populace.
That is the tension at the heart of the story. The €7.4 billion partnership was sold as an investment in stability; the internal figures suggest the social-protection core of that bargain went unmet, and the money moved anyway.
Strik, born in 1961, has spent much of her career on the issues now at stake in the Egypt file. She worked as a legal consultant for the refugee organization Vluchtelingenwerk and as a judicial secretary at the court of Zwolle, handling refugee chambers, before joining GreenLeft as a justice policy advisor in 1997.
She sat in the Dutch Senate from 2007 to 2019, when she moved to the European Parliament with the Greens–European Free Alliance group, and was re-elected in June 2024 on the shared GroenLinks–PvdA list, which won eight seats. Her parliamentary focus has been on rule of law, democracy, asylum and migration.
What happens next is largely in Brussels’ hands. The Commission maintains there is “no contradiction” in its evaluation — and has not yet explained to Gómez López’s satisfaction how the commitments were judged fulfilled.