INDIANAPOLIS — The Libertarian Party of Indiana expected Lauri Shillings to clear the 2% threshold that has kept the party on the ballot automatically since 1994. Preliminary returns from the Nov. 3 election show her 253 votes short.
In the contest for Indiana secretary of state, preliminary returns put Shillings at 38,663 votes — 1.987% of the 1,945,765 ballots tallied across all 92 counties. At that total, the 2% threshold stands at 38,916 votes. A few hundred votes could end the party’s 32-year run of automatic ballot access — and hand that spot to a new minor party.
Greg Ballard received 70,068 votes, or 3.60%, for the Lincoln Party. If the preliminary count holds, the Lincoln Party would gain the convention-nomination option the Libertarians are about to lose, according to the state’s candidate guide.
Not everything is settled. The Indiana Election Division notes that counties were required to file certified returns by Tuesday, though they have until Friday to fix any errors.
253 votes from a 32-year streak
The numbers are close enough that the party is not conceding anything yet. Stephanie Dasbach, chair of the Libertarian Party of Indiana, said the party is holding off until certified results arrive and will assist its 2028 candidates with signature collection if that becomes necessary. She declined to say whether the party would pursue a recount or take legal action if Shillings comes up short.
“We cannot know anything until the final certified results are out,” Dasbach said. “We will pursue any avenues we can to ensure that every vote is counted and that the election is secure.”
Dasbach said the party expected Shillings to clear 2%. She said Shillings was “largely locked out of the media coverage given to her three opponents” and still drew more than 38,000 votes.
“Obviously, our expectations were to reach the 2% ballot threshold, but this was a uniquely challenging race and environment this season,” Dasbach said.
What the 2% line actually decides
In Indiana, a minor party whose secretary of state candidate receives at least 2% and less than 10% of the vote may nominate candidates by convention, keeping its candidates’ party labels on the ballot without petitioning.
Once Libertarians forfeit that designation, their candidates would need to petition for a printed ballot line, with the number of signatures drawn from 2% of the vote in the most recent secretary of state contest within the district where the candidate is running.
Laura Merrifield Wilson, a political science professor at the University of Indianapolis, said that if the Libertarians lose automatic ballot access, putting forward candidates under the party’s banner would become more difficult.
“Of course, if they’re able to clinch the 2%, then the conversation is moot. But that said, this would be I think a major loss for the party,” Wilson said.
In the preliminary tally, Democrat Beau Bayh took the secretary of state contest with 1,007,815 votes, or 51.8%. Republican Max Engling received 829,083 votes, or 42.6%. The two minor parties together took nearly 6% of the vote — a split that Dasbach framed as voter dissatisfaction.
“The results of this election showed that a significant Hoosiers continue to want more options and are dissatisfied with what the Republicans and Democrats are sending them,” Dasbach said.
The Lincoln Party factor
Why did Shillings fall short? Wilson cited a competitive contest between the major-party nominees and a second alternative — Ballard — for voters looking beyond those parties.
Roughly a third of Ballard’s vote total came out of Marion and Hamilton counties, which together supplied about a fifth of the votes cast in the race. He drew 5.9% in Marion County and 5.3% in Hamilton County, versus 3.6% statewide. Shillings received at least 2% in 62 of Indiana’s 92 counties, according to preliminary precinct returns.
Chad Kinsella, an associate professor of political science at Ball State University, said it is hard to know how voters would have behaved in a race without Ballard.
“Some of those people could have gone to the Lincoln Party, but I don’t know that if we got rid of the Lincoln Party, that all of those people or even some of those people would have necessarily gone to Libertarians,” Kinsella said.
“I think there’s a group of people out there that are disaffected. And I have a feeling that this election, it was a lot of Republicans that were very happy to go for any third party because they were really angry with their party.”
Dasbach said that no matter how the count ends up, the party anticipates reworking how it recruits and backs candidates and members. Wilson said losing automatic access could shift where Libertarians put their time and resources.
“Now they’re going to have to look at candidate recruitment probably a little bit differently, at the political infrastructure for campaigns a little differently,” Wilson said.
She added that the party likely relied on a base of libertarian or nonpartisan voters who picked it as an alternative to the two major parties, “not necessarily because of what they stood for or that those voters were super loyal or allegiant to the libertarian message.”
How Hoosiers cast their ballots
The Nov. 3 election drew nearly 2 million voters — 1,997,142 ballots from 4,768,979 registered Hoosiers. That is 115,582 more ballots than in 2022, when 1,881,560 voted, lifting turnout from 39.5% to 41.9%.
| Measure | 2026 | 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Total ballots | 1,997,142 | 1,881,560 |
| Turnout | 41.9% | 39.5% |
| Election Day ballots | about 1.1 million | about 1.2 million |
The bigger shift was in how people voted. Nearly 45% of ballots were cast absentee — a category covering both in-person early voting and mail ballots — up from about 37% four years earlier. Absentee ballots grew by nearly 204,000 even as the overall count rose by only 116,000, and Election Day voting fell by about 94,000.
County trends pointed the same way. Tippecanoe County turnout rose to about 38% from 32%, with its absentee share climbing from about 47% to 60%. Marion County added nearly 38,000 ballots, with turnout up from 34% to 41%. Hamilton County reached 52% turnout, with absentee voting up from 41% to 53%. Monroe County jumped from 41% to 47%, and Johnson County held at about 39% while its absentee share rose from 47% to 55%.
Still, turnout remained below Indiana’s last two presidential elections — about 65% in 2020 and 62% in 2024. Wilson said competitive races give voters more reason to participate, and that some of the absentee growth likely reflects Election Day voters taking advantage of an earlier opportunity.
“To see increases in terms of early voting and absentee voting certainly speaks to voter enthusiasm. I think it speaks to voter engagement,” Wilson said.
Kinsella said how Hoosiers voted stood out more than how many did. “I think here, election day voting is still going to be big,” he said, while expecting more people to use absentee options over time.
What happens before Friday
The next few days decide it. Counties have until Friday to correct their certified returns, so Shillings’ 253-vote gap could still shrink or grow. If the preliminary results hold, the Lincoln Party takes the automatic ballot access the Libertarians have held since 1994 — and the Libertarians would need petition signatures for 2028 candidates, with Dasbach saying the party will help them gather those if necessary.
The streak dates to the party’s early days. The Libertarian Party of Indiana held its founding meeting on July 14, 1974, when about 20 to 25 people gathered at a hotel near what is now the Indianapolis International Airport, and it first won minor-party status in 1994, when Steve Dillon cleared 2% in the secretary of state race — the very contest now deciding its fate.
The party has since counted 12 Libertarians elected to offices across the state, and its strongest statewide showing came in the 2020 governor’s race, when Donald Rainwater took 11.44% of the vote — 345,567 votes, finishing second in a third of Indiana’s 92 counties.
The next secretary of state race, in 2030, would give the party another chance to qualify automatically.