EU Leaders Sideline Kaja Kallas from Ukraine Peace Talks Team

EU leaders sidelined the bloc’s own foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, when they named a seven-strong team last Friday to represent Europe in US-mediated talks on ending Russia’s war in Ukraine — a decision that exposes, once again, who really speaks for Europe abroad: not Brussels, but its capitals.

The summit in Dublin was meant to settle how the European Union would enter negotiations that Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy has repeatedly asked the bloc to join with a single negotiator. Instead, per The Guardian’s reporting from the room, leaders agreed on a lineup that left the person hired for the job off the list entirely.

Sitting alongside US negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, Europe will now be represented by European Council president António Costa, European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen, and envoys from the E5 — France, Germany, Britain, Poland and Italy — working with Nato. Kallas, the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy since 2024, was not among them.

EU Leaders Sideline Kaja Kallas from Ukraine Peace Talks Team
Photo: finwire.io

Here is why that matters beyond the Brussels bubble: this is the gravest security crisis Europe has faced in decades, and the man who once famously asked “Who do I call when I want to talk to Europe?” — Henry Kissinger, in an apocryphal but enduring query — is getting the same non-answer half a century later.

As The Guardian reported, von der Leyen’s defence in Dublin was brisk: “We decide for ourselves who will represent us, and we made that decision today,” she said.

Kallas created the post to be heard

Kallas, a former Estonian prime minister, was unequivocal when the summit convened. Leaders had agreed back in 2024, when it became clear there would have to be talks with Russia, “that I’m the one who is representing Europe in foreign and security policy,” she said, The Guardian reported.

She chairs the Foreign Affairs Council, the EU’s monthly forum of national foreign ministers, and runs the European External Action Service, the bloc’s de facto foreign ministry.

On paper, the job is substantial. She chairs the Foreign Affairs Council, the monthly forum where national ministers agree on sanctions and crisis responses, and she runs the EEAS — the EU’s de facto foreign ministry, with more than 140 embassies worldwide. The role was created by the Lisbon Treaty in 2009 precisely to give Europe one phone number.

But in practice, the post has long been described as a poisoned chalice. As Guardian Europe Jennifer Rankin put it: “Personally, I think Kallas has an impossible job: having to represent the positions of 27 member states that often disagree on foreign policy, and don’t want to cede real decision making on it to the EU.”

Why the 27 bypassed their own diplomat

Three explanations are circulating among diplomats, The Guardian reported. Several western European capitals view the Estonian as too fiercely anti-Russian. More fundamentally, Paris and Berlin resist ceding foreign policy power to Brussels and prefer protecting their own seats at the table. And a wider trend has seen international questions migrate from foreign ministers to premiers and presidents.

Who speaks for europe abroad not its diplomat
Photo: khanlist.com

Germany’s chancellor, Friedrich Merz, defended the intergovernmental route. Formats like the E3 — France, Germany and the UK — are “a well-established format” and “I see absolutely no problem with keeping it that way,” he argued.

Others were blunter. “Europe needs one voice,” said Lithuania’s foreign minister, Kęstutis Budrys. “We cannot speak with 27 microphones. We need one.” Spain also criticised the team approach, according to The Guardian.

Brussels commentator Jennifer Rankin argues the episode shows Kallas has an impossible job: having to represent the positions of 27 member states that often disagree on foreign policy and don’t want to cede real decision-making to the EU. By fielding what he called a “European cacophony”, leaders proved Kallas’s job “is not real, and the EU doesn’t actually have a foreign policy”, he argued.

The friction behind the closed doors

The decision also lands amid an unusually personal standoff. Relations between Kallas and von der Leyen have been particularly difficult, The Guardian reported, with critics accusing the Commission president of the same centralising instincts the member states display.

That friction has been aggravated by active proposals to fold parts of the EEAS and key foreign policy powers directly into von der Leyen’s remit — a structural overhaul that would gut the High Representative’s independence.

Defenders of the Dublin lineup make a fair-minded case. One EU diplomat told The Guardian that EU institutions “do not have sufficient political legitimacy in the eyes of voters. And this matters big time. The E5 solution is an attempt to bridge that gap.” Bringing the big military and financial powers to the table, on this view, supplies geopolitical heft that a supranational official cannot.

Rankin offers a middle path: “I think the E5+ format could be seen as a realistic answer to represent the EU as it is, not the idealised union of the treaties. It needn’t be a cacophony if everyone in the room has the same message.” So far, on Ukraine, consensus mostly holds.

But if, for example, Marine Le Pen becomes French president, “all bets are off”, she cautioned.

What the world sees from the outside

Step back and the signal from last Friday’s summit in Dublin is hard to miss. A peace process on European soil, conducted with Europe’s most powerful capitals but without its designated diplomat, underlines that lockout.

Sanctions policy — agreed in Kallas’s own Foreign Affairs Council — only holds if 27 governments keep moving together.

Development Detail
2009 — Lisbon Treaty creates the role High Representative post established to answer the question of who to call for Europe
2024 — Kallas appointed Former Estonian PM named High Representative and Commission vice-president
2024 — Leaders’ internal agreement Kallas says leaders agreed she would represent Europe in any talks with Russia
Friday — Dublin summit Seven-strong negotiating team named; Kallas excluded; Spain and Lithuania object
Fri onward — Reorganisation debate Proposals circulating to fold parts of the EEAS into the Commission president’s remit

Kallas has put a brave face on the slight, insisting she will focus on “substance” while leaders handle “format”. But the suspicion lingers, as The Guardian’s reporting concludes: Europe’s leaders want the bloc to be a global power — they just won’t let anyone else speak for it.

Until that changes, the EU risks staying on the diplomatic sidelines, punching below its geopolitical weight, while the war next door is settlement-shaped in rooms it helped pay for but could not enter.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Bay Area Storm Floods Highways, Falls Short of S.F. Daily Rain Record

Skydance CEO David Ellison Praises Elon Musk, Open to Future Collaboration