Experts: “Old Person Smell” Science Thin; Ads Use Shame to Sell Soap

Persimmon soap ads on social media are sparking anxiety over a purported “old person smell” driven by a chemical called 2-nonenal. Experts and researchers state that the underlying science is extremely thin, pointing instead to targeted marketing tactics that use personal data and social shame to drive expensive sales.

Is 2-nonenal the true culprit behind aging body odor?

Social media feeds have filled with posts marketing persimmon soap to eliminate a musty, greasy, and sometimes grassy odor often labeled as kareishū or “old person smell.” Advertisers claim this scent is caused by a chemical called 2-nonenal, which supposedly permeates clothes and homes while remaining imperceptible to the person producing it.

According to the marketing, daily washing fails to remove the compound unless consumers purchase specialized soaps. However, the scientific backing for this chemical mechanism is sparse.

“There is some evidence that 2-nonenal may contribute, but it is based on a small group of people,” said Deshan Sebaratnam, a dermatologist at The Skin Hospital in Sydney, told ABC News.

The original claim stems from a 2001 study observing 22 Japanese individuals, which found the chemical only in men aged 40 and older. A subsequent 2006-linked body of research and another Japanese study in 2016 involving 27 participants also reported that 2-nonenal increased with age.

Those findings have not been successfully replicated outside of Japan. A small study in the US in 2009 failed to detect the chemical in either men or women over the age of 39. Researchers behind the US project concluded that 2-nonenal might represent a diet-linked, cultural phenomenon connected to heavy consumption of fish and marine-based foods rather than a universal human aging process.

Experts: "Old Person Smell" Science Thin; Ads Use Shame to Sell Soap
Photo: wellstrack.com

What other factors influence human scent?

Dermatologist Sebaratnam said that skin bacteria, the composition of oil and sweat, hormones, diet, hygiene practices, and genetics all contribute to an individual’s natural scent.

While chemical markers like 2-nonenal lack broad evidence, research into whether humans can guess a person’s age based on smell alone produced distinct results. In that trial, donors wore T-shirts with armpit pads for five consecutive nights before human smell testers evaluated them. While testers could identify older donors, they consistently rated their body odor as less intense and less unpleasant than that of younger donors.

Does persimmon soap actually neutralize body odors?

Online retailers sell orange-colored persimmon soap bars for prices ranging from $8 to $72. Advertisements market these products as clinically proven and doctor-backed, claiming they actively neutralize or eliminate 2-nonenal rather than simply masking the scent.

Sebaratnam expressed reservations about any unique properties in persimmon soap, explaining that any standard soap binds to skin oils and aids with overall odor removal.

The specific claim regarding persimmon originated from a 2012 test published in the Journal of the Japanese Odor and Fragrance Environment. Researchers evaluated a soap blend containing persimmon, oolong, sweet, and green tea extracts on a small cohort of middle-aged Japanese men. After four weeks of use, participants and independent odor judges reported that the men smelled better.

Is old person smell real how harnesses shame
Photo: khanlist.com

The trial included no comparison group using regular soap. Consequently, researchers could not determine whether the perceived improvement stemmed from the persimmon extract, the tea additives, or simply more rigorous washing induced by participating in a clinical study.

Digital platforms have supercharged the marketing of age-related hygiene products through micro-targeted advertising. Ads utilize urgent messaging with phrases like “feel close to the ones you love again,” “smell normal,” and warnings that family members will notice the difference.

“We see messages of urgency, encouraging consumers to take care of themselves in particular ways,” said Giselle Newton, a digital sociologist at the University of Queensland who tracks advertisements for the Australian Ad Observatory, told ABC News.

Newton said that when sudden panic arises around specific body odors, consumers are pushed toward purchasing specialized goods. She added that personalization through social media data makes these marketing campaigns feel vastly different from traditional billboard or television commercials.

The Skin Hospital traces its origins to 1984 as The Skin & Cancer Foundation in Darlinghurst, Sydney, beginning with two rooms for consultation and UVA treatment. It runs clinical trials for conditions such as atopic dermatitis and performs Mohs micrographic surgery for skin cancer, the specialty referenced by the dermatologist in this story.

“If advertisers are, to a certain extent, fabricating problems with people’s bodies, then they should be held accountable for that,” Newton told ABC News, emphasizing that natural bodily processes are simply part of being human.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Nature: 1,135,082 Dermatology Images Unified Into Global Atlas

PSG’s Doué Leaves Pitch in Tears on Stretcher With Knee Injury