Foreign Policy: Woodward’s ‘Secrets’ Reveals Nuclear Fears, War Failures

By Omar El Sayed – World Editor

Bob Woodward is scared about the weak locks on safes guarding authentication codes for US nuclear weapons and the dangers that feel more present and grave.

That haunting fear runs through Secrets, a new memoir by the veteran Washington Post investigative reporter who has spent half a century delivering major political scoops across 11 presidential administrations, Foreign Policy reported.

In his latest book, Woodward pulls back the curtain on the deep-background sources that underpinned decades of his reporting, spanning from his early days breaking the Watergate story with Carl Bernstein that forced President Richard Nixon’s 1974 resignation to his examinations of executive war powers.

Starting with his 1991 book The Commanders, Woodward shifted his focus toward what he calls “the most serious action a president can take”: declaring war. He writes that time after time, successive commanders-in-chief have botched military conflicts badly for nearly identical reasons.

Those missteps stem from a failure to thoroughly hash out pitfalls before pulling the trigger, paired with a commensurate failure by senior staff to deliver honest, tough risk assessments, according to Foreign Policy.

Bob woodward is scared as hell
Photo: khanlist.com

Woodward observes that presidents rarely receive the straight story from their advisors, noting only a few notable exceptions such as Brent Scowcroft, national security advisor to President George H.W. Bush, and Colin Powell, the first secretary of state under George W. Bush. Drawing on a half century of observation, Woodward writes that a president must actively find ways to puncture the treacherous curtain of deference surrounding the Oval Office.

“I have seen clearly over a half century of reporting on 11 presidents how crucial it is that a president understand that part of their job is to find ways to puncture the treacherous curtain of deference around them,” Woodward writes, as quoted by Foreign Policy.

“Others might call it Oval Office Freeze, not wanting to bring bad news to a president or framing something in a way that panders to their ego or worldview.” Woodward writes.

That deep dysfunction creates a direct throughline from Lyndon Johnson in Vietnam—who was ill-served by Defense Secretary Robert McNamara and senior military officials—to George W. Bush, who was persuaded to invade Iraq by Vice President Dick Cheney, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, and CIA Director George Tenet.

Foreign Policy reported that the current conflict with Iran under President Donald Trump is only the latest example of high-level governmental ineptitude, resulting in unnecessary loss of life and a decline in American prestige.

Trump launched “a destructive and bloody war with no legal authority,” Woodward writes, pointing out that his impulsive decision highlights the extreme danger of operating without advisors willing to ask hard questions about the consequences. Adding to that ego-driven impulse, modern warfare has become much more dangerous as AI-driven autonomous systems take over command and control networks, forcing leaders to make life-or-death decisions in minutes or seconds.

At age 83, Woodward admits he feels deeply unsettled by the vulnerability of nuclear procedures, recalling his early days in the mid-1960s as a 22-year-old Navy ensign on a communications ship when he realized how easily authentication codes could be accessed.

He later revisited those chilling realizations through extensive interviews with McNamara before the former defense secretary died in 2009, during which an anguished McNamara confessed that he failed to demand rigorous debate over the loose assumptions underlying Vietnam strategy.

Woodward, born in 1943 in Geneva, Illinois, served five years in the Navy after Yale, including duty as a communications officer aboard the USS Wright. There he was one of two officers assigned to handle nuclear launch codes carried in the ship’s role as a National Emergency Command Post Afloat.

He joined The Washington Post in 1971 and, with Carl Bernstein, broke the Watergate story that led to President Richard Nixon’s resignation. Since 1974 he has written 24 books on American politics, 14 of which reached No. 1 on best-seller lists.

“You could never control a nuclear war,” McNamara told Woodward.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Greece Braces for First Major Cold Snap Nov 22-23 as Warm Spell Ends

Milei Backs Open Trade at Tesla Argentina Launch Event