France Beat South Africa After Disallowed Arendse Try

South Africa’s 21-19 defeat to France in the Nations Championship on Friday night has ignited a debate over officiating consistency, specifically regarding a disallowed Kurt-Lee Arendse try.

Former Wallabies coach Ewen McKenzie argues the officials were inconsistent when they disallowed the score, ending the visitors’ first-half momentum.

The incident occurred just before the interval, with Arendse crossing the line only for the score to be scrubbed for an offside infringement. The Springboks, trailing 21-7 at the break, mounted a second-half resurgence through Cobus Reinach and Malcolm Marx but ultimately fell short when Manie Libbok missed a critical conversion. The result marks France’s first victory over the world champions since 2022.

Libbok Misses Conversion as France Asserts Dominance

  • Manie Libbok (Flyhalf): The missed conversion left the Boks two points short of a draw against France ahead of their next clash against Ireland.
  • France (Team): The victory over the world champions signals their status as one of the top teams in the world capable of competing with the best.

Officiating and the 10-Meter Threshold

Appearing on the Rugby Unity podcast alongside former All Blacks coach Steve Hansen, McKenzie argued that match referees should have intervened earlier following a throw to the back of the lineout by South Africa in the opening stages. He said that the officials were inconsistent when they disallowed the score.

Unbelievable ending | France v South Africa | Nations Championship 2026 — World Rugby

“I wrote in my notes: offside in attack. And sure enough, later on when they scored the try, it got taken back,” he said. Pointing to an earlier unpenalized infringement, he maintained that the refereeing crew missed an opportunity when South Africa utilized the same tactic earlier in the match without repercussion.

“For me, they had to sort it out at the start of the game, because they’d already thrown over the back once and got away with it,” he added.

“You can’t go into the 10m space until the ball has crossed the 15m line. It was obvious on the first one. When the second one comes up and the try is disallowed, everyone moans about it.” He added: “I’m not blaming South Africa, but they used it three times and suffered once, and that was the time they scored the try.”

Insane clash | France v South Africa | Nations Championship 2026 — World Rugby

France Wins Through Set-Piece Physicality and Clinical Backs

While the offside call dominated the post-match discourse, the broader tactical battle remained tight. France’s ability to maintain a physical edge in the set-piece and maximize their halfback distribution proved the difference in a game decided by two points. Hansen praised the winners.

“We keep mentioning South Africa and New Zealand, but France have always been capable of being one of those top one, two, three teams in the world,” Hansen said. He highlighted their forward pack’s physicality and the clinical nature of their backs, who capitalized on limited opportunities.

How the Game Was Won | France vs South Africa — Eggchasers Rugby

The Springboks’ second-half adjustments—shifting to a more direct, carry-heavy approach—nearly secured a draw. Had Libbok’s conversion found its mark, the match would have ended in a stalemate. Both analysts agreed that a draw would have been a fair reflection of the intensity displayed by both squads.

Metric France South Africa
Final Score 21 19
Half-Time Score 21 7

Looking Toward the Ireland Fixture

The focus for the Springboks now shifts to Dublin, where they face Ireland this coming Saturday. The Nations Championship, which concludes next weekend, remains the primary objective for the squad as they look to integrate lessons from the French encounter.

France 21–19 Springboks: No Excuses South Africa Wasted Their Chances as France Delivered — RugbyFanatic

The French victory shows how narrow the margins are between top-tier nations. Hansen says the French squad’s development into a perennial contender forces rivals to account for their physical set-piece and skilled backline in every tactical session.

Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.

Photo of author

Luis Mendoza - Sport Editor

Senior Editor, Sport Luis is a respected sports journalist with several national writing awards. He covers major leagues, global tournaments, and athlete profiles, blending analysis with captivating storytelling.

Lecanemab and Donanemab: First Alzheimer’s Drugs to Slow Disease