Whitehall expected the video gone. Google declined. The UK government asked YouTube’s owner to take down a message from jailed Russell Brand insisting he is innocent, and the company refused, BBC News reported on Wednesday.
The Prison Service of England and Wales filed the formal request through an established channel it keeps with technology companies, arguing the video offended Brand’s victims. Google’s answer, according to BBC News sources: its rules had not been broken.
Brand, 51, is serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence after being convicted at Southwark crown court of rape and three counts of sexual assault. On Sunday, his wife Laura Brand read a message from him on the couple’s YouTube channel. The video, and the account that carries it, remain live.
The refusal matters because it hands the government a rebuff on its own turf. A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said “it was only right” to ask for content that was “distressing for victims” to be removed, adding that while “removal ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms,” the department strongly believes “YouTube should remove this content.”

Meta moved faster than Google. Last week, after the conviction, the company disabled Brand’s profiles on Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp. YouTube, by contrast, has only barred the couple’s channels from earning advertising money — a punishment it imposed back in 2023 under its “creator responsibility policy,” shortly after allegations of rape and sexual assaults between 2006 and 2013 surfaced in a joint investigation by The Times, the Sunday Times and Channel 4’s Dispatches.
A meeting that wasn’t
The ground shifted beneath the story as the week went on. Sky News reported that a justice minister met representatives of Google to ask for the request. BBC News later reported the Ministry of Justice clarified that no minister met Google, and that the request focused on the single video, sent through the prison service’s established mechanism with tech companies.
The government asked, Google said no. Google has not commented publicly.
Inside the walls, a rules inquiry
The video triggered a separate problem for Brand: a Ministry of Justice investigation into whether he broke prison rules by getting the message out. Prisoners may protest their innocence, so no crime was committed.
But convicts are barred from making statements that distress victims, and media contact is permitted only in exceptional circumstances. Under the rules, an inmate is considered in breach if they pass remarks to a relative knowing those remarks are destined for publication.
The stakes of that inquiry are concrete. Sanctions range from an extension of his sentence to loss of privileges, such as limited phone access.
Downing Street called the message “clearly appalling,” adding: “Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims, and speaking to the media is only permitted in exceptional circumstances.”

The platforms, divided
“I just felt for those women that stood trial and everything they went through,” Mia Latter told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme this week.
Latter, 37, has alleged Brand raped her when she was 16. She was not a complainant in his criminal trial, and he denies her claims. Hearing the message read out on the couple’s Sunday Service show left her, she said, “upsetting,” and she was appalled to hear “this Christian message alongside absolute lies.” In recent years Brand has positioned himself as a Christian influencer, and has a large following.
The broadcast of the message itself drew a political rebuke. On Wednesday, Education Secretary Lucy Powell took broadcasters to task for “amplifying” Brand’s words, telling LBC they should not have “transmitted” that.

Who decides what stays up?
The episode lands in an old argument with new urgency: when a state asks a platform to remove lawful speech, the platform’s own terms are the only referee. The Ministry of Justice itself conceded that point. Google applied its terms and found them satisfied. described Brand as “someone who’s not showing a jot of remorse, a jot of any sensitivity at all to their victims.”
The contrast is hard to miss. Meta pulled Brand’s accounts outright within days of the conviction. Google, holding the platform where the message actually circulated, judged that no line had been crossed — leaving the government to complain from the sidelines while the video plays on.

Who decides what stays up?
The episode lands in an old argument with new urgency: when a state asks a platform to remove lawful speech, the platform’s own terms are the only referee. The Ministry of Justice itself conceded that point. Google applied its terms and found them satisfied. Between the two sits the victims, whom Latter says watched the message spread before any institution could act.
For now, the facts stand as the sources leave them: the request was declined, the inquiry into Brand’s prison conduct continues, and the account — with the video still on it — remains active.
Laura Gallacher, as The Independent identifies Brand’s wife, read her husband’s words on Sunday. Five days later, those words are still up.