Three UN member states are holding up the funding of the world’s leading climate science body, and the standoff surfaced publicly on Tuesday at the COP31 summit in Antalya, Turkey, where veteran diplomats warned that future climate agreements could lose their scientific footing.
Laurence Tubiana, a veteran French climate diplomat and one of the architects of the 2015 Paris climate agreement, told Inside Climate News that the science guiding negotiators at COP31 is “under a serious and highly politicized attack.” Her target: Russia, Saudi Arabia and India, which scientists on the panel and independent observers say are blocking progress on future reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
Those countries “are doing everything they can to slow the process,” Tubiana said, as reported by Inside Climate News. The panel, which relies on voluntary donations from member countries, has yet to set a budget for next year. That could delay a scientific report needed ahead of the next UN climate conference.
The numbers explain why that delay matters: the IPCC's assessments drive the steps required under the Paris Agreement, and fossil fuels account for an estimated 80 percent to 90 percent of planet-heating carbon dioxide emissions, according to the IPCC's 2023 assessment. Without a budget, there is no updated assessment.
IPCC Faces Budget Shortfall Delaying Next Climate Report
- The IPCC has no budget for next year, which could delay the scientific report due before the next UN climate conference.
- Russia and Saudi Arabia, both major fossil fuel producers, and India, at an estimated 14 percent of global coal consumption, are the three countries named as blocking progress.
- Diplomats tie the obstruction to the COP28 agreement in Dubai to transition away from coal, oil and gas, and to eroding oil and gas dominance in transport.
Three Governments, One Budget Blocked
The three countries named by scientists on the panel and independent observers, as Inside Climate News reported, occupy different positions in the energy economy but share one interest: slowing machinery that documents the cost of fossil fuels.

| Country | Stated role in the stalemate | Energy profile per sources |
|---|---|---|
| Russia | Blocking progress on future IPCC reports | Major fossil fuel producer |
| Saudi Arabia | Blocking progress on future IPCC reports | Major fossil fuel producer |
| India | Blocking progress on future IPCC reports | Estimated 14 percent of global coal consumption |
Tubiana said the three are becoming less discreet about their efforts. She linked the shift to the conditional agreement reached at COP28, the 2023 Conference of the Parties conference in Dubai to transition away from coal, oil and gas — a deal they increasingly view as a threat to their economies.
Tubiana said oil and gas companies are losing ground in transport as electric-vehicle adoption in Asia surges faster than expected, and she pointed to reports from the International Energy Agency showing that demand for fossil fuels is set to slow.
“Investors hear the message that the decline is coming, and those governments have pushed back,” she said.
From 1988 to a Budget Impasse
The panel now under pressure was established in 1988 to inform international climate negotiations. Since then it has regularly assessed thousands of studies on rising temperatures, sea level rise, melting ice and strategies for adapting to increasingly intense impacts of global warming.
The pressure campaign has a recent documented history, too. Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland and former United Nations special envoy on climate change, said this is not the first time countries have tried to obstruct science. She cited attacks seeking to undermine a recent United Nations Environment Programme report on “overshoot,” which concludes there is no way to avoid passing the 2.7 degree Fahrenheit warming target in the Paris Agreement.
Tubiana dated the escalation in her own telling to the war in Ukraine.
“Since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the oil and gas sector has become much more aggressive,” she said. “I think this is partly because it sees its dominance over energy starting to erode.”
She added that a growing number of countries view the transition away from fossil fuels as a path to greater energy independence and security, while opponents of the shift are becoming “more angry and vocal.”
The Risk of Carrying Other Capitals Along
The danger, in Tubiana’s words, “is that they take other countries along with them that aren’t necessarily committed to that position.” For negotiators, that turns a three-country blocking effort into a broader coalition risk.
The latest draft of the conference's decision document stresses the importance of the IPCC assessments to the negotiations, according to Inside Climate News. Some countries also want language in that document that could help break the science panel’s deadlock. The same countries stalling the IPCC are resisting that effort.
Bill Hare, CEO of Climate Analytics, an international climate science and policy institute, said the climate, environment and energy ministers participating in the current round of talks could help the IPCC get over its political hurdles by advocating for continued support for the panel.
“If the panel can’t deliver the needed climate science because of political obstacles created by a small number of countries, it would be a historic setback for the connection between science and the international climate process,” Hare said.
Who Pays When the Science Stops
Some of the world’s least developed countries and small island states “desperately need” the panel’s reports because they cannot do their own climate assessments, she said.
Those reports have guided the climate process from the beginning, she added, and their absence would fall hardest on the delegations with the smallest research budgets of their own. Robinson also called the moment telling: “It’s just a sign of the difficult times we’re in that we have to fight for it. I can hardly believe it.”
What remains unresolved is the panel’s budget itself. Until ministers at COP31 move on it, the report due ahead of next year’s UN climate conference stays on hold — and the question of whether the three governments will relent has not been answered.
- China Scraps Tariffs; Africa Trade Deficit Jumps 34% to $80bn
- Air NZ Accused of Misleading Passengers About Compensation Rights – NZ Herald
- SAMI and L3Harris Manufacture Military Radio Systems in Saudi Arabia (time.news)
- California Announces New Homekey+ Projects and Funding to Address Homelessness and Veteran Housing (newsdirectory3.com)