More than 540 Google employees and contractors signed a petition on Thursday demanding the company let K-12 schools use Search without its AI features, the Alphabet Workers Union said, as three of America’s largest school districts weigh dropping Google products.
The petition, titled “Let Students Search,” is addressed to CEO Sundar Pichai, head of Search Elizabeth Reid, and education chief Chris Phillips. The union’s letter circulated as Google faces a genuine commercial threat, with workers warning that schools that refuse AI could end up shutting out Google products altogether.
At stake is Google’s grip on US classrooms. Its Chrome operating system ran on 58% of laptops and tablets shipped to US schools last year, per Futuresource Consulting data cited by Bloomberg — and Chromebooks stop receiving updates in 2034, a migration clock that is already ticking.

“The decision of how and when to implement AI into a classroom belongs to the educators leading it, not the executives who stand to profit from its expanded use,” said Parul Koul, the union president and a software engineer at Google.
Why Search and AI can’t be split
The fight stems from a policy Google outlined earlier this month: Gemini and Search will be switched off by default for K-12 student accounts, and schools must opt in. The catch, Gizmodo reported, is that AI Overviews and AI Mode are baked into the Search experience itself.
A school that bans generative AI but re-enables Search gets the AI anyway — so a district that wants zero AI has to go without Google Search entirely, leaving students staring at a message that the service is unavailable.
Phillips told the New York Times that “Search and AI are deeply integrated.” On X, Google offered a clarification, saying the initiative taking effect early next year would let schools toggle Search, Gemini and Gemini Notebook independently.
What it has not explained is how to strip AI Overviews and AI Mode out of Search itself — the union’s core demand. The workers are asking leadership to “allow schools to turn off AI features in Search without disrupting their ability to use search as a whole,” per the petition.
The backlash that triggered the letter
The pressure campaign began after a New York Times report earlier this month revealed the restriction policy. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani accused Google of “trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools,” and parents, students and teachers protested outside Google’s Chicago office.
NYC is the nation’s largest school district, and it is among the jurisdictions that have enacted bans or moratoriums on student-facing generative AI.
Senator Ed Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat, wrote to Alphabet on November 9 asking whether schools could keep Search with the AI switched off, citing the family lawsuit — a North Carolina couple’s claim, filed earlier this month, that their 13-year-old daughter used Gemini and Search’s AI features on a school-issued Chromebook before a suicide attempt.
The suit alleges that “every time a student used their Chromebook to run a Google search, Gemini-powered AI features could be triggered.” Google said it is reviewing the allegations. In July, Common Sense Media had already called Google’s AI Search an “unacceptable risk” for students.
A strategic pickle for Google
The union’s letter frames the risk in blunt commercial terms, warning the policy will more likely result in schools “shutting out Google products altogether” and arguing the reputational damage could threaten the job stability of the workers who build and support these products.
“Decisions like this erode the trust schools place in Google, and that lands on the workers who build and support these products,” said Rob Rose, a union member and software engineer on Google’s Education team.
Leaving isn’t easy, though. Dan Carroll, co-founder of edtech startup Clever, told Bloomberg that Chromebooks are built around Google’s software ecosystem and that moving teachers and students to another search engine costs time and money.
He described Google’s bind succinctly: “Either Google listens to schools and gives students a version of search that’s already feeling outdated compared to the market, or they alienate schools by requiring they use the new version.”
AI Overviews have been Google’s flagship selling point for months, the thing that keeps Search competitive against AI-native rivals. The same integration that differentiates the product in the consumer market makes it unsellable to districts under AI bans.
Google can’t ship Search without the AI without undercutting its own AI rollout narrative — and it can’t force the AI on schools without losing the 58% Chromebook install base that anchors its education business.
The Alphabet Workers Union, announced on January 4, 2021 with an initial membership of over 400 after more than a year of secret organizing, now counts over 800 members among Alphabet’s roughly 130,000 employees. It is a minority or solidarity union that includes full-time employees as well as temporary workers, vendors and contractors, and it is not registered with the National Labor Relations Board, so it cannot engage in collective bargaining.
In February 2023, contractors moderating content for YouTube Music staged Google’s first strike, and in March 2022 subcontractors of Google Fiber became the first members within the union to gain NLRB recognition.
The union did push back on one piece of the framing. It said the reporting around the decision has been “poor” and makes Google look like it is “punishing schools for not using AI” — while simultaneously asking Pichai to change the policy.