A teenage Haymitch Abernathy picks up Woody Harrelson’s old bottle in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the sixth film in the franchise, and critics cannot agree whether the result is a return to form or a franchise on autopilot.
The Guardian handed it one star and called it a “surreally awful prequel”; Time Out gave it four and ranked it among the series’ best. It opens in Australia on Thursday, then in the US and UK on Friday.
The surprise: a major studio release rarely draws such polarized reviews. The BBC’s roundup of the response found the film dismissed as “a tortuous, costly mess” by some critics and praised as “surprisingly strong” and “one of the best films in the series” by others. That split matters commercially, because word of mouth in opening week will decide whether Lionsgate’s return to Panem becomes an event or an afterthought.
Critics split on Haymitch casting as box office test looms
- The reviews are violently split — one star in the Guardian, four stars in Time Out, with little middle ground.
- The common complaint across both camps: Joseph Zada’s young Haymitch lacks the gravitational pull Jennifer Lawrence gave the originals.
- The stakes: a Friday release in the US and UK means the verdict at the box office arrives within days of the critics’ verdict.
What the Guardian saw on screen
The Guardian’s one-star review, published ahead of the release, called the film “overwrought and boring” and argued it “has no actual interest and no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase.”
The review sketches a film caught between two registers: a Steinbeck-style rustbelt depression for the ordinary folk of District 12, and a ruling class rendered as, in the paper’s words, a “bafflingly bizarre pantomime gallery of grotesques.”
That gallery includes Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle and Kieran Culkin as a smarmy young Caesar Flickerman, the TV presenter role once owned by Stanley Tucci. Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow — whom the Guardian’s critic describes as resembling George Washington — infuriated by 16-year-old Haymitch (Joseph Zada) after a gesture of defiance at the opening ceremony and an apparent conspiracy to destroy the Games with explosives.

The review also lands one structural jab: nobody in the film is ever actually shown watching the televised Games. Haymitch’s community has no TVs, and the middle-class audience supposedly glued to their sets is nowhere to be found. For a series built on the idea of spectacle as social control, that is a curious hole in the frame.
The other side of the aisle
But the math of the review aggregate tells a different story. The Wrap praised the film’s “memorable performances, intoxicating style and horrifying commentary,” adding: “When the dust settles it may even be the Hunger Games that holds up best.” The Hollywood Reporter went further, calling Zada’s performance a “star-making turn” and concluding the film is “a return, after the disappointing Songbirds and Snakes, to the spirit of the first movies.”
Time Out’s four-star review called it “as strong as any” of the other films and “certainly a major step up from 2023’s drab prequel The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.”
Where the critics do agree
Even the film’s defenders concede one thing: the center of the movie is missing. IndieWire found Zada “charming enough” but wrote that his character “lacks the gravitational charisma or arc that, say, Jennifer Lawrence brought to the original films.” The same review called the movie “a little bit like a cold cash grab rather than a necessary deepening of the series’ lore” and “a dreary slog.”
The New York Times reached for the same word — “slog” — and put the Lawrence gap even more bluntly: “One really misses the guiding presence of Jennifer Lawrence, who had the raw pathos to both ground and expand a world in a way many younger stars often can’t.”
In the Times’ reading, Jesse Plemons and Fiennes briefly elevate the film, and “seem to be trapped in this dystopia too.” Plemons plays a younger Plutarch Heavensbee, the role the late Philip Seymour Hoffman originated — the Guardian calls him marginally less caricatured than the pantomime grotesques around him.
Screen Daily split the difference, calling it an “underwhelming prequel” that “suffers from a lack of compelling characters” and “feels oddly incidental — a drab afterthought rather than a crucial new chapter.” One of the film’s own defenders, per the BBC’s roundup, put it nearly as harshly: “It can’t escape the sense of feeling supplementary. It’s an enjoyable-enough diversion, but essentially a footnote with aspirations.”
The verdicts, side by side
| Outlet | Rating | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| The Guardian | One star | “Overwrought and boring”; “surreally awful prequel” |
| Time Out | Four stars | “As strong as any” in the series |
| The Wrap | Positive | “May even be the Hunger Games that holds up best” |
| The Hollywood Reporter | Positive | A “star-making turn”; a return to the spirit of the first movies |
| IndieWire | Negative | “A cold cash grab”; “a dreary slog” |
| Screen Daily | Negative | “A drab afterthought rather than a crucial new chapter” |
Why the split matters this week
The timeline is unforgiving. The film opens in Australia on November 19 and in the US and UK on November 20 — within a day of this writing — so the critical civil war breaks out precisely as paying audiences decide whether to show up.
Set 24 years before the first Hunger Games film and 40 years after The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, it is the second prequel in four years, and the franchise’s own recent history is the yardstick every review reaches for.
The cast is doing its part to sell it: alongside Zada, Fiennes, Close, Culkin and Plemons, the film carries Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace and Maya Hawke, per the BBC’s report. That is a marquee roster deployed to compensate for a lead the critics say cannot carry the weight.
And the deeper question the reviews keep circling — why this film exists at all — is one the industry will be watching as closely as the fans. When a franchise’s own boosters call it “supplementary” and its detractors call it a cash grab, the box office this weekend becomes the tiebreaker.
The Guardian’s verdict on that point was the bluntest of all: the film has “no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase.”
The BBC’s full roundup of the review split is here; the Guardian’s one-star review is the source of its verdict.