Rafael Grossi needs nine “encourage” votes and zero vetoes. In the latest Security Council straw poll, the UN nuclear watchdog chief got nine — and four “discourage” votes that could sink him, Al Jazeera reported.
The 65-year-old Argentinian sits second behind Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan in the race to replace Secretary-General António Guterres, who leaves office on December 31 after 10 years. Eight candidates remain in the fray, and the council has met eight times behind closed doors since July 30 to assess them, according to Arab News.
“He transformed the technical watchdog into a highly visible, proactive, diplomatic actor,” Jan Wouters, professor of international law and international organisations at KU Leuven, told Al Jazeera.
That visibility cuts both ways. The same hands-on style that won Grossi admirers has earned him enemies with veto power — and the arithmetic of the race gives each of them a kill shot.
Nine votes, no vetoes allowed
The rules are unforgiving. Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the 193-member General Assembly appoints the secretary-general “upon the recommendation of the Security Council” — but in practice, the council decides, Arab News reported. A candidate needs at least nine of 15 votes and no veto from any of the five permanent members: China, France, Russia, the US and the UK.

Grossi’s nine “encourage” votes meet the threshold. The four “discourage” votes are the problem. A red vote is not necessarily fatal — Arab News noted that Kofi Annan faced repeated French opposition before winning the job — but a permanent member’s veto in a later, color-coded round would end the candidacy outright.
Beijing, according to the South China Morning Post as cited by Al Jazeera, has already ruled Grossi out as too close to Washington and would back Grynspan instead.
Russia, analysts told Al Jazeera, is unlikely to support a candidate so closely aligned with the US — and Grossi’s very active role has “angered” Moscow, which sees him as having overstepped his position as agency head, said Ezequiel Jimenez Martinez, adjunct professor at the Pompeu Fabra law faculty in Barcelona.
Grynspan, meanwhile, leads with 12 “encourage” and three “discourage” votes from the November 5 poll, according to PassBlue, the nonprofit news organisation cited by The News International. But she is not safe either: the US and Russia could veto her bid, that report suggested.

The nuclear file that follows him
Iran has been vocal in its opposition, despite holding no council seat. Tehran’s foreign ministry spokesman, Esmaeil Baghaei, accused the IAEA this month of being overly influenced by the US and European countries in its “one-sided and biased reporting about Iran’s peaceful nuclear programme,” Al Jazeera reported.
The agency estimated Iran held 440.9kg of uranium enriched to up to 60 percent before the June 2025 Israeli-US attacks on its nuclear facilities — while uranium must be enriched to 90 percent to become weapons-grade, the process becomes quick at 60 percent, according to the IAEA figures cited by Al Jazeera.
Jimenez Martinez expects Grossi to withstand the criticism. “The majority of governors of the [IAEA] agree with his approach on Iran,” he told Al Jazeera, adding that the UN context would likely produce “a bit of fireworks, but I don’t think it will change many votes.”
The Milei problem
Grossi’s bigger liability may be his friends. Argentinian President Javier Milei has called the UN “useless” and its diplomats “fatally arrogant parasites,” and reignited a longstanding dispute with the UK over the Falkland Islands, a British-administered territory over which Argentina claims sovereignty, Al Jazeera reported. The Trump administration has withdrawn Washington from key UN agencies, slashed funding and bypassed the body in launching the war on Iran in February.
.@Lana_Nusseibeh's interview at the @FT | «When asked about #Sudan, I made it clear it would be one of my most urgent priorities. "Judge me by my actions in my first 100 days." The fighting must stop. Humanitarian aid must reach those who need it. And we need a credible and… https://t.co/yaIdNz170P
Being seen as the frontman for both leaders could mean “in practice, a shrinking of the UN structure,” Jimenez Martinez told Al Jazeera — merging agencies and reorienting the body around security rather than development. Grossi’s call for leaders to have the “courage to reform” the institution has come without elaboration on safeguards, which is unlikely to win approval from the General Assembly, he argued.
Alvina Hoffmann, senior lecturer in diplomatic studies at SOAS University of London, told Al Jazeera that Grossi is seen as focused on “improving the system and cutting overlapping mandates, rather than addressing the structural drivers of inequality.” His taste for confidential negotiation, she added, “might come at the expense of being able to call out violations of international law at a time in which international law is increasingly under attack.”
A dark horse with baggage of her own
While Grossi fights vetoes, a late entrant has changed the calculus. The Guardian reported that UAE diplomat Lana Nusseibeh, who spent almost 11 years as her country’s UN representative, now has a high chance of replacing Guterres — and diplomatic and humanitarian sources cited by Middle East Eye believe she has the backing of all five permanent members.

Her candidacy is contested. The Guardian’s Steve Bloomfield argued Britain should veto her, and 66 British MPs from across the political spectrum have urged the government to do so, Middle East Eye reported. They point to UN panel of experts findings describing as “credible” allegations that the UAE armed the RSF in Sudan — findings Nusseibeh has disputed.
“There’s nobody who doesn’t come from somewhere,” she told the Financial Times, when asked how she could uphold international humanitarian law after representing a government accused of violating it.
A UK government spokesperson, cited by Middle East Eye on November 6, said only: “Our focus is on the merit of the candidates to secure the most qualified candidate for the next UN secretary general.”
Racing the December 31 clock
History suggests the council can cut it fine. Egypt’s Boutros-Ghali was recommended on November 21, 1991, Arab News reported. In 1996, the US vetoed Boutros-Ghali’s second term — the only time a serving secretary-general has been denied one — and Annan was not chosen until December 13. Javier Pérez de Cuéllar was selected on December 11, 1981, less than three weeks before taking office.
Five of the eight contenders are women, and civil society pressure to elect the first female secretary-general in the UN’s 81-year history is at an all-time high, Al Jazeera reported. Grynspan ticks both the regional rotation and gender boxes.
“The United Nations has existed for 80 years without ever appointing a woman as secretary-general,” Ben Donaldson, adviser to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign, told Al Jazeera. “This persistent imbalance stands in contrast to the organisation’s own commitments to equality, parity and nondiscrimination.”
If no decision comes by January 1, 2027 — the day Guterres’s successor is expected to take office, The News International reported — member states could appoint an interim chief. That would require the same procedure all over again: a Security Council recommendation, then General Assembly approval.
Keep reading
- US War Secretary Hegseth to Meet Colombia Minister, Hand Over First C-130 Hércules
- Registration Opens for 2027 SBN Women’s Leadership Forum in New Orleans
- South Korea Overhauls Suneung Security After AI Cheating Confession (archyworldys.com)
- 3.6% for Social Security, 2.6% for FERS, and a Bill Still Pending for VA (daybreakwire.com)