Indie Devs Bundle Identical Game Titles, Skip Trademark War

Indie developers No More Robots and Neon Polygons transcended trademark conflict by co-publishing the identical title, Piece by Piece, across Steam and the Nintendo Switch.

What started as a potential legal dispute over identical IP found a collaborative, business-forward resolution, demonstrating a rare instance of creative risk mitigation in the crowded digital storefront ecosystem.

The reality of intellectual property (IP) management in the modern gaming industry is often a landscape fraught with trademark contention. When games share a term—whether it’s a generic word like “wasteland” or a specific brand—the potential for legal action is high. Techdirt reported that disputes over similarly named titles are not uncommon, usually centering on whether the public would associate the products with a single source.

However, this specific case transcended typical legal sparring. It involved two entirely separate projects, both titled Piece by Piece.

In March, No More Robots released their Piece by Piece title on Steam, which is described as a cozy sim featuring cute animal characters. Two days later, Neon Polygons launched their own unrelated puzzle-platform game of the identical name.

This close proximity immediately triggered an alert for No More Robots co-founder Mike Rose.

The initial concern was purely defensive. Rose received correspondence from Neon Polygons suggesting that No More Robots might pursue legal action to protect their IP. This is the standard playbook for IP protectionism in a high-velocity market.

The Decision to Prioritize Collaboration Over IP Maximalism

The decision not to engage in a costly legal or USPTO dispute was an anomaly. While IP rights are the lifeblood of a developer’s investment, the two teams chose a path of pragmatic cooperation.

“I got back to them and said ‘Well, that’s just hilarious. Do you wanna bundle up on Steam? I did it partially because it was a nice / fun thing to do, but I also kinda did it because I love chaos,’” Rose told Techdirt.

This move transformed a potential legal confrontation into a unique business opportunity. By bundling the games on Steam, the developers used the confusion of the identical title—a risk they would have reduced through defensive litigation—as a joint sales strategy.

Handling Ecosystem Friction at Nintendo

The collaboration extended beyond the PC storefront. The two developers decided to bring both titles to the Nintendo Switch, but this decision created significant friction with the platform holder.

Gamespot.com detailed that No More Robots was publishing the Switch ports for both titles. However, this created a logistical and branding nightmare for Nintendo. According to Gamespot.com, Nintendo’s internal teams had to be repeatedly informed of the situation.

“We had to explain over and over again, to each separate Nintendo organization (Europe, Japan, America), that ‘No, sorry but those are two separate games. Yes, they have the same name. Yes, they have the same release date. Yes, we are very sorry. We promise we won’t do this again,’” Rose told Techdirt.

The complexity wasn’t just about the name; it was about the metadata and the eShop backend. Launching two distinct games with identical identifiers on a closed ecosystem like the Nintendo Switch requires a level of communication and coordination that even major third-party publishers find challenging.

The contrast in approaches is evident when comparing the initial legal risk to the subsequent platform logistics. While the developers proactively managed the IP conflict on Steam by bundling the titles for maximum visibility, they encountered “a nightmare on the backend of the Nintendo eShop,” as Gamespot.com noted regarding the effort required to reconcile the dual releases.

The Impact on Third-Party Development Strategy

This incident offers a compelling, albeit niche, case study in the tension between brand identity protection and collaborative business models in the digital distribution space. In an era where developers rely increasingly on platform gatekeepers—be it Steam’s storefront logic or Nintendo’s proprietary distribution channels—the ability to manage brand confusion is critical.

The successful coordination of these two separate entities provides a glimpse into a future where “humanity over IP maximalism” might become a viable, even desirable, business pivot for smaller studios.

It’s a move that trades the certain revenue of a single, clean brand identity for the unpredictable, but potentially larger, reach of a shared market position.

This willingness to embrace chaos and collaboration is what makes the story noteworthy.

The joint strategy was set to launch on November 25, 2026, across the Nintendo Switch platform, offering both Piece by Piece titles to consumers under the same publishing umbrella.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Instagram Enables Content Protection for Creators, Tests AI Copy Detection