International Team Finds NV Centers Regain Electrons via Quantum Tunneling

A diamond defect loses its electron mid-task and goes dark. A new study now shows exactly how the defect gets that electron back: not through heat, but through quantum tunneling — a quantum effect that lets a particle slip straight through an energy barrier it should never be able to cross.

An international research team reported in Physical Review Letters this week that nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond — defects used as qubits and magnetic sensors — regain their lost working electrons through direct quantum tunneling from neighboring nitrogen atoms, with recovery times stretching from nanoseconds to hours depending on distance.

The team, made up of researchers from Germany, Lithuania and the United States, combined quantum-mechanical simulations with optical measurements to pin down a charge-transfer pathway that had been suggested before but never actually worked out or proved.

Why the electron can’t just walk over

An NV center is a nitrogen atom sitting next to an empty spot in diamond’s carbon lattice. It only works as a qubit or sensor while it holds one extra electron, which it must borrow from another defect in the crystal. And it often loses that electron during laser readout.

In ordinary semiconductors, room-temperature heat is enough to knock a trapped charge loose so it can wander through the crystal and get recaptured elsewhere. Nitrogen in diamond is different: it holds its electrons so tightly that no amount of ambient heat frees them.

International Team Finds NV Centers Regain Electrons via Quantum Tunneling
Photo: miragenews.com

That left a puzzle — if heat can’t hand the electron over, what can?

The simulations answered it. The electron tunnels directly from the nitrogen atom through the energy barrier binding it, something classical physics forbids. But tunneling alone isn’t enough: the jump releases a burst of energy that something must absorb, or it cannot happen.

The nitrogen itself turns out to be the absorber. When it donates its electron, a broken bond with a neighboring carbon atom reforms, and the released energy flows into vibrations of the crystal lattice.

“When the electron tunnels, it releases a large quantity of energy and the nitrogen atom turns out to be remarkably efficient at absorbing that particular amount,” said the head of the Electronic Structure Theory Laboratory at the Center for Physical Sciences and Technology (FTMC) in Vilnius, who performed the simulations with a colleague at FTMC and a distinguished professor in the Materials Department at UC Santa Barbara.

Counting recovery from nanoseconds to hours

Tunneling probability falls off sharply with distance, and that made the experiment hard. A nitrogen donor within two nanometers — about a dozen atomic spacings — refills an adjacent NV center in a few nanoseconds. Beyond five nanometers, the process stretches to hours or longer.

Standard optical measurements stop disclosing data after a few nanoseconds. To bridge that gap, a researcher at the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research designed a two-laser setup: a pulsed red laser ejects electrons from the NV centers, while a weak continuous beam passing through the diamond tracks their optical absorption as charge returns. The measurement spans nine orders of magnitude in time, from nanoseconds up to seconds.

“Most time-resolved optical studies of these centers stop a few nanoseconds after the laser pulse,” that researcher said. “Following the signal from nanoseconds to seconds lets us separate the fast relaxation inside the NV center from the slow return of the charge, and that slow part is the tunneling.”

The tests confirmed the tunneling model from two directions. Diamonds rich in nitrogen recovered much faster, since donors sit closer to the defects. Temperature, meanwhile, did nothing: heating the crystals from near absolute zero to room temperature left recovery rates unchanged, which rules out any heat-assisted mechanism.

In the report published Wednesday, the same pattern shows up in numbers. In nitrogen-rich diamonds nearly all centers recharge within a fraction of a second. In ultra-pure diamond with one nitrogen atom per million carbon atoms, most centers are still uncharged an hour later.

What it means for quantum devices

An NV center that is waiting for its electron is out of action, and unpredictable recharge delays of that kind undermine reliable operation of quantum computers and magnetic sensors. These include sensors sensitive enough to detect weak magnetic fields inside living cells and microchips. Knowing the exact distance-to-time dynamics gives engineers a lever: placing nitrogen or other impurity atoms deliberately should help stabilize the qubits.

The researchers see the finding reaching past diamond.

Diamond is the case we could measure, but the question is much bigger than one defect in one material. Defects that hold their electrons tightly are everywhere: in the phosphors that make LEDs glow, in the crystals that detect radiation, in the insulating layers of electronic chips. Wherever such defects trade electrons without the help of heat, this is the mechanism to look at, and it helps us predict what the textbook picture simply could not.

A distinguished professor in the Materials Department at UC Santa Barbara, in the study announcement

Funding sources and author dedication acknowledged

Funding came from the Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, through the Co-design Center for Quantum Advantage (C2QA), along with the Max Planck Society, the Lithuanian Research Council and the European Union. The paper carries a dedication: its co-author from FTMC, who initiated the theoretical framework, died before the work was completed.

The theoretical model that explains the data — nitrogen as the ideal energy absorber, built into the very lattice it sits in — was finished and tested without its originator ever seeing it in print.

Earlier coverage: New Computational Method Accelerates Discovery of Diamond Qubits for Quantum Computing

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

French Pupils’ French Skills Slip Again, Math Holds Steady in National Assessments